Follow TV Tropes

Discussion FanficRecs / PuellaMagiMadokaMagica

Go To

Aug 2nd 2016 at 5:51:24 PM •••

The Berserk x Madoka fan comic "I've Managed to Save Mami-san" and its sequel are both on Tumblr. Should the Danbooru links be replaced with those, since Danbooru is NSFW?

Dec 21st 2014 at 6:49:39 AM •••

Uhh... Say, my two recommendations got deleted. It's Titles are "Puella Magi Adfligo Systema" and "Meow Quest." Any Reason why it got deleted? Is it not good enough?

Hide/Show Replies
Dec 21st 2014 at 9:29:10 AM •••

Someone named Carinthium removed them. I think you ought to readd them and message them.

Dec 21st 2014 at 10:03:24 PM •••

How can I do that when I don't remember what I wrote?

Edited by
Dec 22nd 2014 at 6:57:44 AM •••

Click on the "history" button on the top bar.

Dec 29th 2014 at 10:34:06 PM •••

Brotip: Carinthium is a site user. He has been suspended or banned from various parts of the site no less than five times by my count. If he comes back, please edit out anything he has to say; his definition of "holding the Idiot Ball" is "not listening to my 'rationalist' ranting for thirty pages."

Dec 30th 2014 at 1:35:31 AM •••

Actually, no, they haven't been suspended ever and there is no evidence of socking, either. Perhaps you are thinking of a different account name.

Jan 12th 2015 at 10:08:33 PM •••

Sorry, sir. I meant the site where the Quest in question is being held, Sufficient Velocity. Not TV Tropes. He is indeed currently being suspended from that site.

Edited by A.vonZiggurat
Jan 13th 2015 at 1:38:52 AM •••

They have now been suspended from here as well, for the record.

Jan 22nd 2015 at 9:19:40 AM •••

Is it possible that now he's socking? When someone named Planner497 does the exact same thing only days after he was suspended; it doesn't seem like a coincidence.

Jan 22nd 2015 at 11:14:01 AM •••

No evidence they are the same person. They are edit warring though, so they are banned anyhow.

Aug 8th 2013 at 8:52:33 AM •••

Is anyone else having an issue with the formatting? To me, every entry after the first one appears to be boxed, and it'svisually interfering.

Apr 10th 2013 at 10:12:04 AM •••

Sorry I put my referral for One More Arrow between folders, I'm new at HTML. I really think this story merits being here. It has a sparse elegance to the text that I could never imitate but one day hope to match for overall quailty :) Someone please fix and tell me what I did wrong?

Hide/Show Replies
Telcontar MOD
Apr 10th 2013 at 10:31:25 AM •••

Welcome to TVT, and thanks for adding to the page! You may want to take a look at the Text Formatting Rules to learn about how folders work in the future. The problem was that the recommendation was placed in between the [[/folder]] tag for the General Fics folder and the [[folder:Shipping Fics]] line, which begins that folder. This meant it was after one and before the other, so it wasn't included in either. Does that make sense?

To fix it, one just moves the rec above the [[/folder]] marker (assuming that it's a General Fic rather than a shipping one). This means it is now included in that folder rather than being stuck between them. I've done this for you, so it's fine now. May it point many people towards the story.

Edited by Telcontar
Feb 17th 2013 at 10:16:31 PM •••

Hey, my rec got zapped, anyone care to tell me why? It was for a quest called Magical Noir Quest, here's what I linked to:

Was the formatting the problem? I'm brand new, so if I made a mistake, I apologize. But I do feel a bit wronged.

Jan 8th 2013 at 11:37:33 AM •••

Er, alphabetised the folders. Realised belatedly there's apparently no way to revert edits here, so I hope no one minds. The history page would more quickly show recent additions than scrolling to the bottom of each folder but I'm not sure how that affects convenience.

Also removed the following for pedophilic content (lime scene between two fourteen year olds):

Persephone's Waltz by SailorPtah

  • Recommended by kay4today, Grand Prince Paul II
  • Pairings: Madoka/Sayaka so far.
  • Status: In-progress
  • Synopsis: The more times she fails to save Madoka, the more desperate Homura gets...until kidnapping her and locking her in a basement until Walpurgisnacht is over stops sounding like such a crazy idea.
  • Comments:
    • Well-written and quite suspenseful. SailorPtah is a very gifted writer and manages to write the characters' thought and interactions in a believable, not to mention entertaining, way. The circumstances around Madoka's kidnapping and her reaction captivated me and it gave me the feeling that this is what Homura might as well did in one particular timeline, and it contains one of the best written Sayaka's I've ever seen. I really recommend it.

Hide/Show Replies
Jan 16th 2013 at 9:41:53 AM •••

Technically, isn't pedophilia just between someone who is 16+ and someone who is younger? I don't see how it's pedophilia when the two characters are the same age - even if they are only 14. Not critiquing just confused.

Telcontar MOD
Jan 16th 2013 at 10:06:12 AM •••

Eh, the Content Policy specifies that fanfic recs for stories with sex involving those <16 aren't allowed. Whether it's technically paedophilia in every sense isn't really important, though I understand your confusion.

Edited by Telcontar
Jan 8th 2013 at 5:22:16 AM •••

so has anyone found a fanfic where the girls are living normally without magic and little to no shipping(or at least, "canon" pairs yet)?

Hide/Show Replies
Jan 8th 2013 at 10:44:53 AM •••

That's a quite specific and unusual request. Haven't seen anything like that myself, certainly.

Jan 9th 2013 at 4:05:31 AM •••

eh I dont really think so. basically, something like a good So L with the girls lives in general without magic and despair. the only one close that ive seen is the brand new day, and I feel that its littered too much of shipping scenes and then there's the fact madoka isnt there.

im kinda surprised there isnt a few, since well a lot of fans have wanted something like that.

Telcontar MOD
Jul 30th 2012 at 1:38:56 AM •••

These recs are unsigned. Feel free to put them back on the page, but make sure to put your handle next to them.

[1] by ねも

  • Crossing over with: Berserk again.
  • Synopsis: Every little girl's favorite aloof big brother figure helps Sayaka out.
  • Comments: Short and simple: Sayaka gets some sense talked into her. Oh, how I wish this wasn't a fanfic...

[2] by ねも

  • Crossing over with: Berserk. Seems like an obsession. But it is so cool...
  • Synopsis: Now it is Kyouko.

Jul 29th 2012 at 5:17:25 PM •••

Would it be alright to include an AMV or MAD if it manages to have an original plot, and not just serve as a glorified recap of events that have already transpired like most AM Vs tend to do?

Hide/Show Replies
Nov 16th 2012 at 12:18:18 PM •••

You mean like that Walpurgisnacht one? I see no reason why not. There are other rec pages that include them.

May 11th 2012 at 3:42:09 PM •••

Er, Moonlight Bomber? Pretty sure promoting your own fic is against the rules, bro.

Hide/Show Replies
Sep 27th 2011 at 6:55:06 PM •••

Does it seem to anyone else like Zipcode's disappeared? And if so, should we make a notation about that for his/her fics on this page?

Hide/Show Replies
Apr 6th 2012 at 11:58:26 AM •••

All of the Author recommendations appear to have mysteriously vanished... Huh. I'm sure that were all signed, so why would they have been zapped?

Sep 24th 2011 at 2:11:32 AM •••

Should mangas in japanese be in Fanfic recommendations?

Besides not being Fanfics, they are in Japanese, making them incapable of reading by 98% of the community.

Just seems odd

Hide/Show Replies
Sep 24th 2011 at 8:57:09 AM •••

They are amateur works of fiction based on a pre-existing setting. Thus, they are fanfiction.

Also, most of the doujinshi linked have some form of translation function.

Type the word in the image. This goes away if you get known.
If you can't read this one, hit reload for the page.
The next one might be easier to see.

How well does it match the trope?

Example of:


Media sources: