Amateur Veteran
Should we move Mudbriar and Terramar to the supporting cast pages, or should we wait until "Student Counsel" airs in English?
On a related note, should Mudbriar go on the Ponyville supporting cast page, the other supporting cast page, or the family members page?
Hide / Show Replies
Maybe we should wait until the episode airs.
Edited by SymBionicFan
Shouldn't Moondancer be moved to Supporting Cast – Other Locations? After all, she did make a speaking appearance in "The Point of No Return".
Hide / Show Replies
Pretty soon, Quibble Pants will have to be moved to Supporting Cast – Other Locations once "Common Bond" airs.
is correct moving the most famous background characters here? they have appeared since the first season.
Hide / Show Replies
They're in One-Shots (for now anyway) because Slice Of Life is the only episode so far where they've been treated as the main characters. Otherwise they're... background characters.
I'd rather not make things too complicated. If they make more appearances, then they'll be "promoted" to supporting cast and render the sub-folder moot. Anyway, their popularity in the fandom is irrelevant to their role in the actual narrative.
They're fine where they are for now.
Edited by PDL
Actually, Derpy basically sets off the plot in The Last Roundup as well. There's also her being part of the representative team in Rainbow Falls and Equestria Games. Definitely not a One Shot character. Besides, supporting characters don't have to be main characters at all. Considering Twist is in the Supporting Cast, Derpy should be moved there.
Edited by Xevon Natter Natter Natter Natter Natter Natter Natter Natter Natter Natter Natter Natter Natter Natter Natter Natter Natter Natter Natter
Derpy, DJ Pon-3 and Bulk Biceps have been moved a while ago.
I'm all for doing the same with Doctor Hooves, Octavia, Lyra and Bon-Bon. They're stretching the one-shot definition, methinks.
So there seems to be an edit war between listing Cheese Sandwich as a Spear Counterpart and listing him as a Distaff Counterpart.
Knock it off and pick one.
Hide / Show Replies
This is a Spear Counterpart entry. It should stay as such.
"For a successful technology, reality must take precedence over public relations, for Nature cannot be fooled." - Richard Feynman
As of "Rainbow Falls" Bulk Biceps seems to be an Ascended Extra. Is there anyone else who thinks he should be on the Supporting Cast
page instead of the One Shots page?
Depends on whether or not his appearance in Wonderbolt Academy counts as major role. I would say No, but if the rest of you thinks he belongs to the Recurring Cast it’s fine with me.
Not fine with me. His appearances before Rainbow Falls could have very easily been filled by any other character. Not to mention that he still falls under the guidelines of what makes a one-shot. He doesn't deserve to be promoted to Supporting Cast member yet and he's not going to get special treatment.
Edited by 99.232.247.129
My Name Is Not Durwood is no longer a trope. Which trope is this?
- My Name Is Not Doodle: This is not the name you're allowed to call him, unless you are Matilda.
Would Lighthoof and Shimmy Shake count as Ms. Fanservice? The two have very appealing designs, are rather touchy-feely with each other, and are cheerleaders who take some rather suggestive poses that derpibooru has run away with.