Follow TV Tropes

Discussion Characters / Catherine

Go To

lu127 MOD
Jul 6th 2012 at 8:13:28 AM •••

Pulled:

  • The White Prince: Pretty much everything in his life has been mapped out for him, so he tends to just go with what he's told.

The White Prince has been renamed and redefined as Sheltered Aristocrat. There is not enough context to tell if it fits here. See How To Write An Example.

May 14th 2012 at 10:28:48 AM •••

Erica: Gender Bender or Transsexual?

I make this discussion topic in light of a recent edit that claimed the former and not the latter. The edit reason by the user is given as follows:

"wrong trope: he became a woman out of desperation to save his own life, not out of any psychological compulsion to do so"

I say it's Transsexual. There's nothing to suggest the operation was done so Erica could save her own life, unless the user in question found dialogue or information that I hadn't yet.

If "save one's own life" refers to the nightmares, I... seriously doubt that. Erica herself is only aware of the rumor nature of the nightmares, not the truth behind them. To change one's biology for the sake of a rumor seems a bit off.

There WAS discussion with Erica about her disappearing at some time during her young life, but she said the rumors were unsubstantiated and that she was staying with a friend. Also, while the conclusion can be drawn that it was at this time in her life that she had the operation, there's no direct evidence.

I don't want to seem picky about this, but I've always thought it was nice to get a good transsexual character into video games and not have it be a big deal, and to have someone say it's not true is something I would contest.

Edited by CyricZ Hide/Show Replies
May 21st 2012 at 7:12:51 PM •••

It's pretty widely agreed she's transsexual.

The thing that gets me is, she has the nightmares too. So, is Atlus saying that she is not a 'real' woman? Or was it just a throwaway, meant as another hint?

May 22nd 2012 at 10:03:50 AM •••

Maybe it's just Dumuzid saying he doesn't think of her as a real woman. Let's not forget that for all his posturing, he's really not as omniscient about people as he believes he is.

Kn9
May 22nd 2012 at 10:10:32 AM •••

He's also an ancient Mesopotamian fertility god, he's probably not the most progressive guy around.

Type the word in the image. This goes away if you get known.
If you can't read this one, hit reload for the page.
The next one might be easier to see.
Top

How well does it match the trope?

Example of:

/

Media sources:

/

Report