Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion History Administrivia / PermanentRedLinkClub

Go To

Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
Took out this example. I\'m arguing my point here because it would take to much space on the history page.
to:
Took out the example below. I\\\'m arguing my point here because it would take to much space on the history page:
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
This trope also repeatedly comes up in the opposite direction when people \
to:
**This trope also repeatedly comes up in the opposite direction when people \\\"call out\\\" the Doctor for certain things. For example, Donna\\\'s calling out of the Doctor for exterminating the infant Racnoss was portrayed as a WhatTheHellHero moment...even though the alternative would have been for the Doctor to walk away and let the Racnoss babies consume the Earth, and the Racnoss queen had repeatedly turned down his offer to safely find them a new world that wouldn\\\'t involve wiping out a species. Also, Rose berates the Ninth Doctor for trying to kill the lone Dalek after it murdered several dozen security personnel and as far as the Doctor knew, was intent on continuing its path of destruction onto the Earth\\\'s surface. And that\\\'s not to get into all the people who are portrayed as having a point when they shame him for wiping out his species rather than acknowledging that the entire universe owes him for saving it even though he could have just [[AscendToAHigherPlaneOfExistence Ascended To A Higher Plane Of Existence]] with the rest of the Time Lords and left them to fry. The Doctor even does this to \\\'\\\'himself\\\'\\\' when he traps his clone in an alternate universe after the clone saves the universe by genociding all the Daleks for the fifth or so time (admittedly, this was just the excuse he gave so that Rose could be with the man she loved, but his reasoning still counts as this trope).

One by one:

1). Given the events of \\\"Turn Left\\\", I think Donna had a point in yelling at the Doctor that he should stop now. He literally would have permanently died otherwise. It\\\'s also been awhile since I\\\'ve seen the episode, but the Doctor doesn\\\'t look particularly remorseful when he kills the Racnoss. He looks like an angry god. Given the events that would take place in \\\"The Waters of Mars\\\", this is important.

2.). Rose berates the ninth Doctor for trying to kill the Dalek because she had already gotten it to stop killing. All it wanted at that point was to feel the sun.

3.) I\\\'m not sure which people this entry is referring to when it says \\\"people who shamed the Doctor for wiping out his people.\\\" Not too many people know about the events of the Time War.
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
Took out this example. I\'m arguing my point here because it would take to much space on the history page. One by one:
to:
Took out this example. I\\\'m arguing my point here because it would take to much space on the history page.
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
This trope also repeatedly comes up in the opposite direction when people \
to:
This trope also repeatedly comes up in the opposite direction when people \\\"call out\\\" the Doctor for certain things. For example, Donna\\\'s calling out of the Doctor for exterminating the infant Racnoss was portrayed as a WhatTheHellHero moment...even though the alternative would have been for the Doctor to walk away and let the Racnoss babies consume the Earth, and the Racnoss queen had repeatedly turned down his offer to safely find them a new world that wouldn\\\'t involve wiping out a species. Also, Rose berates the Ninth Doctor for trying to kill the lone Dalek after it murdered several dozen security personnel and as far as the Doctor knew, was intent on continuing its path of destruction onto the Earth\\\'s surface. And that\\\'s not to get into all the people who are portrayed as having a point when they shame him for wiping out his species rather than acknowledging that the entire universe owes him for saving it even though he could have just [[AscendToAHigherPlaneOfExistence Ascended To A Higher Plane Of Existence]] with the rest of the Time Lords and left them to fry. The Doctor even does this to \\\'\\\'himself\\\'\\\' when he traps his clone in an alternate universe after the clone saves the universe by genociding all the Daleks for the fifth or so time (admittedly, this was just the excuse he gave so that Rose could be with the man she loved, but his reasoning still counts as this trope).

One by one:

1). Given the events of \\\"Turn Left\\\", I think Donna had a point in yelling at the Doctor that he should stop now. He literally would have permanently died otherwise. It\\\'s also been awhile since I\\\'ve seen the episode, but the Doctor doesn\\\'t look particularly remorseful when he kills the Racnoss. He looks like an angry god. Given the events that would take place in \\\"The Waters of Mars\\\", this is important.

2.). Rose berates the ninth Doctor for trying to kill the Dalek because she had already gotten it to stop killing. All it wanted at that point was to feel the sun.

3.) I\\\'m not sure which people this entry is referring to when it says \\\"people who shamed the Doctor for wiping out his people.\\\" Not too many people know about the events of the Time War.
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
This trope also repeatedly comes up in the opposite direction when people \
to:
This trope also repeatedly comes up in the opposite direction when people \\\"call out\\\" the Doctor for certain things. For example, Donna\\\'s calling out of the Doctor for exterminating the infant Racnoss was portrayed as a WhatTheHellHero moment...even though the alternative would have been for the Doctor to walk away and let the Racnoss babies consume the Earth, and the Racnoss queen had repeatedly turned down his offer to safely find them a new world that wouldn\\\'t involve wiping out a species. Also, Rose berates the Ninth Doctor for trying to kill the lone Dalek after it murdered several dozen security personnel and as far as the Doctor knew, was intent on continuing its path of destruction onto the Earth\\\'s surface. And that\\\'s not to get into all the people who are portrayed as having a point when they shame him for wiping out his species rather than acknowledging that the entire universe owes him for saving it even though he could have just [[AscendToAHigherPlaneOfExistence Ascended To A Higher Plane Of Existence]] with the rest of the Time Lords and left them to fry. The Doctor even does this to \\\'\\\'himself\\\'\\\' when he traps his clone in an alternate universe after the clone saves the universe by genociding all the Daleks for the fifth or so time (admittedly, this was just the excuse he gave so that Rose could be with the man she loved, but his reasoning still counts as this trope).


1). Given the events of \\\"Turn Left\\\", I think Donna had a point in yelling at the Doctor that he should stop now. He literally would have permanently died otherwise. It\\\'s also been awhile since I\\\'ve seen the episode, but the Doctor doesn\\\'t look particularly remorseful when he kills the Racnoss. He looks like an angry god. Given the events that would take place in \\\"The Waters of Mars\\\", this is important.

2.). Rose berates the ninth Doctor for trying to kill the Dalek because she had already gotten it to stop killing. All it wanted at that point was to feel the sun.

3.) I\\\'m not sure which people this entry is referring to when it says \\\"people who shamed the Doctor for wiping out his people.\\\" Not too many people know about the events of the Time War.
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
This trope also repeatedly comes up in the opposite direction when people \
to:
This trope also repeatedly comes up in the opposite direction when people \\\"call out\\\" the Doctor for certain things. For example, Donna\\\'s calling out of the Doctor for exterminating the infant Racnoss was portrayed as a WhatTheHellHero moment...even though the alternative would have been for the Doctor to walk away and let the Racnoss babies consume the Earth, and the Racnoss queen had repeatedly turned down his offer to safely find them a new world that wouldn\\\'t involve wiping out a species. Also, Rose berates the Ninth Doctor for trying to kill the lone Dalek after it murdered several dozen security personnel and as far as the Doctor knew, was intent on continuing its path of destruction onto the Earth\\\'s surface. And that\\\'s not to get into all the people who are portrayed as having a point when they shame him for wiping out his species rather than acknowledging that the entire universe owes him for saving it even though he could have just [[AscendToAHigherPlaneOfExistence Ascended To A Higher Plane Of Existence]] with the rest of the Time Lords and left them to fry. The Doctor even does this to \\\'\\\'himself\\\'\\\' when he traps his clone in an alternate universe after the clone saves the universe by genociding all the Daleks for the fifth or so time (admittedly, this was just the excuse he gave so that Rose could be with the man she loved, but his reasoning still counts as this trope).

1). Given the events of \\\"Turn Left\\\", I think Donna had a point in yelling at the Doctor that he should stop now. He literally would have permanently died otherwise. It\\\'s also been awhile since I\\\'ve seen the episode, but the Doctor doesn\\\'t look particularly remorseful when he kills the Racnoss. He looks like an angry god. Given the events that would take place in \\\"The Waters of Mars\\\", this is important.
2.). Rose berates the ninth Doctor for trying to kill the Dalek because she had already gotten it to stop killing. All it wanted at that point was to feel the sun.
3.) I\\\'m not sure which people this entry is referring to when it says \\\"people who shamed the Doctor for wiping out his people.\\\" Not too many people know about the events of the Time War.
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
This trope also repeatedly comes up in the opposite direction when people \
to:
This trope also repeatedly comes up in the opposite direction when people \\\"call out\\\" the Doctor for certain things. For example, Donna\\\'s calling out of the Doctor for exterminating the infant Racnoss was portrayed as a WhatTheHellHero moment...even though the alternative would have been for the Doctor to walk away and let the Racnoss babies consume the Earth, and the Racnoss queen had repeatedly turned down his offer to safely find them a new world that wouldn\\\'t involve wiping out a species. Also, Rose berates the Ninth Doctor for trying to kill the lone Dalek after it murdered several dozen security personnel and as far as the Doctor knew, was intent on continuing its path of destruction onto the Earth\\\'s surface. And that\\\'s not to get into all the people who are portrayed as having a point when they shame him for wiping out his species rather than acknowledging that the entire universe owes him for saving it even though he could have just [[AscendToAHigherPlaneOfExistence Ascended To A Higher Plane Of Existence]] with the rest of the Time Lords and left them to fry. The Doctor even does this to \\\'\\\'himself\\\'\\\' when he traps his clone in an alternate universe after the clone saves the universe by genociding all the Daleks for the fifth or so time (admittedly, this was just the excuse he gave so that Rose could be with the man she loved, but his reasoning still counts as this trope).

1). Given the events of \\\"Turn Left\\\", I think Donna had a point in yelling at the Doctor that he should stop now. He literally would have permanently died otherwise. It\\\'s also been awhile since I\\\'ve seen the episode, but the Doctor doesn\\\'t look particularly remorseful when he kills the Racnoss. He looks like an angry god. Given the events that would take place in \\\"The Waters of Mars\\\", this is important.
2.). Rose berates the ninth Doctor for trying to kill the Dalek because she had already gotten it to stop killing. All it wanted at that point was to feel the sun.
3.) I\\\'m not sure which people this entry is referring to when it says \\\"people who shamed the Doctor for wiping out his people.\\\" Not too many people know about the events of the Time War.
Top