Discussion History Monster / Literature

Go To

[007] Spirit Current Version

Changed line(s) 1 from:

I deleted an example of CreatorsPet in regards to Liara. This is like the 3rd or 4th time I\'ve done so, so I thought I\'d open a discussion on whether she really does qualify or not to avoid any future EditWar. I say she doesn\'t, since to be a Pet she \'\'\'must\'\'\' fulfill all four points on the page.

to:

I deleted an example of CreatorsPet in regards to Liara. This is like the 3rd or 4th time I\\\'ve done so, so I thought I\\\'d open a discussion on whether she really does qualify or not to avoid any future EditWar. I say she doesn\\\'t, since to be a Pet she must fulfill \\\'\\\'\\\'all\\\'\\\'\\\' four points on the page.

Changed line(s) 3 from:

* Hated by fans(TheScrappy) - Far from it, she\'s one of the most liked characters in fanbase.

to:

* Hated by fans(TheScrappy) - Far from it, she\\\'s one of the most liked characters in the fanbase.

[006] Spirit

22nd Mar '13 at 08:07:30 PM

Changed line(s) 8 from:

Now, one could make a case for any one or all of bottom 3 bullets, but by virtue alone of \'\'not\'\' being a Scrappy means she does not qualify. Opinions or evidence to the contrary are welcome.

to:

Now, one could make a case for any one or all of the bottom 3 bullets, but by virtue alone of \\\'\\\'not\\\'\\\' being a Scrappy means she does not qualify. Opinions or evidence to the contrary are welcome.

[005] Spirit

22nd Mar '13 at 08:05:21 PM

Changed line(s) 8 from:

Opinions or evidence to the contrary are welcome.

to:

Now, one could make a case for any one or all of bottom 3 bullets, but by virtue alone of \\\'\\\'not\\\'\\\' being a Scrappy means she does not qualify. Opinions or evidence to the contrary are welcome.

[004] Spirit

22nd Mar '13 at 08:03:43 PM

Changed line(s) 6 from:

* Talked up by the other characters (CharacterShilling) - Again no. While yes, she does recieve a healthy amount of praise, it\'s hardly undue or excessive. Even then fan favorites like Wrex will still poke fun at her during the times when she does screw up or doesn\'t solve all problems.

to:

* Talked up by the other characters (CharacterShilling) - Debateable but no. While yes, she does recieve a healthy amount of praise, it\\\'s hardly undue or excessive. Even then fan favorites like Wrex will still poke fun at her during the times when she does screw up or doesn\\\'t solve all problems.

[003] Spirit

22nd Mar '13 at 08:03:16 PM

Changed line(s) 4 from:

* Loved (or worshipped) by the writers - Very arguable. One of the devs did admit a while ago that Liara was his favorite character, but that is little proof in of itself.
* Put into big scenes for no reason(CharacterFocus) - Not likely. She\'s literally the only squadmate from the previous games to be guaranteed to be alive, so her getting focus could be a case of necessity rather than preference. Contrast how Garrus, a permanent squadmate across all 3 games and could be dead by 3, has still gets as many scenes to himself and about as many lines as Liara.
* Talked up by the other characters (Character Shilling) - Again no. While yes, she does recieve a healthy amount of praise, it\'s hardly undue or excessive. Even then fan favorites like Wrex will still poke fun at her during the times when she does screw up or doesn\'t solve all problems.

to:

* Loved (or worshipped) by the writers - Very arguable. One of the devs did admit a while ago that Liara was his favorite character, but that is little proof in of itself. Her plot importance could even just be one of necessity (see below).
* Put into big scenes for no reason(CharacterFocus) - Not likely. She\\\'s literally the only squadmate from the previous games to be guaranteed to be alive, so her getting focus could be a case of necessity rather than preference. Contrast how Garrus, a permanent squadmate across all 3 games and could be dead by 3, still gets as many scenes to himself and about as many lines as Liara.
* Talked up by the other characters (CharacterShilling) - Again no. While yes, she does recieve a healthy amount of praise, it\\\'s hardly undue or excessive. Even then fan favorites like Wrex will still poke fun at her during the times when she does screw up or doesn\\\'t solve all problems.

[002] Spirit

22nd Mar '13 at 08:01:56 PM

Changed line(s) 3 from:

* Hated by fans(TheScrappy) - Far from it, she\'s quite well like amongst the fanbase.

to:

* Hated by fans(TheScrappy) - Far from it, she\\\'s one of the most liked characters in fanbase.

[001] Spirit

22nd Mar '13 at 08:01:14 PM

Changed line(s) 1 from:

I deleted an example of CreatorsPet in regards to Liara. This is like the 3rd or 4th time I\'ve done so, so I thought I\'d open a discussion on whether she really does qualify or not. I say she doesn\'t, since to be a Pet she \'\'\'must\'\'\' fulfill all four points on the page.

to:

I deleted an example of CreatorsPet in regards to Liara. This is like the 3rd or 4th time I\\\'ve done so, so I thought I\\\'d open a discussion on whether she really does qualify or not to avoid any future EditWar. I say she doesn\\\'t, since to be a Pet she \\\'\\\'\\\'must\\\'\\\'\\\' fulfill all four points on the page.

Top