Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion History Administrivia / ListOfShowsThatNeedSummary

Go To

[001] IceCrystal Current Version
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
I\'m not sure on policy. Is it all right to keep the novel and movie pages merged? There are some huge differences between book and film but \'\'The Guns of Navarone\'\' is a borderline case of AdaptationDisplacement, because the film has GregoryPeck and other A-list celebrities of the era and is on the whole much more memorable than the book by Alistair [=MacLean=]. Then again this was all well before my time, maybe I\'m underestimating the popularity of [=MacLean=].
to:
I\\\'m not sure on policy. Is it all right to keep the novel and movie pages merged? There are some huge differences between book and film but \\\'\\\'The Guns of Navarone\\\'\\\' is a borderline case of AdaptationDisplacement, because the film has GregoryPeck and other A-list celebrities of the era and is on the whole much more memorable than the book by Alistair [=MacLean=]. (Then again this was all well before my time, maybe I\\\'m underestimating the popularity of [=MacLean=].) Perhaps the best solution would be to leave the redirect in place, but separate the trope list on said page into Book and Film examples.
Top