Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion History YMMV / GameOfThronesS8E5TheBells

Go To

[003] XFllo Current Version
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
The show also wants us to sympathize with Tyrion for being the sole moderate voice of reason in Dany\'s council over zealots like Grey Worm, and someone whose faith in Daenerys is betrayed, while Dany browbeating him is treated as her being a Bad Boss. Others point out that Tyrion has genuinely been a terrible Hand who has screwed up multiple chances and opportunities given to him, starting right from the beginning with his handling of Meereen where he got suckered by the Masters of Slave Cities, over the objections of both Missandei and Grey Worm who warned him but gave him the initial benefit of the doubt until his mess nearly got them killed, which explains and justifies Grey Worm\'s hardened resolve against his \
to:
!!Copied from the page
The show also wants us to sympathize with Tyrion for being the sole moderate voice of reason in Dany\\\'s council over zealots like Grey Worm, and someone whose faith in Daenerys is betrayed, while Dany browbeating him is treated as her being a Bad Boss. Others point out that Tyrion has genuinely been a terrible Hand who has screwed up multiple chances and opportunities given to him, starting right from the beginning with his handling of Meereen where he got suckered by the Masters of Slave Cities, over the objections of both Missandei and Grey Worm who warned him but gave him the initial benefit of the doubt until his mess nearly got them killed, which explains and justifies Grey Worm\\\'s hardened resolve against his \\\"advice\\\". Tyrion\\\'s plan to attrition war Cersei into submission has led to tremendous losses for Dany, both in military and personal terms. Tyrion\\\'s peace deal with Cersei to create a Grand Alliance to stop the Long Night was based on his total misreading of his sister\\\'s personality. In other words, when Tyrion negotiates a Last-Second Chance for the city to surrender by ringing the bells and opening the gates (with the bells being run after the breach well past the deadline), there\\\'s little to no reason for Daenerys to listen to him. In the long run, fewer lives would have been lost had Daenerys gone to King\\\'s Landing right from the start and not prolonged the war the way Tyrion has. Anyone in real life with as many failures as Tyrion has in military and civil service, would have been removed from service and demoted and the fact that Daenerys kept him around for as long as she has is indeed a sign of her mercy.
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
[[quoteblock]] The show also wants us to sympathize with Tyrion for being the sole moderate voice of reason in Dany\'s council over zealots like Grey Worm, and someone whose faith in Daenerys is betrayed, while Dany browbeating him is treated as her being a Bad Boss. Others point out that Tyrion has genuinely been a terrible Hand who has screwed up multiple chances and opportunities given to him, starting right from the beginning with his handling of Meereen where he got suckered by the Masters of Slave Cities, over the objections of both Missandei and Grey Worm who warned him but gave him the initial benefit of the doubt until his mess nearly got them killed, which explains and justifies Grey Worm\'s hardened resolve against his \
to:
The show also wants us to sympathize with Tyrion for being the sole moderate voice of reason in Dany\\\'s council over zealots like Grey Worm, and someone whose faith in Daenerys is betrayed, while Dany browbeating him is treated as her being a Bad Boss. Others point out that Tyrion has genuinely been a terrible Hand who has screwed up multiple chances and opportunities given to him, starting right from the beginning with his handling of Meereen where he got suckered by the Masters of Slave Cities, over the objections of both Missandei and Grey Worm who warned him but gave him the initial benefit of the doubt until his mess nearly got them killed, which explains and justifies Grey Worm\\\'s hardened resolve against his \\\"advice\\\". Tyrion\\\'s plan to attrition war Cersei into submission has led to tremendous losses for Dany, both in military and personal terms. Tyrion\\\'s peace deal with Cersei to create a Grand Alliance to stop the Long Night was based on his total misreading of his sister\\\'s personality. In other words, when Tyrion negotiates a Last-Second Chance for the city to surrender by ringing the bells and opening the gates (with the bells being run after the breach well past the deadline), there\\\'s little to no reason for Daenerys to listen to him. In the long run, fewer lives would have been lost had Daenerys gone to King\\\'s Landing right from the start and not prolonged the war the way Tyrion has. Anyone in real life with as many failures as Tyrion has in military and civil service, would have been removed from service and demoted and the fact that Daenerys kept him around for as long as she has is indeed a sign of her mercy.
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
[[quoteblock]]
The show also wants us to sympathize with Tyrion for being the sole moderate voice of reason in Dany\'s council over zealots like Grey Worm, and someone whose faith in Daenerys is betrayed, while Dany browbeating him is treated as her being a Bad Boss. Others point out that Tyrion has genuinely been a terrible Hand who has screwed up multiple chances and opportunities given to him, starting right from the beginning with his handling of Meereen where he got suckered by the Masters of Slave Cities, over the objections of both Missandei and Grey Worm who warned him but gave him the initial benefit of the doubt until his mess nearly got them killed, which explains and justifies Grey Worm\'s hardened resolve against his \
to:
[[quoteblock]] The show also wants us to sympathize with Tyrion for being the sole moderate voice of reason in Dany\\\'s council over zealots like Grey Worm, and someone whose faith in Daenerys is betrayed, while Dany browbeating him is treated as her being a Bad Boss. Others point out that Tyrion has genuinely been a terrible Hand who has screwed up multiple chances and opportunities given to him, starting right from the beginning with his handling of Meereen where he got suckered by the Masters of Slave Cities, over the objections of both Missandei and Grey Worm who warned him but gave him the initial benefit of the doubt until his mess nearly got them killed, which explains and justifies Grey Worm\\\'s hardened resolve against his \\\"advice\\\". Tyrion\\\'s plan to attrition war Cersei into submission has led to tremendous losses for Dany, both in military and personal terms. Tyrion\\\'s peace deal with Cersei to create a Grand Alliance to stop the Long Night was based on his total misreading of his sister\\\'s personality. In other words, when Tyrion negotiates a Last-Second Chance for the city to surrender by ringing the bells and opening the gates (with the bells being run after the breach well past the deadline), there\\\'s little to no reason for Daenerys to listen to him. In the long run, fewer lives would have been lost had Daenerys gone to King\\\'s Landing right from the start and not prolonged the war the way Tyrion has. Anyone in real life with as many failures as Tyrion has in military and civil service, would have been removed from service and demoted and the fact that Daenerys kept him around for as long as she has is indeed a sign of her mercy. [[/quoteblock]]
Top