Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion History Main / SelfMadeOrphan

Go To

[004] Asherinka Current Version

5th Jun '18 at 04:42:38 AM

Changed line(s) 2 from:

n

Black Widow's page is 19k symbols.. I don't have a strong opinion on that. As I've written below, there are 17 characters with pages longer than 25k symbols (and their list hasn't changed since 6 May), I would keep those. Now we also have 5 more individual pages that are shorter (Black Widow, Rocket, Drax, Yondu - 19-23k and Hawkeye - 12k). Hawkeye stands out, but I believe if the rest are to be merged back, the same decision should be made about all four of them.

to:

Black Widow\'s page is 19k symbols.. I don\'t have a strong opinion on that. As I\'ve written below, there are 17 characters with pages longer than 25k symbols (and their list hasn\'t changed since 6 May), I would keep those. Now we also have 5 more individual pages that are shorter (Black Widow, Rocket, Drax, Yondu - 19-23k and Hawkeye - 12k). Hawkeye stands out, but I believe if the rest are to be merged back, the same decision should be made about all four of them.

Changed line(s) 5 from:

n

Upd Let's simply keep the

to:

Upd Let\'s simply keep the \"New Avengers\" then.

I believe though that Sharon Carter should be moved to the [=SHIELD=] page, while Erik Selvig and Helen Cho - to Citizens (just like Jane Foster). They are not Avengers, and all heroic organisations are technically Avengers\' allies. Not a reason to list minor characters on the Avenger\'s page.

[003] Asherinka

5th Jun '18 at 04:30:00 AM

Changed line(s) 2 from:

n

Black Widow's page is 19k symbols.. I don't have a strong opinion on that. As I've written below, there are 17 characters with pages longer than 25k symbols (and their list hasn't changed since 6 May), I would keep those. Now we also have 5 more individual pages that are shorter (Black Widow, Rocket, Drax, Yondu - 19-23k and Hawkeye - 12k). Hawkeye stands out, but I believe if the rest are to be merged back, the same decision should be made about all four of them.

to:

Black Widow\'s page is 19k symbols.. I don\'t have a strong opinion on that. As I\'ve written below, there are 17 characters with pages longer than 25k symbols (and their list hasn\'t changed since 6 May), I would keep those. Now we also have 5 more individual pages that are shorter (Black Widow, Rocket, Drax, Yondu - 19-23k and Hawkeye - 12k). Hawkeye stands out, but I believe if the rest are to be merged back, the same decision should be made about all four of them.

Changed line(s) 5 from:

n

I couldn't come up with anything better than

to:

Upd Let\'s simply keep the \"New Avengers\" then.

I strongly believe though that Sharon Carter should be moved to the [=SHIELD=] page, while Erik Selvig and Helen Cho - to Citizens (just like Jane Foster). They are not Avengers, and all heroic organisations are technically Avengers\' allies. Not a reason to list minor characters on the Avenger\'s page.

[002] Asherinka

4th Jun '18 at 12:15:42 PM

Changed line(s) 1 from:

n

@[=DustSnitch=]\\
Black Widow's page is 19k symbols.. I don't have a strong opinion on that. As I've written below, there are 17 characters with pages longer than 25k symbols (and their list hasn't changed since 6 May), I would keep those. Now we also have 5 more individual pages that are shorter (Black Widow, Rocket, Drax, Yondu - 19-23k and Hawkeye - 12k). Hawkeye stands out, but I believe if the rest are to be merged back, the same decision should be made about all four of them.

to:

@[=DustSnitch=]\\\\\\\\
Black Widow\'s page is 19k symbols.. I don\'t have a strong opinion on that. As I\'ve written below, there are 17 characters with pages longer than 25k symbols (and their list hasn\'t changed since 6 May), I would keep those. Now we also have 5 more individual pages that are shorter (Black Widow, Rocket, Drax, Yondu - 19-23k and Hawkeye - 12k). Hawkeye stands out, but I believe if the rest are to be merged back, the same decision should be made about all four of them.

Changed line(s) 4 from:

n

@[=KingClark=]\\
I couldn't come up with anything better than

to:

@[=KingClark=]\\\\\\\\
I couldn\'t come up with anything better than \"[=AoU Recruits=]\", but I agree that the name is clumsy. So any other ideas for the name are welcome :) The problem with \"New Avengers\" and \"Recruits\" is that Spider-Man is technically a recruit too. But I wouldn\'t oppose that name. We could simply keep \"New Avengers\" then.

I strongly believe though that Sharon Carter should be moved to the [=SHIELD=] page, while Erik Selvig and Helen Cho - to Citizens (just like Jane Foster). They are not Avengers, and all heroic organisations are technically Avengers\' allies. Not a reason to list minor characters on the Avenger\'s page.

[001] Asherinka

4th Jun '18 at 12:11:57 PM

Changed line(s) 1 from:

n

@DustSnitch\\
Black Widow's page is 19k symbols.. I don't have a strong opinion on that. As I've written below, there are 17 characters with pages longer than 25k symbols (and their list hasn't changed since 6 May), I would keep those. We now also have 5 more individual pages that are shorter (Black Widow, Rocket, Drax, Yondu - 19-23k and Hawkeye - 12k). Hawkeye stands out, but I believe if the rest are to be merged back, the same decision should be made about all four of them.

to:

@[=DustSnitch=]\\\\\\\\
Black Widow\'s page is 19k symbols.. I don\'t have a strong opinion on that. As I\'ve written below, there are 17 characters with pages longer than 25k symbols (and their list hasn\'t changed since 6 May), I would keep those. Now we also have 5 more individual pages that are shorter (Black Widow, Rocket, Drax, Yondu - 19-23k and Hawkeye - 12k). Hawkeye stands out, but I believe if the rest are to be merged back, the same decision should be made about all four of them.

Changed line(s) 4 from:

n

@KingClark I couldn't come up with anything better than

to:

@[=KingClark=]\\\\\\\\
I couldn\'t come up with anything better than \"[=AoU Recruits=]\", but I agree that the name is clumsy. So any other ideas for the name are welcome :) The problem with \"New Avengers\" and \"Recruits\" is that Spider-Man is technically a recruit too. But I wouldn\'t oppose that name.

I strongly believe though that Sharon Carter should be moved to the [=SHIELD=] page, while Erik Selvig and Helen Cho - to Citizens (just like Jane Foster). They are not Avengers, and all heroic organisations are technically Avengers\' allies. Not a reason to list minor characters on the Avenger\'s page.

Top