[001]
TheBigBopper
Current Version
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
So the sense I'm getting from Arawn999 is that for characters who are too changed from their manga designs, it would be better to use Black & White manga panels if there is no official colorized Miura portrait. That case-by-case basis approach is different than if we went with the phenomx13 proposal that the primary should always be artwork by Miura, whether or not a colorized version is available. It would require us too look at each character and determine a rule of thumb for how different is too different.
to:
So the sense I\'m getting from Arawn999 is that for characters who are too changed from their manga designs, it would be better to use Black & White manga panels if there is no official colorized Miura portrait. That case-by-case basis approach is different than if we went with the phenomx13 proposal that the primary should always be artwork by Miura, whether or not a colorized version is available. It would require us too look at each character and determine a rule of thumb for how different is too different.
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
Let's take some specific examples. I had made Foss' primary an [[http://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/foss_anime_b.jpg image]] from ''Anime/Berserk1997'', as I found it largely the same as in the manga, and it is in color. Phenomx13 saw fit to replace it in precedence with [[http://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/foss_8.jpg this]] monochrome manga panel. On one hand, the '97 anime is in color, but on the other hand the coloring is a little flat compared to the level of shading in the manga and the TCG. The same issue with the Queen of Midland and Gambino: I would like to use ''Anime/Berserk1997'' and I'm guessing phenomx would say that the current monochrome manga portraits are still better. What would you have us do?
to:
Let\'s take some specific examples. I had made Foss\' primary an [[http://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/foss_anime_b.jpg image]] from \'\'Anime/Berserk1997\'\', as I found it largely the same as in the manga, and it is in color. Phenomx13 saw fit to replace it in precedence with [[http://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/foss_8.jpg this]] monochrome manga panel. On one hand, the \'97 anime is in color, but on the other hand the coloring is a little flat compared to the level of shading in the manga and the TCG. The same issue with the Queen of Midland and Gambino: I would like to use \'\'Anime/Berserk1997\'\' and I\'m guessing phenomx would say that the current monochrome manga portraits are still better. What would you have us do?