Follow TV Tropes

Discussion History UsefulNotes / JosefStalin

Go To

[004] presh Current Version
Changed line(s) 1 from:
Does [[spoiler:Old Habits' room also]] count as {{Bizarrchitecture}}? The vibes it gives off rather resembles the [[spoiler:basement, but it's not as weird as the graveyard,]] for example.
to:
Does [[spoiler:Old Habits\' room also]] count as {{Bizarrchitecture}}? The vibes it gives off rather resemble the [[spoiler:basement, but it\'s not as weird as the graveyard,]] for example.
Changed line(s) 1 from:
Does [[spoiler:Old Habits' room also]] count as {{Bizarrchitecture}}?
to:
Does [[spoiler:Old Habits\' room also]] count as {{Bizarrchitecture}}? The vibes it gives off rather resembles the [[spoiler:basement, but it\'s not as weird as the graveyard,]] for example.
Changed line(s) 3 from:
Likewise, do bear in mind that among amateur and professional historians, no-one bothers to say that murder is bad and that murderers are evil. This is particularly the case in genocide studies, wherein the more than four dozen books I've at least skimmed on the subject have never once bothered with moral condemnations. This is because it wastes time and ink, and clutters the page with redundant words.
to:
Likewise, do bear in mind that among amateur and professional historians, no-one bothers to say that murder is bad and that murderers are evil. This is particularly the case in genocide studies, wherein the more than four dozen books I\'ve at least skimmed on the subject have never once bothered with moral condemnations. This is because it wastes time and ink, and clutters the page with redundant words.
Changed line(s) 5 from:
So when JulianLapostat wrote
to:
So when JulianLapostat wrote \"back down to acceptable numbers\", I suspect they assumed you would know that they were saying so from the viewpoint of the NKVD and/or Stalin... rather than exhorting people to kill Orthodox Christians, or expressing a personal view that killing Orthodox Christians is good.

For my part I certainly assumed that if I told you I didn\'t have sufficiently detailed knowledge of Stalin\'s personality to give you insights that you couldn\'t take JulianLapostat\'s word for, or research for yourself, you would take that statement at face value rather than accuse me of being a Stalinist.
Changed line(s) 3 from:
Likewise, do bear in mind that among amateur and professional historians, no-one bothers to say that murder is bad and that murderers are evil. This is particularly the case in genocide studies, wherein the more than four dozen books I've at least skimmed on the subject have never once bothered with moral condemnations. This is because it wastes time and ink, and clutters the page with redundant words.
to:
Likewise, do bear in mind that among amateur and professional historians, no-one bothers to say that murder is bad and that murderers are evil. This is particularly the case in genocide studies, wherein the more than four dozen books I\'ve at least skimmed on the subject have never once bothered with moral condemnations. This is because it wastes time and ink, and clutters the page with redundant words.
Changed line(s) 5 from:
So when JulianLapostat wrote
to:
So when JulianLapostat wrote \"back down to acceptable numbers\", I suspect they assumed you would know that they were saying so from the viewpoint of the NKVD and/or Stalin... rather than exhorting people to kill the religious, or expressing a personal view that killing religious people is good.

For my part I certainly assumed that if I told you I didn\'t have sufficiently detailed knowledge of Stalin\'s personality to give you insights that you couldn\'t take JulianLapostat\'s word for, or research for yourself, you would take that statement at face value rather than accuse me of being a Stalinist.
Top

How well does it match the trope?

Example of:

/

Media sources:

/

Report