Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion History YMMV / DumbingOfAge

Go To

Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
I'm not necessarily opposed to keeping the entry, even if I disagree with it - I believed I helped edit it to include the mentions of homophobia and transphobia. In particular, I specifically stated that ''some'' of the criticisms could delve into this territory, to avoid the implication that all of them do. I feel like these mentions of
to:
I\'m not necessarily opposed to keeping the entry, even if I disagree with it - I believed I helped edit it to include the mentions of homophobia and transphobia. In particular, I specifically stated that \'\'some\'\' of the criticisms could delve into this territory, to avoid the implication that all of them do. I feel like these mentions of \"blanket accusations\" and \"average fans\" aren\'t really substantiated, and it leans too close to siding with Mary on the issue. And then there\'s the addition to the related {{Moral Event Horizon}} entry, with as far as I\'m concerned has got to go.

Perhaps it might help to acknowledge Willis\' stance on the issue, which was basically that while Carla is a jerk, that does not in any way justify misgendering her. That is, I believe, the entire point of this plotline.
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
I'm not necessarily opposed to keeping the entry, even if I disagree with it - I believed I helped edit it to include the mentions of homophobia and transphobia. In particular, I specifically stated that ''some'' of the criticisms could delve into this territory. I feel like these mentions of
to:
I\'m not necessarily opposed to keeping the entry, even if I disagree with it - I believed I helped edit it to include the mentions of homophobia and transphobia. In particular, I specifically stated that \'\'some\'\' of the criticisms could delve into this territory, to avoid the implication that all of them do. I feel like these mentions of \"blanket accusations\" and \"average fans\" aren\'t really substantiated, and it leans too close to siding with Mary on the issue. And then there\'s the addition to the related {{Moral Event Horizon}} entry, with as far as I\'m concerned has got to go.

Perhaps it might help to acknowledge Willis\' stance on the issue, which was basically that while Carla is a jerk, that does not in any way excuse misgendering her. That is, I believe, the entire point of this plotline.
Top