Have a question about how the TVTropes wiki works? No one knows this community better than the people in it, so ask away! Ask the Tropers is the page you come to when you have a question burning in your brain and the support pages didn't help.
It's not for everything, though. For a list of all the resources for your questions, click here. You can also go to this Directory thread
for ongoing cleanup projects.
Ask the Tropers is for:
- General questions about the wiki, how it works, and how to do things.
- Reports of problems with wiki articles, or requests for help with wiki articles.
- Reports of misbehavior or abuse by other tropers.
Ask the Tropers is not for:
- Help identifying a trope. See TropeFinder.
- Help identifying a work. See MediaFinder.
- Asking if a trope example is valid. See the Trope Talk forum.
- Proposing new tropes. See TropeLaunchPad.
- Making bug reports. See QueryBugs.
- Asking for new wiki features. See QueryWishlist.
- Chatting with other tropers. See our forums.
- Reporting problems with advertisements. See this forum topic.
- Reporting issues on the forums. Send a Holler instead.
Ask the Tropers:
openAbout
I am currently working on a personal writing project/exercise, and I was wondering if I could use my own Tropers page (which is not yet created, but I assume it would be Tropers/Waddle) as my own personal sandbox to keep record of this project in an easy to use/edit interface.
So my question is actually this one: can I do whatever I want in my own Troper page? Or should I keep what is basically a Super Smash Bros. fanfiction out of it, and only use it for actual information about myself?
Edited by WaddleopenLoveItOrHateIt question.
I had recently noticed that the Love It or Hate It trope is listed on the In Universe Examples Only page, but when you go the the Love It or Hate It page itself it's clearly listed as a YMMV trope. So I'm just a little confused. Is it supposed to be both or is it one and not the other?
open Revert on SpectacleFighter? Videogame
Could we get a mod revert on Spectacle Fighter? A troper took it upon himself to cut most of the page without discussion. He is on the Discussion page now, so I think the prudent course of action would be to revert the page, discuss what does or does not need to be cut, and then re-cut stuff.
I do agree that the fat should be trimmed, but he cut way too much before any discussion occurred.
openRemaking Of The The Eye Creatures: Namespace Film
Since Attack of the The Eye Creatures was purified, I'd like to re-create its original version where it belongs, which means in one of the "fun" namespaces. However, I'm not sure whether it should be in Just for Fun (which was my first hunch) or Self-Demonstrating...
Edited by Medinocopen De-power and Brought Down To Normal
Isn't De-power used for characters that lost their powers permanently while Brought Down to Normal used for characters that lost their power temporary? I have seen some peoples confused a De-power example as a Brought Down to Normal example, even on the De-power page itself.
Edited by flamemario12openEdit warring on the E3 page
Here
, Dragon Ranger made Step Three into the triggering of an Edit War by "Switching 2016 controversies entries back" to a rather-unintuitive format that places the whole thing at the middle of the E3 2016 section, trying to correlate an act of solidarity from the ones present in the conference towards the affected ones by the Orlando shooting with a controversial analysis on video game violence (using Feminist Frequency as a source in the process). Before said analysis was added at all, the folder merely mentioned the expressions of sympathy like the rainbow ribbons, and I think it was perfectly fine that way since it was very relevant to how E3 was performed this year. Indeed, after Dragon Ranger originally repurposed that part to add an analysis on gaming violence (which ONLY relates to E3 in the content and themes of the games exhibited and not the event itself), it was reverted by another troper for the reasons I'm explaining. Now DR simply reverted it as they believe the two pieces of info must be together.
Since this is the kind of thing that unfairly ruins and degenerates the subject of the article (as happened in many other pages), my opinion is that the whole entry about analysis on gaming violence should be axed and leave the entry about the solidarity of the conference (like I said, this one thing is relevant and meaningful). But I'm bringing this here first because there's sadly an Edit War declared here and I need the troper community's stance on this before douing anything.
EDIT: In fact, if you read carefully the current revision, you'll note that the whole tribute and solidarity part was demoted to being a "side note". When in fact that should be the only thing preserved there at all!
Edited by MyFinalEditsopen Not the fall that kills you Literature
Is Richard Mayhew's fear of heights not because of the fall, but because he doesn't trust himself in Neverwhere an example of Not the Fall That Kills You?
openSome...interesting formatting on Music/TheAgonist Music
Music.TheAgonist consists entirely of zero-context examples grouped by song. Even if the examples had context (which they don't) and were indented correctly (which they aren't), would this method of organizing even be kosher? It just seems to be more unwieldy than just arranging the tropes in the normal way.
I'm not familiar enough with the band to add context to any of the examples, and the few examples with context seem to be misuse, so...uh...what should be done here? I could try to overhaul it myself (the reason I ended up on the page in the first place was because I started listening to one of their albums and liked it), but it would take a while.
open new royalty girl in winter kingdom? Literature
Hello All, In an ideal world it would be a book about a girl who somehow becomes a queen/(some form of power position) and must rule in a winter land, with a night full of monsters and magic. She isn't sure who she can trust, etc. So I have a very specific tone for the book I'm requesting. I'm looking for a mix between 'The Little White Horse' and 'A Game of Thrones'. Now let me explain, I would like the beauty and suspense of TLWH and from GOT I would like only the north. By that I mean only the feeling of Winterfell and beyond the wall. I'm looking for some creepy/suspense/horror/beautiful/fantasy/magic book, preferably with a dash of romance. You will be my friend for life if you can find me this obscure wish book. (I feel like I should just write this myself heh). Thank you fantastical people!
open Mediation Needed
Brief backstory:
In Xenoblade Chronicles X, there's an optional conversation with a party member whereas she complains about guys who hit on her as well as other women. If you are a male character (and ONLY if you are male) asks you for your opinion, and if you agree, she basically says "I KNEW you were different. Heck, I'd ask YOU out for a drink!"
After that, the concept of a date or romance never comes up again.
Myself and Dragon95 think this is sufficient for Ship Tease. Larkmarn leans toward agreeing with us, but hasn't played the game. Miin U does not agree, and is becoming increasingly hostile about their opinion.
This is the third time I've gotten into a debate with this person, and we are equally stubborn. However, Miin U's arguments don't make any sense to us, with all three of us at one point calling them out for making invalid arguments.
We need new people to chime in and say if they think we're right or wrong.
Edited by KingZealopenDoes it count if a work offers a Mythology Gag within itself? Videogame
- Another Vanu Vanu daily quest is called "The Binding Soil". Does it count if a work offers a Mythology Gag within itself?
Well, does it? (This was on Final Fantasy XIV. The context is that a quest in the :Heavensward expansion has a Punny Name with the pun being derived from a Bonus Level [Specifically what MMO players would refer to as a "Raid"] in the base game)
openMy first question
Why is the trope "Stronger Than They Look" got remove? Is it because it's offensive to the users or trope itself?
Edited by SeptimusHeapopenStill can't find uploaded images...
So a few months back, I was asking about why the images I've recently been uploading aren't showing up when I search for the images that I personally uploaded and I'm noticing that nothing is getting resolved.
Yesterday, I uploaded an image of Phantom Girl from the Legion of Super Heroes show to have on the Characters page and just today, I uploaded a picture for the Revolution (2016) Work page and I can't find either or on the list of personally uploaded images that one finds when he/she searches him/herself in the Search by Tropers search engine in the Images List.
Is this problem happening with anyone else or is it just me? Because frankly, I'm getting worried.
Edited by TargetmasterJoeopenSnapshotOfASoul and Openness
There are a lot of problems with this page
and its accompanying Trivia and YMMV pages (ZC Es, tropes on wrong page, putting Main/ in front of all of the tropes, and editing their own YMMV page, for starters), but the creator and sole editor, SnapshotOfASoul
just seems a little too...personal.
Like on the YMMV page:
- Author Phobia:
- The director will often go out of his way to imply sexual abuse instead of overtly show it as it happens to avoid triggering himself.
Calling himself the director and it being on the wrong page aside, that doesn't seem like the kind of thing that should be on any page, Trivia or not.
Edited by ArctimonopenHu.Cloverfield?
Does anyone know what this page
is about? Putting it through a Google Translate reveals it's a one-sentence summary of the film itself (insofar as I can tell with Translate) ending with the words 'good start'.
openSo-called "complaining" about prehistoric life
There's a user named Magnus Force who goes around on paleontology-related tropes like Artistic License – Paleontology and Ptero Soarer and complains in the discussion page about the examples being complainy, and he removed the pterosaur example from Informed Species (which I re-added) for the same reason.
Thing is, these examples don't come across as complainy, at least not to me, any more than the other tropes pointing out biological inaccuracies. (Like Artistic License – Ornithology and Somewhere, a Herpetologist Is Crying.) Then again, I'm a paleo fan myself, so I'm not sure if I count.
So, what do you think? Does Magnus Force actually have a point, or is he just being nitpicky?
open Accidental deletion. Videogame
Someone accidentally deleted a large portion of Fate/Grand Order: Assassins. I fix it myself but I can't do it on my tablet.
Edited by WhirlRX

Do the edits made by autwitchstic in Heroic Self-Deprecation
, Shed the Family Name
, and Half-Breed Discrimination
count as agenda-based editing?