Have a question about how the TVTropes wiki works? No one knows this community better than the people in it, so ask away! Ask the Tropers is the page you come to when you have a question burning in your brain and the support pages didn't help.
It's not for everything, though. For a list of all the resources for your questions, click here. You can also go to this Directory thread
for ongoing cleanup projects.
Ask the Tropers is for:
- General questions about the wiki, how it works, and how to do things.
- Reports of problems with wiki articles, or requests for help with wiki articles.
- Reports of misbehavior or abuse by other tropers.
Ask the Tropers is not for:
- Help identifying a trope. See TropeFinder.
- Help identifying a work. See MediaFinder.
- Asking if a trope example is valid. See the Trope Talk forum.
- Proposing new tropes. See TropeLaunchPad.
- Making bug reports. See QueryBugs.
- Asking for new wiki features. See QueryWishlist.
- Chatting with other tropers. See our forums.
- Reporting problems with advertisements. See this forum topic.
- Reporting issues on the forums. Send a Holler instead.
Ask the Tropers:
openProbably non-kosher entry on ''Holy Terror''; thoughts?
On the Holy Terror page (about a comic book written by American author Frank Miller) someone felt the need to interject Real Life Dutch politician Geert Wilders (as background: he's best-known for his stance against immigration of non-Westerners, specifically Islamic, people into the Netherlands; and is in the Netherlands a political figure as polarizing as Donald Trump is in the U.S. (and lately frequently compared to the latter)). It seems nonsensical to drag a Real Life politician who doesn't have any relevance to the comic book plot (written by and set in a different country than said politician) into this entry, it seems almost as trolling. Also as a double whammy, a lot of natter then follows about the nature of the U.S. and its constitution - doesn't seem relevant to the comic book either.
Probably better to remove the Geert Wilders (and the natter about the U.S. constitution?) stuff out of this entry, but knowing how polarizing political stuff is, I wanted to ask for feedback here first. This is the entry:
- Bile Fascination: Just seeing how much religious bashing in portraying Muslims in general as motivated by violent extremism at worst and misguided, helpless victims at best can be put into a single set of one hundred pages is quite not good taste, but it's certainly a level of awfulness that one cannot help but keep looking in disbelief that such Geert Wilders-ian style ethnic/racial/religious hatred stoking can exist in the United States, a land that prides itself in incorporating and integrating the various people of the world based on the ideal that, to quote the United States Declaration of Independence, "all men are created equal" and are "endowed by their creator the rights of life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness".
openAction Mom and Mama Bear Misuse
The Digimon mom example in particular is problematic in that Sora's mom IS NOT action oriented,she's a flower arranger who otherwise never fights or does anything remotely action oriented, she's listed because she "Fearlessly Saved Sora From Danger" which should go to Mama Bear... which in and out of itself has become bloated to mean "Any female who fights for her loved ones, regardless of if they are her actual children". Its really annoying and we should do something about this.
resolved Fanfic self-recommendation on FanficRecs/RWBY Web Original
(Why do the RWBY pages get so much attention here?)
Skybrigadier, the author of The Reactsverse, recommended Weiss Reacts (the verse's first entry) on RWBY's Fanfic Recs page.
I've removed it from the page, under the assumption that any following recommendations are in reaction (heh) to the illicit self-rec. Allowing Weiss Reacts to stay on the page despite initially being self-recced would set a very bad precedent for fanfic recs pages.
Edited by bwburke94open Does Single Stroke Battle only apply to swordfights, or can it apply to fist fights as well?
The page itself seems to imply that it's only for swords (citing it as the Sword Counterpart of Showdown at High Noon), but there are some examples of barehanded fights on the page as well.
openWhat should an entry for OneWordTitle on a Work page look like?
What should an entry for One-Word Title on a Work page look like?
I'm just having "One-Word Title", and then nothing after it, if it's obviously, like Manga/Bleach or something like that.
It seems allowed? According to the hidden comment at the top of One-Word Title:
"(Obviously most examples here will be self-explanatory, but if you're going to refer to a series with a multi-word title which consists of works with one-word titles, without actually referencing any of those works, that's a Zero Context Example.)"
openDo Sub Tropes have to be utterly enclosed by their Super Tropes?
Do Sub Tropes have to be utterly enclosed by their Super Tropes?
Like is Character Title actually a Sub-Trope of One-Word Title? Because a title could refer to a character without being only consisting of one word, like "Silver Surfer".
Super-Trope itself says:
openStellaris YMMV example about a racist mod and controversy Videogame
We have this example on YMMV.Stellaris:
- What Do You Mean, It's Not Political?:
- A user created a mod that turned all Human phenotypes into European ones. While not particularly significant, the user also added the tagline "No Multiculturalism Here!", which resulted in the comments section of the mod being about what you'd expect with such a tagline. Cue the mod being deleted within the blink of an eye, a teacup tempest erupting over it, and the mod being brought back. You can read all about it here.
For the record (again), Paradox are Swedish. And that is all that will be said about that.
- A user created a mod that turned all Human phenotypes into European ones. While not particularly significant, the user also added the tagline "No Multiculturalism Here!", which resulted in the comments section of the mod being about what you'd expect with such a tagline. Cue the mod being deleted within the blink of an eye, a teacup tempest erupting over it, and the mod being brought back. You can read all about it here.
There is an Example Indentation issue already, but the example has other issues. Particularly potential drama importation/Flame Bait (note the Internet Backdraft pothole. The racist nature of the mod itself also does not do the example any favors) and that it is the only time on the YMMV page in which a Game Mod was referenced. Paradox being Swedish was likewise also unmentioned on the page outside the example. The history revealed the reason for the referencing of Sweden and the indentation. Both were tied to another example (added by a different troper) that was cut by the Trump/ROJEC thread. In which case I ask if we should cut it or not?
Edited by MorningStar1337openIs This Trope Used Right?
So there's this entry on YMMV.raocow:
- Dude, Not Funny!:
- The reaction he and his fans had to the "Lowest Ranked Levels" world of Vanilla Contest '14. The overworld was designed to mock the troll entries the contest would receive in previous years, except most of the lowest ranking entries this year were either just average or ambitiously misguided. Regardless, these levels looked as if genuine effort was put into them, and didn't warrant being labeled as complete abominations by the category they were placed in.
- In a MAGLX2 level (Sad Skillful Military Base
), somebody made a "sad cat room" as both a joke and a memorial to both their own cat and raocow's cat Gaston. This turned out to be one of the biggest tearjerkers in the history of raocow, probably a bigger tearjerker than the original video
which was made when Gaston passed away ( the joke was about how the "villain" of that level was so evil, he set up a room for cute things being sad out of spite ). Many people felt like the joke was in really bad taste (and raocow even said "sometimes a joke goes a bit too far"), but raocow said that he didn't mind it, it was just that it was very unexpected. Also qualifies as a Mood Whiplash.
Thing is, Dude, Not Funny!! as a YMMV entry should relate to the work/person itself rather than what said work/person's reacting to, so the use of this entry seems wrong. There's also the issue of complaining on the first part of it. So with that being said, should this whole thing be cut, modified, or left as is?
openEditing error. Film
On the page Logan I made an edit for a speech and then clicked enter to stop an editing mistake which succeeded with the previews. Someone undid the enter causing that editing mistake again. I don't want to fix this myself because it could be confused with an edit war.
Edited by ReynTime250openDeleting Pages
How do you delete a page? I just made a new trope page for a dinosaur media entry, but the authors of the work the page described felt it didn't deserve a page and I find myself inclined to agree with them.
openTitles with Descriptions, Style of Index Pages and Long-Lasting Anxiety
On 23rd Nov '16, at Main/Manhua, I deleted the descriptions of every single entry on the page, leaving behind only the titles of the works, citing "We can save the descriptions for the individual pages; this page is just for indexing." I was motivated by how most of the work index pages lack these information and still function alright despite so, making me think that they are unneeded.
The incident prompted a PM discussion between me and fellow editor Mercy, and there was also an ATT thread here started by Mercy that you can find by searching for "Wuz" concerning the situation. (I don't know how to link an ATT thread)
The ATT thread "concluded" that due to how inconsistent foreign-language indexes are, at least original language titles should be restored, and the rest should stay as is.
The case may have ended, but the anxiety never died, and it came back again. Around a month ago, I found this: Web Serial Novel. The page is literally filled with entries that have descriptions going alongside the titles and the occasional description-less title-only entry, and once again I became anxious over this issue again as I debated with myself if I did the right thing in removing all the descriptions, or if I really was being brash in editing without discussing. (for the record, I am anxious over a lot of things, and this is just one of them)
Looking through Administirivia, I didn't really see a style guide on how should index pages be written. Should they have descriptions going alongside the titles? Or are they cluttering the page and making things hard to look through? Those are my questions.
Edited by WuzopenHow could I shorten the Red vs. Blue WMG page? Web Original
It's too ridiculously long. I'd like to shorten & reorganize it myself, but I've never had to do something like this before. I don't know where to start. Can someone help?
openInterpreting In Universe characters through their actors on YMMV
OK, here's a delicate one. I'll try to formulate as neutral as possible.
7th Heaven ran from 1996 to 2006. Years later in 2014, it came to light that main actor of that show Stephen Collins had sexually molested children in Real Life.
Now the 7th Heaven YMMV page is riddled with backwards interpretations of his In Universe character, Eric, through these horrific acts the actor commited in Real Life. E.g. Eric is called a Base-Breaking Character due to what his actor did in Real Life; there are lots of potholes to Harsher in Hindsight regarding any scene Eric's character had with a minor girl, etc.
So my question: in how far do we interpret / judge characters on YMMV pages through the lens of what their actors did in Real Life?
Because I think on this particular page, the In Universe character Eric is Troped too much on what his actor did in Real Life, than on the character as himself In Universe.
openNative Americans Liking an American President Equals Germans Love David Hasselhoff
I dont think it does. I like the entry itself, but its NOT Germans Love David Hasselhoff. They are from the SAME country? Why was it put there.
Its on Germans Love David Hasselhoff People.
openOffensive Filename
Doing some edits on Ed Sheeran and did a double take on the filename of his photograph. A bit of digging in the history got me this little gem:
"5th Sep '14 12:31:58 AM creekery Is there an issue? Send a Message
Added Diff Lines:
[[quoteright:283:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/anuscocknigger_5477.jpg]] [[caption-width-right:283:The guitar guy himself.]]
Reason: Sorry for the filename, nothing else was working because everything was already taken."
Not cool, regardless of how you might feel about this artist. The N-word is especially nasty. Can someone address? Thanks.
Edited by Exxolonopenchickenpie999 Film
chickenpie999
has deleted several examples
from YMMV.Return Of The Jedi without providing any edit reasons.
They've also changed an example from this:
To this:
openQuestions regarding cleanup efforts.
I have a few questions. I just started a ST Projects thread (The only other Projects thread I started was for the Pokemon Anime's YMMV page before this) and I want to make sure the action itself didn't violate any rules, as well as a sandbox page relevant to this.
- Is there any procedure for making threads on both boards? Unlike TRS or IP the threads don't start locked, but I wanted to know if they need mod permission or other requirements first (The sticky on the STP board mentioned something about discussion form elsewhere, such as ATT. I think that requirement is covered covered by this query
)
- As the cleanup is focused on reorganization, I want to know a few things related to that. Mainly to see if 1 Sandbox/ page is enough for the cleanup.
- Is there a way to view how many characters are in a given page?
- What is the maximum amount of characters a page can hold before becoming a problem? (I think its 400000 max)
openHigh School DxD EX Anime
I have a quick question for those who are familiar with High School DXD. The anime's third season BorN was a setup by Ichiei Ishibumi to create the EX spin-off to fix up the anime's timeline thanks to Loki's machinations; Ishibumi himself later confirmed that any future anime seasons will adapt the light novels after the third season's debacle.
If the plotline of the anime's fourth season gets announced (most likely an adaptation of EX and volumes 9-10), what should we do about the EX entries? I want to bring this up to the community to get thoughts on the matter. Thanks.
Edited by gjjonesopenSpoilers in Fanfic/TheHarvester
Fanfic.The Harvester was just launched today and already has a good number of tropes. Unfortunately, almost all of the tropes have a spoiler on them, with the Designated Victim example completely whited out. I'd fix it myself, but I haven't read the fic, so I'm not sure what would count as a spoiler. Could someone who has go through the page and help me?

I know what Self-Demonstrating articles are, both as a trope and a page. As a trope, it's used in an article to parody said article. As and article, it's a thing describing itself(Such as the Wheatly and G La DOS pages). It also appears that the Self-Demonstrating articles are the mains for those characters. So, how does one make a Self-Demonstrating article for a character? Do you modify the main and it gets nominated Self-Demonstrating, or do you make a separate page altogether?