When you find yourself trying to remember a show (or any works) that's on the tip of your tongue but just out of reach, come here - the collective brain of the TVTropes community can probably help. Post all the details you can remember (examples help). If you're looking for a trope, head over to Trope Finder. Have general questions about tropes? Visit Ask The Tropers!
Okay, here's some more info: the main characters come across a theater troupe, that they later end up joining. The troupe is led by a guy who, as a child, had his hands bitten off by a hippo at the zoo, and while his arms came back in the afterlife, he still likes to pretend they're gone and still wears his prosthetic hook hands (though he finally ends up discarding them when this was revealed to the main characters by accident).
One of the last parts of the comic (and just so you know, this comic wasn't especially long) dealt with the main guy leaving the apartment the three had gotten in the city, after a falling out for reasons I can't quite recall. However, he has feelings for the female member of the trio (as does she for him), and it's obvious that it's eating up at the two of them. After he leaves, he ends up joining a group of hobos, who help him when he decides to crash in on the theater troupe's play. Unfortunately, the girl and another guy ended up switching parts at some point, with her playing a male part and the dude playing a female part, so the main dude ends up kicking the girl in the jaw when he swings on stage from a rope (or cable, I forget) and confessing to (and then kissing) the dude. Thankfully, after giving him a good sock to the jaw, the girl confesses her feelings for him as well, and things end up working out well for everybody. One thing I remember in particular was that the old greeter was, at the end, convinced to go to the retirement village area, though he plans on making things much more lively around there, and the white-haired member of the main trio took over his job as greeter/decapitator of the newly dead.
Edited by JozinIt's "A Divine Dramedy" by Jim Tierney. It was one of my favorites a few years back. Unfortunately, the website it was hosted on (graphiteplayground.com) appears to have disappeared from the annals of the internet.
Here's an archived version of the website, just to confirm: http://web.archive.org/web/20060409232827/http://www.graphiteplayground.com/
And here's the website now, unfortunately: http://www.graphiteplayground.com/index2.php
Sorry for the outcome, but I hope that helps.

There was a webcomic from a while back that finished up pretty neatly. It was about three friends who had all died at once, and awoke in coffins in the afterlife. They were greeted by an old man whose job it was to greet the newly dead, and since apparently everyone is disbelieving of their being dead at first, he's made a habit of decapitating them with an axe to show them that, yes, they are deceased. They end up fine, of course, as any serious/mortal injuries obtained in the afterlife wear off quickly. Out of the three friends, one of them is a girl, one of them is a dude with white hair (I think his name is Noah, or Moses, or some other old Biblical name), and the last, who is basically the main character, is a dude with short dark hair. In this story, the afterlife they are in is pretty much a huge city, with a retirement village-esque area on the outskirts of the city for the older dead (which the greeter man refuses to go to).