Follow TV Tropes

Ask The Tropers

Go To

Have a question about how the TVTropes wiki works? No one knows this community better than the people in it, so ask away! Ask the Tropers is the page you come to when you have a question burning in your brain and the support pages didn't help. It's not for everything, though. For a list of all the resources for your questions, click here.

Ask the Tropers:

Trope Related Question:

Make Private (For security bugs or stuff only for moderators)

12th Mar, 2018 02:00:57 PM

Good idea, although the title seems a bit unclear — it sounds like an admonition not to use time travel tropes.

Something like Trope What Happens Not What You Think Will Happen Is unambiguous (but long I know.) Or maybe Dont Extrapolate The Plot.

Edited by DracMonster
12th Mar, 2018 02:24:48 PM

Good suggestions, but the problem with the last one is that it's not always related to a plot.

What about Dont Extrapolate The Trope?

12th Mar, 2018 02:27:16 PM

Would these not be the beginnings of Implied Trope? Maybe a Downplayed Implied trope or something?

Or Ambiguous Situation mixed with Implied Trope?

12th Mar, 2018 02:56:58 PM

Implied Trope wouldn't apply to any of the examples I mentioned, except perhaps First Girl Wins. But even then, a First Kiss doesn't inherently mean a couple has officially gotten together and that the other love interests have "lost".

In the other examples, the trope just plain old hasn't happened. Either a base is broken or it isn't and either a limb gets replaced or it doesn't.

12th Mar, 2018 06:54:10 PM

Ooh yeah, that's on the mark I think.

12th Mar, 2018 08:09:34 PM

Speculative Troping could also include admonishments against trying to predict the work's tropes based on the trailers, previews, and previous works.

12th Mar, 2018 09:26:12 PM

Excellent ideas!

I'll submit it a bit later.

12th Mar, 2018 10:25:44 PM

Submission made.

Probably still needs a lot of work.

13th Mar, 2018 12:29:31 AM

I agree with crazysamaritan. After all, we have a trope called Never Trust a Trailer.

Edited by GastonRabbit
13th Mar, 2018 01:48:09 AM

How common is this problem? People tend to overestimate the benefits of extra policy pages and underestimate their problems.

13th Mar, 2018 04:45:28 AM

This is currently covered by How to Write an Example - Don't Speculate, Don't Prognosticate.

13th Mar, 2018 05:14:41 AM

^Maybe expanding that to cover the sort of wording that's mentioned in the original post would be sufficient, akin to how Examples Are Not Arguable contains examples of words and phrases that act as red flags for violations of that policy. Doing this and referencing the existing name in edit summaries would be an alternative to changing the name to one of the names mentioned in this thread, but at least one name change happened in the past (the name of Keep It an Example was changed to Examples Are Not General).

Edited by GastonRabbit
13th Mar, 2018 05:33:30 AM

@Septimus Heap: I don't there's really any way to answer that question.

Speculation is one of those cleanup jobs which is often minor or overlaps with other issues, such as removing a few words an example that bloats itself with trivial detail just shy of Fan Wank, or arguing about whether a trope has been implied or not. All of us have probably done this dozens of times without even thinking about it and probably wouldn't even be able to point at each specific time.

Edited by NubianSatyress
13th Mar, 2018 06:29:58 AM

I think the same function can be filled more elegantly with a slight expansion of the Don't Speculate, Don't Prognosticate section of How To Write An Example and a new redirect to that page (Speculative Troping sounds fine).

Edit: another option for the redirect might be Examples Are Not Speculative to fall in with the "Examples Are Not X" scheme (Examples Are Not General, Examples Are Not Recent, Examples Are Not Arguable, etc.)

Edited by HighCrate
13th Mar, 2018 07:21:18 AM

@Septimus: I don't know how common this is with 'actual' tropes, but it seems like a huge proportion of the misuse for certain YMMV pages like Broken Base involves jumping-the-gun knee-jerk stuff. I feel like a mere subsection of How To Write An Example doesn't seem to be cutting it.

13th Mar, 2018 08:02:16 AM

I think you may be underestimating how much good having a redirect specifically for this problem to link to in edit reasons can do.

"General" examples were at least as big a problem as this, and that didn't need its own page, just the Examples Are Not General redirect to give people a clear, easy link to follow to the relevant portion of the How To Write An Example page.

13th Mar, 2018 08:10:25 AM

I agree with nrjxll. My experience is that a redirect to How To Write An Example doesn't solve much.

That page, in my opinion, is so heavily cluttered that I don't see how direct links addressing the individual problems in detail can't be of help.

Edited by NubianSatyress
13th Mar, 2018 03:10:17 PM

Yeah, that page itself may need a repair thread on the forums.

By the way, if someone thinks a trope is going to happen in the future, isn't that Wild Mass Guessing? If so, just insist all such speculation be put there.

13th Mar, 2018 03:47:07 PM

Okay....that's not helpful criticism.

If there's a problem with the page that you think is problematic enough to need TRS before it's launched, then now is the perfect time to be specific so that they can either be addressed or the page can be nuked if it's unsalvagable.

13th Mar, 2018 06:25:22 PM

^I'm pretty sure the first sentence of DragonQuestZ's post was agreeing with what you said about cleaning up the How to Write an Example page.

Edited by GastonRabbit
13th Mar, 2018 07:08:12 PM

It was. Sorry for the confusion.

The rest was stating that if there is to be a message, it's that it's to note that any speculation, even of a trope that hasn't happened yet, is still Wild Mass Guessin.

13th Mar, 2018 07:16:36 PM

I'm sorry. I don't know how I missed that.

As for Wild Mass Guessing, the reason people don't post their speculation there is because WMG is kind of regarded as an "unimportant" subpage. When people post speculation, they're usually subtle about it and try to give it as much legitimacy as they can get away with.

Edited by NubianSatyress
13th Mar, 2018 09:43:16 PM

I've actually argued in the past that it's unfortunate that WMG amalgamates both actual serious speculation about where a story might go and joke or impossible theories - this might be some support for that.

Top