Have a question about how the TVTropes wiki works? No one knows this community better than the people in it, so ask away! Ask the Tropers is the page you come to when you have a question burning in your brain and the support pages didn't help.
It's not for everything, though. For a list of all the resources for your questions, click here. You can also go to this Directory thread
for ongoing cleanup projects.
I think that all the Real Life fluff needs to go from that description. It doesn't help with storytelling and it touches on one or more very controversial and not-agreed-upon subjects.
"For a successful technology, reality must take precedence over public relations, for Nature cannot be fooled." - Richard FeynmanI agree - cut it. That said, I think it does need a SHORT note that the trope is not true in real life and that real victims can respond in varying ways (and that responding in those ways does not make them more or less a victim or ever to blame). Perhaps redirecting toward a Useful Notes, though a Useful Notes on rape and sexual assault would probably be a very bad idea. Maybe a link to RAINN would be much better.
Edited by RevolutionStoneI think that such an Useful Notes page could be good for troping purposes but it will almost certainly need a lock.
As for Rape Leads to Insanity, is there any material beyond the first two sentences that should be kept in the description?
"For a successful technology, reality must take precedence over public relations, for Nature cannot be fooled." - Richard FeynmanI'd say some should be said in the main, including a mention of how complex this is, with no assumption of the likely level of psychological affect being entirely accurate or appropriate: it's wrong and far from helpful to assume that a person should go "crazy", or that they should stay completely in control.
Another thing that could be mentioned is some of the most common psychological issues associated with rape in real life and/or fiction, such as a broad range of phobias, depression, changes in sexual and other behavior, self-destructive behaviors and suicide.

Should some work possibly be done with the page Rape Leads to Insanity? A rather large portion of the page is concerned with real life information that is uncertain or in some cases actually contradicted by reliable sources. The page seems to talk for some time about how "most" rape victims take the event calmly, even though sources have said rape more often than not leads to severe trauma lasting months if not years. The page even goes so far as to suggest that the traumatization experienced is more a result of the person's personality than the assault itself.
A good point is made in the page that expecting trauma and mental disturbance is unhelpful, since expecting the victim to be more traumatized than she or he seems to be can come across as doubt of the account or downplay of the event. However, the opposite is also true: since most victims do experience significant trauma whether they show it or not, it's not helpful to expect them to be normal or suggest that they're personally responsible for the way the event affected them.
Ultimately, it's not helpful to expect people to freak out and claim that the event must not have been so bad if they don't show enough trauma, and it's equally bad to say that people shouldn't be bothered and it's the individual's fault if they can't move on. Neither extreme is really true, both can be hurtful, and both are about real life more than tropes or devices. Would it not be better to include less about the real world, maybe a brief presentation of the conflicting ideas with emphasis on the conflict and absence of clear answers, then focus on the application of this material to specific works?