Bumping this, apparently a link is here
.
Just got done with it and here's my takeaway:
Is it porn? Absolutely. Almost every chapter has a long sex scene included in it, and a couple are almost entirely made up of the sex scene in question.
Does it have a non-excuse plot? I'd say yes. At its core it's a character story centered around two characters struggles and identity crises, with some side characters having subplots of their own, and every sex scene serves a narrative purpose within that story. There were maybe one or two sex scenes that made me wonder what their purpose was other than titillation, which was pretty impressive given there were so many I kinda lost track.
Are there pedopandering concerns? Eh, I'd say not really. The halflings (called Halvin in the story) are drawn with adult facial features and treated like adults by the narrative and in their behavior.
It's pretty mundane porn with plot which I'm pretty sure passes P5 muster. I vote keep.
Edited by 4maskwolf on Aug 22nd 2022 at 7:08:09 AM
Too much plot, character development, etc. to justify cutting. "Pedo-pandering" claims in particular are baseless unless very clearly university-aged-to-middle-aged Hobbits are the breaking point.

The flag here for Alfie was sent with the rationale