There's also discussion of a montage for the main page, so we should wait and see what they decide to do with it. If it ends up changing, we could just move the Quattro pic to this page.
Enough people dislike collages (myself included) that I don't think there will be consensus to use that for the main page.
It is not absolutely forbidden to use the same image on two pages, but, it is undeniably weak. Consider that a big strike against using Quattro again.
Becky: Who are you? The Mysterious Stranger: An angel. Huck: What's your name? The Mysterious Stranger: Satan.True.
I'm just saying that it depends on whether or not the main image changes.
Reaction Image RepositoryKei as in Keitaro from Love Hina. He gets beat up by the girls all the time, all for reasons he's never actually guilty of doing and other complete misunderstandings and over-reactions. I think seeing Motoko about to come down on him with a sword is a pretty good depiction.
Also, it has just hit me that the whole thing with Quattro is starting to affect my judgement of her image in a very negative way. For some reason, the more I see people so adamant about keeping her up as a page image, the more I want to see her removed and never put back up. I don't know why this is, because I've never seen the Nanoha and don't know anything about it.
I like Keitaro (2)
◊ also.
Another one (which has been superbly ignored in the main Oh Crap thread):
Fuguno realizing he now has a Clingy Jealous Girl and an Overprotective Dad (who happens to be his boss) out for his blood, in Yume De Aetara
◊.
Doesn't need context to understand, everything's said in the text.
edited 6th Dec '10 6:55:03 PM by AceNoctali
"Your kindness gives me the presentiment I can be reborn. Now, I want to believe at least in you." - Kaori YaeKeitaro's classic. I'll toss my vote in there.
I like that one for details, but it's three panels and formatting it would be a bastard and a half to get it to fit on the page without stretching it. I don't think it'd have the same impact without the three panels though. Maybe a square formatting job would help it?
![]()
![]()
![]()
I'm a fan of Nanoha and during that last thread I was about ready to give up the ghost just for the sake of cutting the incessant arguing out. I personally am glad that thread's over, as it was far too much debate for my taste. And I was one of the people debating too.
I'll say that Keitaro's humorous and gives me a nice light chuckle, and with Motoko (I think) descending from on-high with a katana, it pretty clearly shows what's about to come down.
edited 10th Dec '10 8:33:58 PM by HayateKusanagi
I still love the Keitaro images but putting another one forward from a recent chapter of Negima.
edited 31st Dec '10 3:45:30 AM by Raso
Sparkling and glittering! Jan-Ken-Pon!That's not bad. And I'm glad you found a new source with decent quality scans.
Fight smart, not fair.That Negima picture is better than Quattro ever was. The frowning lips, teeth clenched, and sweat beads on her face add further emphasis of her expressed emotion. Quattro has none of those. In fact, her mouth being open is part of why I think she was always a bad image.
I still like Motoko about to slash at Keitaro though.
Tempted to replace the Quattro pic with the Chisame pic just cause it shows the "Oh, Crap!" face so much better (I am big fans of both) and just put the Keitaro pic on the anime page.
Sparkling and glittering! Jan-Ken-Pon!^^ He looks more angry and/or focused at firing a Ki Blast of his own than being horrified at the sight of an incoming Kamehameha.
"Your kindness gives me the presentiment I can be reborn. Now, I want to believe at least in you." - Kaori YaeCLANNAD OH CRAP 1
◊ (what about this one, where Okazaki gets cornered by 5 girls)
CLANNAD OH CRAP 2
◊ (or this one, when he realized Kotomi won't help him. Cue Fuko coming and saying she'll make everything "better". Okazaki: NO, SERIOUSLY... STOP....).
edited 11th Jan '11 9:13:48 PM by bhl88
Oh good Christ, Chisame looks TERRIFIED. That's awesome. My vote hands down.
I wouldn't go editing the Quattro picture though, it was a nightmare last time. Leave it where it is and call the whole thing even. I say we set up Chisame on Anime Manga and just be pleased in the smug satisfaction that the Anime Manga picture is better than the main one, heh.
edited 12th Jan '11 6:26:05 PM by HayateKusanagi
I defended the Quattro picture big time but the Chisame pic has all the same qualities that I liked so much in the Quattro pic except its far more detailed.
Well anyway do we want to make a crowner?
Sparkling and glittering! Jan-Ken-Pon!
Crown Description:
Nominations for replacement images:

Main Oh, Crap! discussion #3: https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/posts.php?discussion=kipyz2s3jqd363x85dijf7s3&page=1
Suggestions so far:
- Quattro
◊ from Magical Girl Something Something
- Enel
◊ from One Piece
- Perona
◊ from One Piece
- "Kei" 1
◊
- "Kei" 2
◊
Becky: Who are you? The Mysterious Stranger: An angel. Huck: What's your name? The Mysterious Stranger: Satan.