Their problem with Broly, I think, is that he's uninteresting and flat and a blatant Mary Sue villain.
"He's the most powerful Saiyan ever and can only scream KAKAROT and his entire reason for hating Goku is because his crying kept him awake."
It pretty much goes without saying that one of the four Main Villains of the post-Raditz era is going to get the #1 slot.
- Vegeta
- Frieza
- Cell
- Majin Buu
Exactly which differs from person to person, but you'd be hard-pressed to find any fan who doesn't think one of these four is the greatest villain in DB history.
My Tumblr. Currently side-by-side liveblogging Digimon Adventure, sub vs dub.Majin Boo...good enough.
Rules of the Internet 45. Rule 45 is a lie. Check out my art if you notice.Another I think will make it high on the list is Mercenary Tao
He's basically the first villain that kicks Goku's ass so bad Goku needs to find a plot convenient power up (Also probably the first real enemy - not counting people who are sparring with Goku or trying to teach him like Roshi - to do so without needing some trick like General Blue's psychic powers), which basically sets the pattern for like half of Z. He's also the first villain that kills a supporting character, causing the need for that person to be raised by the dragonballs.
And he shows up by killing the main henchmen/villain of the previous arc with his tongue.
edited 1st Dec '16 10:10:53 PM by Ghilz
I totally forgot about Mercenary Tao. Yeah, both him and King Piccolo will definitely be the high ranking villains from Dragon Ball.
I also think Broly's rank is going to be higher than a lot of people are expecting. Hated as he may be, I believe even non-fans are able to recognize as a character. The Video Games always treat his reveal as a big incentive to buy their games. Hell, the very first thing they tried to hype up about fusions was what Goku and Broly's fusion was going to be.
edited 1st Dec '16 10:12:27 PM by Lionheart0
It could be anyone...like General Silver or Captain Yellow.
Rules of the Internet 45. Rule 45 is a lie. Check out my art if you notice.Well, here you have me
Piccolo's the best villain for me. If it were me making that list, I know at least what my Top 6 would be:
- 6. Baby
- 5. Cell
- 4. Majin Buu (all forms as a whole)
- 3. Tao Pai Pai
- 2. Freeza
- 1. Piccolo (Daimao & Jr)
I'm excluding Beerus (who's an antagonist, but not quite a villain) and Zamasu (who I thought was a great villain, but his arc is way too fresh on my mind).

Wasn't there a rumor that they were going to get Markiplier to voice Broly?