That one would not have revived Vegeta.
...which might actually be for the best in the long run. So yeah, stamp of approval.
My Tumblr. Currently side-by-side liveblogging Digimon Adventure, sub vs dub.You can just add "Except those who worked for Freeza or a Saiyan at the time of death" to the wish.
EDIT: Or the good aligned clause too.
Point is "They couldn't resurrect the city" is a moot point when there's no limit to how complex you can word a specific wish. So long as it's a single wish.
Of course the real reason is Toriyama probably didn't even remember Nappa had existed by that point, let alone that he had killed a whole city, so that point is ultimately moot. Or you can argue Popo, Kami and King Kai didn't think of it, which, isn't impossible either if you jones for a Watsonian reason.
Point being, the only reason is "No one bothered to ressurect them" not "The mechanics of the dragonball and circumstances didn't allow for that"
Edited by Ghilz on Mar 27th 2019 at 8:31:06 AM
Did the people in the city King Piccolo destroy come back? I know Goku went to get back the Dragon Balls so that Krillin, Roshi, and Chiaotzu wouldn't be suffering for eternity as wandering spirits, but I don't remember if the actual wording of the wish included everyone killed by King Piccolo and his minions.
Actually, nevermind, I answered my own question by realizing that we see Giran, Nam, and King Chappa later on, so the wish must have included everyone.
Actually, if I am not mistaken that is not a hard and fast rule. It was only mentioned when talking about resurrecting everyone Freeza and his men had killed, and it was specifically because of the sheer number. We don't know what the number limit is, but if the wish was more restrictive (say, "every Earthling Nappa has killed", it is not impossible that these people could have been brought back.
Yes it did. Popo specifically asks for them (though weirdly he says 'a planet far away' rather than Namek).
The other characters specifically talk about Namek, and Popo's wish doesn't make sense to include multiple planets within it.
And after granting the wish Shenron says he revived those on Planet Namek.
God also specifies that if the wish was made to revive all of Vegeta and Nappa's victims, it'd be limited to one year.
Edited by Saiga on Mar 28th 2019 at 7:11:17 PM
Bulma could just go back in time herself, guys. She doesn't need Yamtrunks or Gohan to do it.
Bulma goes back in time, she gives Goku the heart medicine herself after he defeats Mecha-Frieza the way he did in the original timeline. Then he doesn't take it, his illness acts up during the android fight, and Android 19 kills everybody. The end.
...
Okay, so maybe I need to work on my definition of things working out in the long run.
My Tumblr. Currently side-by-side liveblogging Digimon Adventure, sub vs dub.Good point. I mean, his reasons for not taking it (the symptoms never came up, and he was told not to take it until then) weren't too bad, but this is Goku we're talking about. You'd think Bulma would want to be sure.
Plus, his symptoms never coming up were something they never anticipated, so sticking around to observe things would be a good idea.
Then again, Bulma coming back herself would damage the timeline even more than Trunks did, and either of them staying would just add to that.
One Strip! One Strip!Also, wouldn't Piccolo have been able to handle 19? He was doing just fine against 20.
Also, Piccolo's existence also shuts down any downside to reviving Frieza's goons. The only Frieza goon who's anything resembling a threat is Ginyu himself (thanks to CHANGE NOW), and he's still a frog. Everyone else would be absolutely schooled by Piccolo.
Edited by Larkmarn on Mar 28th 2019 at 10:57:27 AM
Found a Youtube Channel with political stances you want to share? Hop on over to this page and add them.<shrug> Toss up. Piccolo was able to take Gero easy after Gero had already drained him almost dry. Likewise, Vegeta was able to take 19 after 19 was already hopped up on (weakened) Super Saiyan energy. I don't think Toriyama put a particularly large amount of thought into how much of a buff energy absorption gave either of them.
Likely because at that point in the writing the two were supposed to be defined by the fact that the heroes could beat them regardless of the threat the posed (though that's more of a Doylist answer).
Also, presuming that 19 and 20 existed in Trunks' timeline, and he just didn't know about it due to being like a year old at the time, Bulma could have warned them about the energy absorption and such.
Edited by KnownUnknown on Mar 28th 2019 at 8:03:19 AM

They could go with 'revive all the good people killed in the last year's but they hadn't come up with that wording until the Boo arc.
Also, they didn't even know that Shenron could do mass revivals until their first attempt