starmate3
Come to the place where party is king!
from Piñata Island
Since: Jun, 2024
Relationship Status: [TOP SECRET]
starmate3
Come to the place where party is king!
from Piñata Island
Since: Jun, 2024
Relationship Status: [TOP SECRET]
starmate3
Come to the place where party is king!
from Piñata Island
Since: Jun, 2024
Relationship Status: [TOP SECRET]
Total posts: 4

Here’s how this will work. Select three avatars in your gallery to discuss where each Sonic game, mainline first and then the side games and then place them in the List between S-tier and E-tier, with S being the best and E the worst. This video that I linked above is where I got the idea for this and we go in release order for this, so after my three do Sonic 1, the next poster will do Sonic 2 and so on and so forth.
So:
(Sonic, Luna, Cream)
Alright dudes! Let’s get this show started! And we start with Sonic 1.
Miss Loud, I have to say that this first game was, for its time, good.
You have Green Hill and Starlight, but you also have some mixed quality ones like Scrap Brain and Marble. Though to defend those stages, it was Sonic Team’s first attempt at making a game
OK, that’s fair. But, you also had 3 acts for every stage, not to mention that Scrap Brain Act 3 is just Act 4 of Labyrinth and honestly, the good ending wasn’t anything to write home about.
Still, it was pretty decent for the first attempt at least, so what verdict do you guys think we should give it? Me, personally I’m thinking A-tier.
I agree with Mr. Sonic, this game definitely deserves A, but not S.
I would’ve given it B honestly, but A’s fine.
Final Verdict: A-tier
Next set of three avatars will discuss Sonic 2.
So grab a stick and take a swing! Do the Piñata thing!