No. All names have meaning of some sort. It's only a Meaningful Name if it has meaning story-wise, even if that meaning is just basic symbolism or a reflection of personality.
Working on: Author Appeal | Sandbox | Troper WallSomething like this sounds like it could only work in the sense of "you expect this from them but no" subversion or aversion, but that's just Non-Indicative Name.
"..."Or even Artifact Name.
Edited by SamCurt on Oct 8th 2024 at 4:33:27 AM
Scientia et Libertas | Per Aspera ad Astra NovaRight. Virtually all names are derived from an existing word/term, and if people take Meaningful Name as "the name has some meaning", every single named character would have a Meaningful Name, which is obviously not the case.
This is indeed very widespread misuse of Meaningful Name on character pages, especially for Japanese works. Entries will be written as trivia about what the name means, even if it isn't relevant.
Reminds me of the one ATT where someone wanted to use it for a voice actor. We can probably just delete that sort of thing.
Working on: Author Appeal | Sandbox | Troper Wall
Technically it's listed as NRLEP, but the rationale is similar: aside from ROCEJ concerns, it mentions that the name has to be picked by an external creator to have story meaning.
I take that to mean both Watsonian and Doylist intent are fine?
If you mean, there's an overt In-Universe justification for the name, versus one that's interpreted from the text as applicable to the story without being acknowledged In-Universe? Yeah, I think both count.

A question that's randomly hit me, can something be a meaningful name if the meaning has nothing to do with the plot or the character's activity.
So like, for example, a character called Hunter who does nothing that would relate, either literally or figuratively to hunting, predators, or such topic. Or a character called William who does no protecting (William means protector, roughly speaking).
The specific example that brought this to mind is a recent addition to Transformers One. Orion Pax' name. Orion is a mythological hunter. Pax means peace. He's hunting for peace!
Except that he isn't? Like, his society is at peace. He's trying to bring opportinity and equality to people. The reason he's named that is because the character has been named that for 40 years now, through various interation. They didn't pick this name to match the plot or his personal journey.