Suggestion: Bound And Gagged

There's been discussion off and on about taking some of the subpages for Bound and Gagged off the "no pic" list, and to that end, here's suggestions for some of those subpages:

For BoundAndGagged.Webcomics, from Pacificators: panels 8 + 9

For BoundAndGagged.Video Games, from DIDNapper: 1◊, 2

For BoundAndGagged.Music: This◊, taken from this video

For BoundAndGagged.Live Action Films, from Batman (1989): 1◊, 2◊

For BoundAndGagged.Live Action TV, from Batman (1966): Batgirl◊

For BoundAndGagged.Disney: 1◊, 2◊

For BoundAndGagged.Comic Books, from Red Daughter of Krypton: 1◊

For BoundAndGagged.Anime And Manga, from Ranma ½: 1◊, 2 (looks to be a screencap that someone posted to their dA account)

Thoughts?

Edited by Willbyr on Jan 11th 2021 at 10:00:29 AM

Finally opening this one.

• BoundAndGagged.Webcomics: Good with me.

• BoundAndGagged.Video Games: Both images seem to be Fanservice (especially considering the creator's DeviantArt gallery), and this very issue is the reason why the subpages were left imageless for so long.

• BoundAndGagged.Music: Could we get a shot with more of a focus on the girl? (As a side note, that music video is extremely 2011.)

• BoundAndGagged.Live Action Films: 1.1.

• BoundAndGagged.Live Action TV: Good with me.

• BoundAndGagged.Disney: 1.2.

• BoundAndGagged.Comic Books: Good with me.

• BoundAndGagged.Anime And Manga: 1.2.

Edited by jandn2014 on Jan 7th 2021 at 6:06:23 AM

They look good to me, I think I'd go with 2 on the video game example, (actually looking like it's from a game, the other looks like it could be from an anime), 1 for film, and 2 for anime, on the grounds it's easier to see and looks to be higher-quality as well.

I agree with that the video game examples are too much of a Fetish Fuel. I find the live action film examples too bad quality. For anime, I prefer the 2nd. For webcomics, I think that 1 panel is enough.

For the Disney (1.2), Comic Books, and Anime & Manga (either) suggestions.

The Music & Live-Action suggestions are of poor quality, the Video Game ones has too much Fetish Fuel going on.

Ambivalent on the webcomic one. The panel has too much on the captor rather than the captive.

Edited by Adept on Jan 8th 2021 at 3:57:22 AM

To Webcomic, Live Action TV, 2nd Disney, Comic Books, and 1st Anime.

What do we do with any of those subpages that aren't found in this thread? Do we keep them at no pic, BUPKIS them, or neither?

I’m open to other suggestions.

For the record, the pics from Batman '89 are of a VCR-quality video being played on a TV monitor; the actual film clip is pretty sharp as I recall. Barring other ideas, I can try to get a wider crop of the scene.

Edited by Willbyr on Jan 7th 2021 at 5:01:16 AM

Here's a different suggestion for the Video Games subpage from an animated short for Sly Cooper:

That can work.

Approving the latest suggestion.

To 9

Okay, that's plenty of consensus for that one; it's in and tagged as "don't change the pic". Any other votes on the other suggestions, or other ideas?

Edited by Willbyr on Jan 11th 2021 at 10:11:59 AM

Bump. Any votes for the other suggestions?

I've hooked a crowner for the other options. I'll see if I can get a better shot from the music video and post it.

EDIT: Posted a crop of the first one and a shot from later in the video where she's about to be freed.

Edited by Willbyr on Jan 16th 2021 at 6:41:32 AM

Votes bump; 5 in the green right now.

Okay, calling the crowner. The options that ended up with consensus are in on their respective pages; the tags have been updated from "no pic" to "don't change the pic" for consistency with the others, and the respective lists are updated on Image Pickin' Special Cases. Captions for any of them? Ideas for the other subpages?

For webcomics, panel 7?

Caption suggestion for B&G A&M; "She got her, and her little cat too!"

I thought about that one before but wasn’t sure if that one panel was enough. I’d be okay with it.

Edited by Willbyr on Jan 24th 2021 at 10:18:34 AM

Looking through these, I just noticed the image on the western animation page has a rather obvious network bug on it.