Needs Help: X Pac Heat

This image◊ was downvoted in the Suggestion thread. Other ideas or suggestions?

I thought this one was on point...could we get a wider crop showing more of the crowd?

Yeah, I don't get why this was downvoted (and I'm not just saying that because I recommended it). How else are you going to convey these reactions with a picture?

EDIT: This is the original uncropped photo.

Edited by thecarolinabull01 on Feb 6th 2020 at 1:03:14 PM

That's more like a page quote in PNG form. I'd say replace the current quote by this one, it's much better. And BUPKIS.

Yeah, it seems too page-quotey.

Then how does one convey X-Pac Heat in a photo?

Or is this just one of those pages that a photo isn't really possible for?

The context of it being on sign puts it out of "might as well be a page quote" category from me. I think it's a decent image, maybe a bit better uncropped.

I guess I understand why others don't think it's a good fit. But the crowd sign was the only way I figured that this reaction could be illustrated in a picture.

It's kinda hard to convey "Fans booing the person and not their character" in a photo.

If anyone else has a suggestion, I'd like to know. Otherwise, maybe the page should remain image-less.

It's too page-quotey. It would have been less so if the crop of the sign showed that they were in a booing crowd and/or at a wrestling event, but as it is it's just...words.

It's a better page quote than current, though.

Agreed.

Make it the page quote

It's already on the quotes page. Should I just move it over or does that need to be discussed to? (I'd assume so).

Yeah, if we get enough consensus to make it the page quote it can be moved off the Quotes page and replace the current.

BUPKIS indeed.

I agree with BUPKIS. There is no point in using a bad image just because we can't do any better.

I like the uncropped version.

Crowner's hooked.

Votes bump; one in the green.

This one's more than clear. The current quote's been swapped with the quote of the sign from the quotes page, the page is tagged, and the BUPKIS list is updated. Locking up.