Based on this post and the comments it got.

Basically, you pick some of your avatars and post them in a certain order. Then, the next poster has to create a story about it.

Example:

Poster 1:

Poster 2:

As a girl struggles with a eldrich abomination, she calls the Monkey King, who turns it into a cookie.

Now start!

Lady Galadriel arrives to scold Loki for being holed up in his bedroom when he should be doing yard work. Loki defiantly returns to reading the latest Warrior Cats book.

Some random lady gives nonsensical advice to a government spy, said random lady's friend calls out said spy (and her comrade) for not having friends, said comrade may or may not have been a dictator that probably declared war on the random lady's country but the spy says that's true tho.

Human pony drools at the sight of Ho Yay, while a K-pop guy tells her to stop. Another pony then screams “Life is pain” at the sight of human ponies kissing.

Teacher tells a fairy tale of a large duck that contanied a city full of decadent nobles, raucous criminals and vigilante sociopaths.

Edited by KeironCioran on Oct 16th 2019 at 7:36:27 AM

An Oracle uses a Veve to aid a Cool Old Guy to understand a Bara Furry with a Chinese philosopher and writer while a trans musician writes a song based on the event.

Edited by KJsixteen on Oct 16th 2019 at 7:55:58 AM

bump

An epic tale of weirdness, girls and Pokemon all in one package.

four girls get powered up by the shards they found and now they gotta defeat the villainess riding her mount, a winged beast, sent by apparently a normal girl

Ponies and ghouls try to understand some weird symbols and wings.

A bizarre love triangle between several superheroes and a monkey king.

an anime that starts with a Beach Episode then it eventually becomes a retelling of The Call of Cthulhu

Some creatures are dancing while a woman watches and a horse cheers on them. Then there were skeleton horses and a mammal god turns them human.

Edited by Oggy123 on Nov 7th 2019 at 11:46:03 PM

A Sugar Bowl superhero cartoon that ends in a cosmic horror story.

Well, this is over-the-top.

Edited by AdeptGaderius on Nov 8th 2019 at 10:12:05 AM

a Bildungsroman that progresses into a Postmodern pastiche of cosmic horror stories involving ancient precursor gods.

A guy with a cool hairdo travels through time and meets many obscure historical figures.

A comedic journey of anthropomorphic animals in the underworld with Charles Darwin.

Some girls save the world from beings of darkness. Turns out the antagonist is just basically a terrified psychic girl.

Edited by Oggy123 on Nov 9th 2019 at 9:53:14 PM

A cast of cute characters meet up and play with planet Earth until two Knight of Cerebus arrive and destroy the party unleashed by a two girls.

Two adventurers are attacked by a dinosaur, luckily, two explorers save them. It turns out the dinosaur is sent by a ghost girl and a clown.

Edited by Oggy123 on Nov 11th 2019 at 4:31:53 PM

I'd join:

A fluffbal tries to win the heart of a fairy princess from the dark knights controlled by a petulant child and to win her heart, both the fluffball and the child tried to find a sunflower that only grows in full-moon.

Edited by ElfenLiedFan90 on Nov 12th 2019 at 8:29:15 AM

green-haired sword boi and will smith must go to big city to stop Eldritch Abomination, ugly clown mascot and evil radio lady

A girl is just walking, then Twilight Sparkle sees her and is confused, and her confused yelling startles a bird person to hit his nose which somehow hurts his whole body and causes a Gainax Ending

A Dystopian Story about a corrupt government with forced propaganda and a fleet of monsters. Our hero is oblivious to this and thinks this isn't happening.

Edited by TabbyGirl4 on Nov 12th 2019 at 2:28:37 PM

A Magical Cat Girl gets trapped in a cube with a fantastical kingdom inside of it, and our heroine meets the ruler of the kingdom, a seemingly kind queen with her cookie squire on her side. The queen then tells our heroine about a diabolical witch who controls people with her trumpet, and so our heroine is aided by a pair of romantic nekos who approach King Dedede and his army, who tells our heroines that it's hopeless to confront the witch before giving them a syringe filled with magical moon dust.

Edited by KJsixteen on Nov 12th 2019 at 1:04:02 AM