Follow TV Tropes
Yeah, these examples are wordy but don't actually say anything. The only example I feel confident with is Does This Remind You of Anything?.
See, I disagree with Does This Remind You of Anything? having sufficient context because it's only a quote- it doesn't actually explain anything about the context for said quote.
Anyway, I moved over tropes that I think are salvagable from Characters.Project Genesis (which I feel now can be cut) over to Roleplay.Project Genesis, rewriting a couple based on what I could glean from the ZCE tropes on the page. Thoughts?
Though I still think City with No Name is funny, I'm unsure if it can be considered contextual.
Anyway, the page does look a lot better now. I was too quick on the draw to suggest we cut it wholesale, I guess.
edit: tried to ping to get the cut declined but I wrote the name wrong so whoops
So, in the meantime, any thoughts on Cumberholmes Roleplay Twitter Community? Just looking at it hurts my brain. I wanted to wait for Macron before touching it, but I want a second opinion on if it's worth trying to salvage, or if it should be cut. I don't know what tropes have context because I haven't had the patience to read everything.
Edited by WarJay77 on Oct 11th 2019 at 10:24:07 AM
We could use some vocabulary to refer to "an edit made to a page that changes page content that isn't merely cutting misuse, repairing links, removing nonexistent links, or fixing formatting or grammar".
When looking at pages with like 95% ZCE but still the minimum of tropes, might we consider other factors such as inbounds, quality of grammar and formatting, and recent insert-above-quotation edits?
Edited by Tabs on Oct 11th 2019 at 8:33:16 AM
Yeah, I do think there are some pages that, though salvageable, aren't contributing anything, and would be better off just cut. If nobody who'd edited the page in the last several years bothered to fix the major problems, if the people who made it have vanished into the aether, and if the page is just poorly written, I wouldn't mind cutting them even if they're technically "OK". If nobody gives a damn about the page...
...And yeah, we need a term... "Non-cleanup editor"???
Characters.Project Genesis has been cut; the Roleplay.Project Genesis request has been declined.
This is late since I take long breaks from the site but I didn't create Cumberholmes and it's not on my record of created pages (and Oreochan was my first handle that I used 2009 - 2013). It was a cleanup edit. Pretty sure all I did was move the page to off the main/ namespace so probably didn't even read the page but don't really remember because that was 5 years ago. Should have said thats what what I was doing back then.
But yeah, I think it should probably be cut since it's such a mess and the people who are familiar with it are long gone.
Edited by MacronNotes on Oct 13th 2019 at 9:52:50 AM
It looks to me like Project Genesis has more than three valid examples.
It does now.
Oh, that makes sense. I agree, it's a mess, and I'm not sure anyone would care to clean it.
Anyway, thanks for letting us know!
Edited by WarJay77 on Oct 13th 2019 at 10:23:01 AM
Edited by Tabs on Oct 14th 2019 at 11:51:19 AM
A good few months ago (sorry for not popping in sooner!) I was sent a message about the Discord roleplay Daily Mysteries and was asked whether or not it was public. The answer to that, and the other RP page that had been made in the same vein Hope's Requiem is that these were groups that were once public, but unfortunately the invite links have both been lost to time. As far as I'm concerned, they're kind of both messes of pages I regret creating with plenty of empty slots and I'm 100% for them being cut.
Edited by HoneyButt on Oct 14th 2019 at 2:14:14 AM
Late reply, but oh well. Thanks for coming in. I think we'll probably move it to Darth Wiki rather than cut it outright, but I'm fine either way, honestly.
I'll try and get some of the M's cleaned up tonight and get this thread going again.
Apologies for my absence- I've had, and still have, a lot on my plate to deal with, alongside general exhaustion from the colder weather and procrastination from it all to play video games instead
Civil War sounded familiar, and a quick check confirmed that it's hosted on these forums. I've added a link to the page. Not sure when I'll get back to cleaning, but I am still invested in the effort!
Hahaha, I understand completely.
This Is Why We Fight:
I'm gonna move it to Darth Wiki soon since the last non-cleanup edit was in 2015.
Edited by Tabs on Oct 31st 2019 at 10:58:30 AM
The forum :P
Darth Wiki move sounds good to me.
Here it is, one convoluted search involving acronyms and deviantart later. It doesn't seem to be like mgcomics, where the site as a whole is blocked off from Google searching, so I dunno why it wasn't showing up 🤔
How in the world do you... ? This one is saved from the Darth Wiki-ing. Perhaps it fell off the Google rankings since it hasn't had a post since 2015?
Edited by Tabs on Oct 31st 2019 at 4:10:17 AM
It was a bit of a ride. Putting in "This is why we fight" "Sydney" into Google got me a link to a deviantart from one of the players. I didn't find any links, but they used TIWWF as an acronym, so I figured I'd try that next. That got me to the forum, where there was a link to a TIWWF website... that didn't work, but searching on the forum itself eventually turned that up.
It really makes me appreciate when a page has a distinctive title, character name, or quote to make searching easier
Good work, Whizzerd!
A few more
During my Spoiled Sweet cleanup, I ran into this: Despair Despair Despair Mania. When I was at it, I started commenting out examples.
Then, after I was done, I noticed it's the dreaded Roleplay/ namespace. The main work page is stub with no tropes: Despair Despair Despair Mania. Analysis.Despair Despair Despair Mania is its duplicate. It also has a very weird quote tab: Quotes.Despair Despair Despair Mania.
There are some tropes with context on the character sheet, though I haven't read it, so I don't know how accurate these are. Should they be moved to the main Roleplay/ page?
I'd cutlist everything, to be honest. What do you think?
Move the entries from the characters pages to main, cutlist all the subpages.
Yeah. Otherwise, the main page is tropeless. I would simply copy over just the character tropes with sufficient context, but if you want to be charitable, you can copy over the entire character page including descriptions and drop it in a "Characters" folder.
EDIT: Actually, I can't even search up this title. All Google gives me are the two TV Tropes pages. Some troper named korzuhuba was responsible for the entirety of these pages. So before doing any more work, it's probably easiest to give it the Darth Wiki treatment and cut list everything else.
Edited by Tabs on Nov 6th 2019 at 9:37:36 AM
Community Showcase More
How well does it match the trope?