Needs Help: Fandom Berserk Button

I was following the Trope Repair Shop thread, and the consensus is that only factual errors and misconceptions are valid examples. Currently the trope is undergoing cleanup.

Reflecting that, we may need to look at the current image, as the half involving Pokéfans would be declared invalid due to mentioning what generation is better in that person's eyes. The Whovians half is valid as it is a misconception, so maybe some strategic editing is in order, or if we can find the source, select another panel to replace the Pokéfans half. Alternatively, we can find something else. Thoughts/ideas?

Previous thread

http://loldwell.com/?comic=return-of-the-nagging-of-the-nerds

Source comic.

Hmmm, guess we can stick to just the Whovian panel. Looking at the unused panels, there's one that's a "they should've done this" (which I'm uncertain as to if it qualifies), one that mentions a disliked adaptation, one that's like the Pokéfan panel (generation pref), and one "Oh, I skipped to a certain act".

edited 8th May '18 1:47:58 PM by Berrenta

edited 8th May '18 2:26:01 PM by eroock

I'm good with that.

4.1

4.1.

Sure

I agree that the Doctor Who part works on its own, so I'm going with 4.1.

4.1 is good

I can go with that.

Good enough. The single panel's swapped in and tagged...the full comic's linked in the examples so we're good to go on that. Caption?

Old pic:

"And no, his name isn't 'Doctor Who'."

That's decent.

Depending on which series you're talking about. He's been credited as such quite a lot.

I like it. True, he's sometimes been credited as Doctor Who, but the fan reaction to calling him that is still negative. Maybe we could add a note?

This one's been gathering dust for a while and I'm not seeing enough consensus on the suggested caption (I'm not crazy about it, for the record); locking up.