Follow TV Tropes
It looks okay to me.
Bringing up this example from The Dom Reviews:
From YMMV.Pokemon Adventures:
Non of them does a good job in explaining why they are that.
All suffer from lack of context.
Go-Toubun No Hanayome
Base-Breaking Character: Out of the quintuplets we have Nino and Itsuki for different reasons:
Seems to dwell in the negative with zero positives
I wasn't aware that any of the characters there caused wars to erupt in the fandom. And I'm always dubious when it's about a character described as "bland". That usually doesn't inspire fan wars as much as lack of interest.
BrokenBase.Clarence has nothing remotely salvageable IMO
The first point is basically general reception. Some people love the show, some people merely like it and others hate it. That's meaningless.
Pretty much the rest is knee-jerk reaction to episodes and borders on Zero-Context Example.
The ones about "Where The Wild Chads Are" and "The Break Up" are just negative reviews with no mention of the other side of the argument.
The penultimate point alludes to middle ground of the argument.
May I send it to the cut list?
Edited by Silverblade2 on Jan 12th 2019 at 4:07:22 PM
Cut the first two, at least.
Edited by RAlexa21th on Jan 12th 2019 at 7:04:29 AM
Cut it all and let mod sort it out.
Seriously, though, cut it all.
Edited by AnotherDuck on Jan 12th 2019 at 4:16:29 PM
From Batman: Bad Blood
Seems to dwell on the negative and doesn't guve an even debate. However, changes to Batwoman backstory could be put in They Change It Now It Sucks.
Edited by WhirlRX on Jan 12th 2019 at 12:10:59 PM
A few of these sound like uncited Unfortunate Implications examples in disguise.
A lot of the Warrior Cats recap pages have off-looking Broken Base sections that'll need glancing over sometime.
So it's been 4 days, any chance I could get a response regarding the example I brought up above? x14.
This was added to YMMV.Fate Grand Order.
Base-Breaking Character: Boudica. Due to her debut in the Septem along with her design, many fans were quick to write her off as The Scrappy, not helped by their considering her inaccurate to the real Boudica in exchange for being a Cool Big Sis, and preferring her more vicious Avenger form. Just as many fans were quick to defend her, enjoying her Cool Big Sis status with most characters, noting her personality in Septem is less inaccurate but rather a result of the writing for Septem in general, and protesting that her Fetish Retardant status only exists in her first stage, while her Avenger form is an even bigger example, looking like she came out of a BDSM dungeon. There is virtually no middle ground regarding her. The closest thing being that most can agree that she's a Tier-Induced Scrappy.
Does it do a good job of being fair on both arguments? I see it as being still close to complaing.
Fate/Grand Order player here. Boudica really is base-breaking like that.
Edited by DipperPines on Jan 24th 2019 at 5:15:30 AM
So it's been a week, any chance I could get a response regarding the example I brought up above? x18.
So it's been a week and 3 days, any chance I could get a response regarding the example I brought up above? x19.
No. There is no chance. It's been a week and three days. Use your best judgment.
Anddrix, the examples you bring up are almost ALWAYS misuse or at least lacking context. You don't really need a second opinion to cut them. I've said this repeatedly before.
Edited by nrjxll on Jan 20th 2019 at 1:41:12 PM
Absolute cut the Batman: Bad Blood examples. They're all one sided criticims.
From Donald Duck:
While these two statements are true they seem entirely too mild to count, it's not even really a conflict. Some people like his voice, other's don't.
Community Showcase More