I think the opinions on that might be a bit more diverse regarding pros and cons about petri-dish creations and bio-engineering modifications...
That aside.
I see, however, we really don't know how High-End got Muscular's quirk, considering that that guy is in jail as of now...so...
How did that genetic material get involved in this creature?
(Besides, in order to create a masterpiece of a new race, it must have the ability of reproduction in order to become self-sufficient. Intelligence is another factor of course...and if the Doctor is a mad scientist to that degree, there might be a reason to why there is a female High-End in development among the test tubes...)
I wouldn't be surprised if the good doctor has had genetic material on hand of all the members to use for Quirk replication thanks to All for One
I'm with dan in hoping those Noumus aren't anyone we know, because this really drives home how fucked it is to become that.
... Actually makes me wonder if the one Noumu who first challenged All Might is still alive and in custody.
Edited by vicarious on Mar 21st 2019 at 2:25:08 PM
Not only does the Doctor look like Eggman, he even likes to go evil santa laugh ("HO HO HO HO") like Eggman does too.
If Chikao Otsuka had still been alive, I bet the anime team would have casted him as the doctor.
Watch SymphogearI know. I said if if he HAD been alive, he probably would have been casted as the doctor as a sort of Casting Gag.
Watch SymphogearBut seriously, I'm just going to point out that we've seen "Ujiko"'s face before, at the same time we saw All for One, in fact. Which kind of makes me wonder what's the point of framing things like this, but whatever.
As for how he can have the same Quirk that All for One used, All for One did say he lost a lot of the Quirks he had after his first fight with All Might. Maybe after he "loses" them, they go back to the original owner, and Ujiko happened to get his back?
Edited by LSBK on Mar 21st 2019 at 2:33:52 PM
Or maybe at some point he stole another quirk that would seem useless until combined with another. Someone had the ability to duplicate quirks. But they're duplicated in place. Meaning the owner of the quirk just has a redundant copy of their own quirk that makes no difference whatsoever. But with All for One, since he can move quirks around, it's a broken quirk when he has it.
Some people can have multiple Quirks. One for All is technically two different powers, and it may be presented as one, but for all intents and purposes Shoto has two Quirks.
Bewitching EyesBut we were told that the Quirks could merge together into one when we were getting the run down on what All for One does. Evidently, that's what One for All is.
Kind of the same thing that happens when parents Quirks merge into a new thing for their kids, except without the sex.
I don't really think it's that hard to get - we've been told that "Quirk Factors" are things that are flowing through people's bodies or whatever. Presumably having multiple Quirks means having multiple, separate Quirk Factors that can be activated independently for a specific power(s). Whereas with One for All two different Quirk factors merged into one, and so now it's just one Quirk doing both of those things.
Edited by LSBK on Mar 21st 2019 at 2:55:40 PM
Isn't that the drug is Vigilantes that makes Quirks stronger? No, not that. I mean he's getting samples of people's Quirks from their DNA, copying it somehow, so the person gets to keep their Quirk, while they inject the copy into someone else. Or something.
All For One still probably would make doing that easier, though.

Isn't really much of a narrow down now, is it?
Besides, who to say they're not petri-dish "children" (aka "homunculi"), grown from scratch through quirks, donor genetic materials, and the reason for them being smarter, might not be due to being more advanced, but for being born with multiple quirks from the get-go and better adapted to them overall?
Just a thought.
In that case, the Doctor wouldn't have to resort to abduct people anymore, beyond getting genetic samples of quirks to infuse in the creations...