I'd like to step in and say the "immunity to becoming a Witch" thing in any form is kind of a stupid idea in a Madoka RP. It kills the tension, honestly, and if any magical girl could make that wish, don't you think the Incubators would have done something about it by now? I mean, it would make the whole system fall apart, and immortality is the go-to wish for anyone with half a brain (not that it helped all those DBZ villains who had that half brain and nothing else...).
On top of that, the only capable of making a wish so great that it thoroughly broke the system was Madoka, and she was a Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann living in a world of Gundams and Eva units in terms of her magic potential.
edited 20th Apr '14 10:14:22 PM by KSPAM
I've got new mythological machinery, and very handsome supernatural scenery. Goodfae: a mafia web serialI see it as less "100% immune to witchification" as "immune to witchification through magic overuse.
Magical girls become witches when either conditions are fulfilled :
A) Uses Magic too much. B) Despair reaches a certain threshold.
With the caveat that those two things occupy the same metaphorical "despair bar". Use magic too much, and your dog dying would witchifies you. Losing everyone you ever loved, and some small magical tricks would witchifies you.
Also, the turn magical girl closest to you into a witch sounds like an ample cause to form a lynch mob.
I'm not so much against the immune to witchfication part of it as much as the 'some other random Magical Girl gets turned into a Witch instead without them being able to do anything about it'
This girl plays it badly and Witches and the girl who has maintained her Soul Gem clear, has a nice day and such suddenly has her soul explode and gets turned into a monster while the one responsible just walks away revitalized? That's really unfair and this is Madoka Magica we're talking about.
I'm pretty sure people would want to hang her even before the magical girl serial killer, and that's saying something
(cellphone so excuse my sparseness) Actually that sense of unfairness and the whole -kill the aberration- was what i was aiming for. However given the controverse I might offer a couple of other options.
- Her wish of eternal beauty turns her catatonic,unable to even move unless someone heals her instead of a witch.
- There is no second ability and she survived for that long.
I'm thinking that considering the circumstances and controversy, the second option may be the best. I've read several different theories that raise the question: would a Mahou Shoujo age after contracting at all anyways? Considering they're now pretty much animated corpses, would the aging process effect them at all? Considering thus is my RP I'll decree that they don't and you can say that she's simply been lucky enough to not overuse her magic or succumb to despair.
Ok final verdict is that Ouroboros is nuked from orbit, if the sheet stays as is right now you're in. Your girl has simply been lucky enough to avoid magic overuse and narcissistic enough to not care about anyone else enough to despair loop into being a Witch
edited 21st Apr '14 1:44:39 PM by Gladonost
/人◕ ‿‿ ◕人\ Will you make a contract with me?Why... would she ever need that? I mean if it was phallic-shaped I'd get it, but... it's a grenade. It's not phallic. Not unless she stuffed a WW 2 potato masher in there, in which case I think it might be time I stop asking questions...
I've got new mythological machinery, and very handsome supernatural scenery. Goodfae: a mafia web serialI think magic might be a bit more effective than a single grenade. I mean, Homura had a shit-ton of them, but I don't think one's gonna do much to a Witch.
I've got new mythological machinery, and very handsome supernatural scenery. Goodfae: a mafia web serial@Atomic: Changing the sheet right after I say its accepted as is, isn't cool. Change it back. If you want to add or change a detail run it by me in a PM first, do not go back and change the sheet then ask permission.
edited 22nd Apr '14 6:45:44 AM by Gladonost
/人◕ ‿‿ ◕人\ Will you make a contract with me?

So many magical girls for Junko to latch to/idolize!