That's been my own off-and-on theory: A Servant Race that outlived their masters.
Or Turned Against Their Masters; there'd be a certain irony if White Diamond rebelled against her creators, only to have her creations turn against her in turn.
My headcanon is that White Diamond is or was a Genius Loci of a dead world. She's been reduced to a planetary parasite who moves on to other worlds and sucks them dry. Homeworld isn't actually her true homeworld but merely her latest victim.
At some point she got tired of doing all of this by herself and created the other Diamonds (who would then create other Gems).
If this reminds you a bit of Ego the Living Planet...it should.
Edited by M84 on Jan 11th 2019 at 11:41:18 PM
Disgusted, but not surprisedHe's a non-plot thing to speculate about: Will "Battle of Heart and Mind" end with an Iris Out?
The show's largely phased them out this season* , and tended to use a Smash to Black even for episodes that end of a gentle note (like "What's Your Problem" or "Made of Honor"). But then "Lars' Head" brought it back after eight episodes in a row without, so it might be used if the last scene is more of a breaking point.
They actually did use it for every season finale so far but the fourth, which was an entirely serious Cliffhanger. (P.S. I noticed the iris in "Mirror Gem" changes to a flashing diamond at the last season.)
Edited by thatother1dude on Jan 11th 2019 at 12:06:30 PM
> If this reminds you a bit of Ego the Living Planet...it should.
I'm reminded of Brainac absorbs things as data and has loads of different drones running about
Wouldn't surprise me if the origin story for the Gem race as whole involved them being one gigantic being that was spilt apart and has harvesting planets in the hope of rebuilding itself.
Edited by Ultimatum on Jan 12th 2019 at 1:37:12 PM
have a listen and have a link to my discord serverI hope they don't add another enemy source, like the gems were building conquests and geoweapons to fight off this bigger bad. This late in the game to introduce and defeat someone completely new wouldn't be satisfactory of an ending as we then try to figure out THEIR backstory or we don't connect to them because of how sudden it is. Its a mystery enough with the gems. Don't Kuja/Necron us.
Edited by ObligatorySarcasm on Jan 12th 2019 at 9:35:54 AM
-Witty line-I'm confident they wont introduce another race the Gems are fighting in the present tense, I could see them going for a past war scenario where they were fighting off a threat to their race and the constant focus on building up their forces is left over from that period,getting them to accept it's no longer necessary to focus on fighting an enemy that's not there anymore wouldn't be too surprising
have a listen and have a link to my discord server@ObligatorySarcasm: We don't know how many more seasons the show is going to have; we know there'll be at least 1 more for sure, but rumor has it the total is going to be at least 7 and possibly more, and they can't all be townie episodes. Between having to set up a new Myth Arc in a shorter span of time than we might prefer and having no driving plot at all, they're pretty much going to have to go with the former if they've been renewed for more than 1 additional season after 5, assuming Battle of Heart and Mind was written as Grand Finale.
Now if they do go down this sort of route, it almost obviously won't be some Always Chaotic Evil Giant Space Flea from Nowhere, instead we'd probably get a situation amneable to diplomacy, and to me the best bet for that would be the Gems' estranged creators, assuming they have one.
It wouldn't be any more sudden than White Diamond being introduced, displacing Yellow and Blue as the Big Bad, and having the conflict with her resolved in the space of 5 episodes, which is what would have to happen if this was originally meant to be the series finale.
OTOH, it's also entirely possible they got renewed early enough in production to rewrite the outcome of this arc from what they originally had planned to allow for a sixth season that continues the current Myth Arc. I think that's the most likely possibility given they had about 2 years to rework things, but we won't know for sure until the episode airs.
Edited by CaptainCapsase on Jan 12th 2019 at 2:15:48 PM
Yeah, the assumption was always that White Diamond existed.
They kept her conspicuously absent, probably just because they wanted to hold off on her big reveal, but in-universe because White doesn't seem to get directly involved with almost anything now, but that White Diamond existed was always the first thought.
You never know,something like that might be addressed in a throw away line,especially since it looked like Pink did some experiments in her room,could be they're very convincing fakes in the place of the real real ones,the real ones being hidden away in the chest inside Lion's mane
have a listen and have a link to my discord server![]()
No, she wouldn't. Rose doesn't think changing identities absolved her of guilt. And leaving them in stasis even after the war would be something bad she did as Rose, not Pink.
And what would the point of putting them in the chest when she had plenty of room and left Bismuth's bubble hanging around?
On the topic of the chest, I'm starting to think whatever's in there will be somewhat important, but not tremendously so.
Edited by thatother1dude on Jan 13th 2019 at 1:51:09 PM
> And what would the point of putting them in the chest when she had plenty of room and left Bismuth's bubble hanging around?
There's a lot of them compared to the one bismuth she bubbled away and leaving in a chest means she has them all left tidily in one place
have a listen and have a link to my discord serverI mean I really don't think the Rose Quartzes existing proves anything about "Rose's" identity as Pink Diamond. Its already the assumption that Rose had unique abilities, and that the other Rose Quartzes didn't. Because otherwise why would Homeworld bubble all of their healing Gems?
Maybe the voice might give it away, but even within the caste there can be very different inflections.
And I can't see Rose deciding "I need to get the Rose Quartzes away from the other Diamonds" and also deciding "I'm going to do the exact same thing they were doing and leaving them in stasis just to cover my ass."
The Crystal Caverns A bird's gotta sing.P.S. Joe Johnston
The Mario music makes it 10x funnier.
see my completed Tangled (Varian) fanfic collection! https://archiveofourown.org/works/24467056/chapters/59049532

One possibility is the oft-cited "Gems were AI/artificial lifeforms" theory being true and the Gems' creators returning.