Well, I don't want to defend Yellow. So I'll just say I think it's unlikely, they'll go that route, 1) because I don't think they'd have anyone seriously try it because it's a morbid concept and this is still a show for kids. And 2) because if either of the Diamonds actually wanted to do it, unlike Pearl they wouldn't fail at attempting it, they'd go through with it. And Steven has Plot Armor so that's not going to happen. I could see Blue and Yellow having a fight over the idea, maybe.
Edited by xanderiskander on Jul 7th 2018 at 12:51:32 PM
I'm wondering whether the gems' wedding clothes were material or made via shapeshifting. On one hand, Peridot's dress and shoes disappeared when Yellow destabilized her. On the other, Peridot's inability to shapeshift probably extends to her clothes, Bismuth refers to her armor as "the nicest thing she owns" (implying she couldn't shapeshift a new outfit), and Pearl is seemingly reusing the tuxedo she got in Empire City.
Has that power just been quietly retconned out of existence? I can't remember the last time it was used, and there's been several instances where gems put on human clothing (the baseball uniforms in "Hit the Diamond", Ruby's cowboy outfit in "The Question") instead of replicating it with their powers.
I rewatched the next episode promo and noticed that, when Blue is holding Steven in the palm of her hand and crying Tears of Joy, her powers are still making him cry along!
Changing your clothes is a facet of shapeshifting. I don't see why they would retcon it. In fact, I believe there's actually an issue in the new run of comics where Amethyst shapeshifts into her outfit from "Too Short To Ride" while keeping her regular form, so it's still canon there.
As for Peridot... I think it's just an oversight. Plus, her dress falling with her gem wouldn't be as dramatic as her gem just hitting the sand.
Jawbreakers on sale for 99¢Changing clothes was just a thing...
Rules of the Internet 45. Rule 45 is a lie. Check out my art if you notice.They made a big deal out of it...by which I mean it was a flashy transformation sequence in season 1 which all 3 of them did.
But in "Last One out of Beach City" Pearl had to physically put on pants and a jacket because reasons.
Sooo...
Rules of the Internet 45. Rule 45 is a lie. Check out my art if you notice.I honestly don't see what's the problem of them using clothes. Rose had fricking armor hidden in her armory (so Bismuth wearing physical armor makes sense).
Shapeshiftng clothes usually involves rearranging their color schemes. They can just easily shapeshift any extraneous elements in their standard designs and put on clothes if there's some need for it (like the baseball disguises, or wearing formal attire for the wedding).
Also, Steven and Connie and the comics establish that worn physical clothing is merged when fusion occurs, which is what happened to Garnet's clothes.
Peri's clothes were brought for her to wear,although that raises even more questions,like how do you fit it over her head,unless involved taking the dress apart and putting it back together while its on her
Edited by Ultimatum on Jul 8th 2018 at 9:50:08 AM
have a listen and have a link to my discord serverRIP Peridot's dress
I'm more curious about her changing out of her regular clothes. If she just took them off, did they disperse or just hang around until she was poofed? Or maybe she put the dress on over them. She's clearly wearing the same leggings, though the straps should also be visible.
Greg buying Ruby's cowboy outfit makes me wonder if Ruby didn't learn to shapeshift her clothes (or at all), even though Garnet did. Which brings up the question of how a fusion's experience transfers back to their parts.
It's also possible that Ruby and Sapphire just appreciate the fun of wearing something that they didn't create. Garnet's visor isn't part of her form like Peridot's, I don't think (it seems to be stored, like their weapons). Plus there was that bit of Garnet giving Peridot the thumbs up for trying on some of Steven's clothes.
It's like Steven insisting on getting Garnet to wear golf pants that one time
And I imagine the feeling of wearing something is different from shapeshifting clothes that would just be part of a Gem's light projection
Edited by Bocaj on Jul 8th 2018 at 12:58:24 PM
Forever liveblogging the AvengersEven if the weapons aren't actively created, Garnet morphed her glasses into swim goggles once, and when she transforms into Steven she makes them shorter because there isn't a third eye to cover.

You're mincing words. Of course that denial has reasoning in every case. But what's important that that denial is consistent, and that Gem's hesitance to believe Steven's true nature is consistent. In terms of my point whether the gems literally thought it was impossible or whether they more precisely thought it "probably wasn't true and instead was more likely that Rose was dormant or altered" isn't the point, because both reactions still show that that hesitance to believe is typical of Gems, and regardless of which either is still a problematic option should the Diamonds act the same way everyone else has.
Similarly, if "hairs breadth" bothers you, replace it with "came close" or simply "almost did" or something. My point doesn't change: Pearl, someone close to Rose who knew what she was doing, considered ripping out the Gem to get Rose back. The Diamonds, who never understood or cared about Pink's ideology at all and don't have any reason at all to care about Steven specifically, wouldn't have that same reservation.
Yellow Diamond's response to things bothering her or being in the way of what she wants has consistently been to blow those things up.
The entire point of us getting all the talk about Yellow being analytical and logical and well reasoned was for the payoff of us actually finding out what she's truly like and learning that she's petty, temperamental and destructive.
Edited by KnownUnknown on Jul 7th 2018 at 9:42:45 AM