![]()
![]()
What description? You mean Garnet's statement that Pink Diamond needed to die "for me to exist"? Because that doesn't indicate anything about whether it happened before or after Garnet's creation. I'd say it makes more sense for it to be before, because otherwise there doesn't seem to be much reason for Blue to be there in the first place.
Anyway, I'm not trying to whitewash Blue Diamond at all or argue that she isn't a bad guy or try to argue she had some justified reason for ordering Sapphire's death. I just don't think Garnet's story provides any proof that she's a cold, unfeeling monster either, considering that it's a stylized bedtime story where Garnet herself plays the part of Blue Diamond.
edited 23rd May '17 9:50:26 AM by DrDougsh
![]()
I believe it's possible that she was more cruel and overtly malicious before Pink Diamond's shattering and now her grieving state makes her somewhat nicer. Also what I meant by Garnet's description is that her tone sounded like she witnessed the event herself or at least was around when it happened.
I think learning all that of their kind were imprisoned because of one them shattered their own diamond in a 1000 year rebellion would be a really hard to thing accept
It would probably on a sad note when they have to bubble them
![]()
edited 23rd May '17 10:28:53 AM by Ultimatum
have a listen and have a link to my discord server@49576 I personally think that's more likely than not. That seems like such an obvious source for drama, angst, and character development that I'd bet on it.
Of course, that's at the Zoo, and I thought that Aquamarine was taking Steven to Homeworld, so I don't think it's coming up just yet.
Also, if you go with the theory that the Famethyst is ripe to make a collective Mook–Face Turn and join the Crystal Gems, I could easily see them releasing all of the Rose Quartzes (if you're about to cut bait and are looking for as much help as possible, asking the group that was imprisoned for things they didn't do isn't the worst idea).
Huh... completely different thing that I just thought of... Rose was always shown with pretty much the same form, right? All of the other gems have had various tweaks to their outfits, but Rose always had that particular dress with the star-shaped window on her navel. I kinda wonder why she never tweaked her look like the others did.
Reminder: Offscreen Villainy does not count towards Complete Monster.What it comes down for me is that if they want to do a separate redemption vs. evil thing with the Diamonds fine. But the reasoning people are going for with hit happening, just comes off as very shallow and without nuances. And considering nuanced characters is one of this show's strongest points, that's very strange to me.
![]()
![]()
![]()
I said somewhat nicer, the Affably Evil trope exits for a reason.
edited 23rd May '17 10:56:22 AM by Kaiseror
All he wants to do, is see him turn into, a giant non-binary individual, giant non-binary indiviiiiiiiidual
Forever liveblogging the AvengersIt's easier for timing...
Rules of the Internet 45. Rule 45 is a lie. Check out my art if you notice.

edited 23rd May '17 9:38:07 AM by xanderiskander