There seems to be something special about Bismuths, they can create unique Gem weapons/structures nobody else can. pearl even says they've not come back to the Forge because there was no need to. So if anyone can modify a unique Gem weapon, I don't doubt she could, if that's indeed what she's doing.
Also her mention of building arenas and spires gives me a imperial Rome vibe.
Bismuth: You really don't remember, huh? Rose Quartz changed my life. I came to Earth thinking this was just another colony. Build another arena for important fighters to fight in, build another spire for important thinkers to think in, and then, I met her. Just another Quartz soldier, made right here in the dirt, but she was different. And she was different because she decided to be. And she asked me what I wanted to build, and I'd never heard that before. And Gems never hear they can be anything other than what they are, but Rose opened our eyes.
She did try to use the Breaking Point on Stephen, so that pun makes sense.
Rules of the Internet 45. Rule 45 is a lie. Check out my art if you notice.The thing about the breaking point is that it is kind of useless. So it kind of distracts from the rest of the episode.
It might have better if the weapon Bismuth made was the same as what corrupted the gems. That could actually make a difference in the war.
When life gives you lemons, burn life's house down with the lemons.@darkabomination: The mention of intellectuals paints Homeworld different than I expected. Or at least past Homeworld—Lapis did think current Homeworld was way worse.
In direct combat, I don't think it's supposed to be any better than any other weapon, just more lethal. Between Rose's Sword and the Breaking Point, neither was more likely to win the battle, but Bismuth winning would have killed Steven, while Bismuth could still come back.
edited 5th Aug '16 12:40:56 PM by thatother1dude
It is worst than pretty much any weapon I can think of. The range means it has to be shot point blank, the enemy can easily dodge it, it has to hit the gem to be lethal. It would be easier to proof them and then shatter the gem. There was no way it could change the war for the better. It kind of might have worked on Steven since she didn't need to shatter his gem to kill him.
edited 5th Aug '16 12:45:29 PM by higurashimerlin
When life gives you lemons, burn life's house down with the lemons.It'd instantly poof them anyway if it misses...
Rules of the Internet 45. Rule 45 is a lie. Check out my art if you notice.Not to mention there's always the possibility of the Breaking Points being upgraded into something more effective and devastating.
Latest blog update (November 5th, 2022).At this point I'm not sure if I want to continue this Jasper-Bismuth discussion or let it die. note
I'll be blunt about my feelings. Also I try to stop myself from commenting on everything or we end up with essay: I can't help but find these complains about beefy women a bit "strawy-graspy". I mean we have a female beefy villain who is cool and treated seriously. She actually has much batter chance at redemption than your average beefy, intimidating villain . Bismuth is another well written beefy woman. She's cool, likable and complex. Hardly a real villain,her bubbling is treated as very tragic. Even better chances of redemption. These are not common characters. They're more interesting and multilayered then muscled women you can find in most shows. Oh, and the same show already has covered numerous other diversity issues including genderless character. And that's not enough?
I mean I have issues with stuff too. Whether it's small (boy teams need token girl, but girl teams never have token boys), medium (hitting a woman is shown to be bad, even when she's a villain ) or big (domestic violence is always portrayed as something that only men do) I could easily get offended all the time. Or I could learn to go with flow and accept every little victory I get. I would say that Jasper and Bismuth are a little victory to say at least. And yes, I know that Steve got me covered in all issues I mentioned above, thank you very much.
edited 5th Aug '16 12:58:00 PM by Sunchet
You can't know the flaws of a weapon like this without test, but Bismuth has some bias...mostly because Rosey wouldn't let her use it.
Rules of the Internet 45. Rule 45 is a lie. Check out my art if you notice.Whips and helmets do not make good weapons, either. Rule of Cool.
The more I think about it, the less effective Bismuth's weapon actually seems. I mean, putting aside the fact that you have to manage to somehow aim right at the gemstone with the Shattering Point in order for it to work (although, it might also work if you just hit some part of the body, as in it gives you one-hit kills... but didn't Rose's sword basically do the same thing?), what real advantage does shattering a Gem have as opposed to bubbling it? Was the concern that Homeworld forces could get to the Gems and unbubble them or something? (BTW, since the war was presumably before the temple was made, where did they keep all the bubbled gems?)
edited 5th Aug '16 1:15:42 PM by DeathsApprentice
When we're done, there won't be anything left.It takes less time to shatter than it does to bubble...which you wouldn't be doing it the middle of a war due to it leaving you vulnerable to enemy attack.
Rules of the Internet 45. Rule 45 is a lie. Check out my art if you notice.@random: Oh, that is true. I guess in the middle of war, they wouldn't really have time to bubble the Gems. So does that mean they just left them there to fight other soldiers? That seems pretty likely. Well, then I guess Breaking Point is less useless than I thought.
Some analysis about Bismuth and her actions in her eponynous episode.
Yeah, after thinking about it, the Breaking Point just seemed to be a plot device to give Steven an "I'm a fighter, but I'm not a killer" moment, as opposed to an actual weapon. If she came up with a weapon that could shatter multiple Gems at the same time in a small radius, or in rapid succession, now that could've given Steven a moment and be versatile weapon.
Maybe Bismuth could've made a weapon that launches small metal projectiles at great speed from a distance.
"The cruelest thing you can do to an artist is tell them their work is flawless when it isn't." -Ben "Yahtzee" CroshawBasically how live casualties are treated in real life, except there's no imediate need for medical attention.
edited 5th Aug '16 1:46:08 PM by thatother1dude
I got it the second time it rolled around. I then forced myself to stop thinking about it when I thought to look up where in Earth's crust different gems form.
I wonder if the Breaking Point would have come across a little more... realistic if it had been some sort of directed sonic weapon? Might have been a little on the nose, but I think it would have been more believable.
Me and my friend's collaborative webcomic: Forged MenSpeaking of "upper-crust gems", here's an interesting theory about them.
