Monster Girl Encyclopedia - 5P ONLY

We fucked up on this one.

I think we've all seen enough evidence that this is pedoshit. This can be our recount vote. My devil-head remains the same.

Yeah, I'm gonna roll with the devilhead, too. The descriptions for "Alice" and "Fairy," among others, pretty much confirmed this.

I'm in agreement.

Well, that's three. I'm still a little on the fence myself, but not enough to come up with a decent argument to keep. Cut it and lock up this thread.

Unless someone has a better solution, that doesn't lose us some 6,000 inbounds?

edited 8th May '12 3:26:49 PM by Discar

Do we even want inbounds for stuff like that?

Sorry, was at work.

Whether we want inbounds for this seems to be a moot point, since there doesn't look like there's any way to keep them. There's no author page or Bleached Underpants version to redirect to. I mean, unless you want to redirect it to Cute Monster Girl, which...isn't an absolutely horrible idea, but I don't think it's a good one either.

I voted the Devil Head.

I heard of this, and read some of the cards and comics, when it was beginning to get noticed. I didn't remember paedo elements then, but this being a large hentai community there's bound to be some eventually, and lo now they exist.

Even ignoring that, it's pretty much porn.

The inbounds... That's a shame, but we're going to have to let it go. It's not in keeping with our guidelines, and, to be slightly on the cynical side, those inbounds are only going to invite more uncomfortable gushings.

edited 8th May '12 10:51:26 PM by Catalogue

Like I said before: Cut it and lock up this thread. I think we're done here.

Wait, apparently Living With Monster Girl is by the same group, and has a non-porn version. That needs to be looked into, and if it gets restored, this page can be redirected there.

Indeed, we are.

Wait, what?

edited 8th May '12 11:13:54 PM by Komodin

Apparently. I was going to read it, but I'll do that in the morning.

Reading Living... just now, I'm more inclined to set the Devil of Porn on it.

It's not all mindless porn, but they're all buildups to some (rather sentimental) sex elements. It's not final, but yeah.

Yeah, I already gave it a Devil of Porno. Too much explicit content, not enough plot to make up for it.

So it's a Horny Devil?

Or a Porny Devil, as it were.

You guys oughtta take that show on the road.

Nah, with this audience there's no chance of getting hit with beer bottles.

Regarding Discar's suggestion to restore the Living With Monster Girl page but limit it to the non-hentai "Daily Life With Monster Girl" story only. If the panel agrees, then Monster Girl Encyclopedia and Monster Girl Quest could be redirected to Living With Monster Girl.

edit: re-posting my response from that thread:

That "Daily Life With Monster Girl" is about as clean as sexual Rom Com's get. There's no actual sex in the two chapters released thus far, just a few panels where the Lamia girl is topless. The romantic comedy and "strange species integrating into human society" aspects far outweigh the sexual stuff.

I'm in agreement with this.

(Though it might be better to just create a page for Daily Life With Monster Girl instead, and redirect all three of them to that with explicit instructions to keep the trope list to Daily Life only.)

edited 9th May '12 5:58:56 PM by Meeble

Hi guys. Is this any closer to being resolved? I'm trying to clear out the resolved pages on the the "pages pending for perusal" list. Thanks!

Will, mon, right now, the voting for this work is a perfectly even split. We're just waiting for the final vote.

Whoops, my fault, I never voted. Well, that's three devil-heads now. These Monster Girl things are like weeds, you whack one off and another one pops up. So are we going to make a new page for that Daily Life with Monster Girl thing?

...that's what you just voted on, man. The Bleached Underpants version. I mean, you didn't close it up, so I guess if you agree with that, you can put "Restore under Bleached Underpants only."

Well, personally, I wasn't quite sure what we were voting for on the tool after thinking about it for a bit after the fact. Where we voting to restore the actual Living With Monster Girl page, and limit it to examples of "Daily Life With Monster Girl" only? Or were we voting to create a Daily Life With Monster Girl page?

If it's the latter, I don't particularly think we need a vote in the queue for that, just general agreement in this thread that we're good with going that route.

Right, I was wondering the same thing Meeble is asking about. I did click "close," but it doesn't always work right. I'll do it again.

Pretty sure it was put on the cue for the Bleached Underpants version only. I thought we actually voted to cut the h-version, not that it was just chopped off in the first round of cuts.

But yeah, if we all agree here the Bleached Underpants version is fine, then we don't need to deal with the tool.