The Place for Purging Porn and Pedo-Pandering (AKA P5 flag evaluations)

I'm not sure it has that, though - it's just known for being an exceptionally dumb attempt to use Sex Sells for an unremarkable biking game (and the lawsuit that ensued, but even that's a bit tangential).

Oh cool, reports page changed up. Looks nice. Gave an angelhead to Can You Spare a Quarter?

Yes, we just pushed some updates to the system. Still working on a few other things.

Hey, I can actually see it while on Night Vision now

Awww, I miss the low-res demon and angel heads though. They were charming.

Same. They were nice and cute but the new icons look nice too. I don't like that only 10 results display on a page. Makes going through the backlog more tedious.

I looked into Enzai. The page has been deleted because a ban evader made it as the original got axed. Now it needs votes to note the deletion and lock the page. It's an erotic vn. I checked out the ova and it's very graphic even with the pixeled genitals. Porn with a main character of dubious age. Devil head.

Edited by DrPsyche on Mar 24th 2021 at 9:20:29 AM

Not P5 but how about 25? I thought that 50 would be too much.

25 is a good number.

Should Sonic's Ultimate Harem and similar lemon fanfics be listed on SoBadItsGood.Fan Works or not? Ultimate Harem seems to be just porn with an Excuse Plot (and has underage characters). The listing of Tails Luv-er's fanfiction should also be reviewed. For example, My Rival's Brother has a 19-year-old Silver and 13-year-old Tails being in a romantic relationship (and kissing!!!!). Another example would be To Love Yourself, which has a 16-year-old Modern Sonic having sex with a 12-year-old Classic Sonic (eep!!!!).

Also, should my joke about Silver's Image Song "Dreams of an Absolution" being a song about sex on DarthWiki.Intercourse With You be removed, because Silver is only 14? I think it's okay because teenagers having sex is a thing (I first added the example as a 15-year-old), but I want to be sure.

Edited by PrincessPandaTrope on Mar 27th 2021 at 1:24:47 PM

If something is pretty much porn, it shouldn’t be on this wiki. However, I don’t think Age-Gap Romances between teenagers are banned. The same applies to teenagers having sex, as long as it’s not hardcore. We already went over this back in December.

Edited by jandn2014 on Mar 27th 2021 at 1:18:16 PM

So I cleaned out ScrewYourself.Fan Works for general examples that fit my newly-launched Alternate Self Shipping instead, but there's still examples on the page that might need to be cut due to lewdness as a good deal of these fics appear to be porn. A few examples:

• The Wizards of Waverly Place fic ''Selfportrait has Alex having sex with a doppelganger she created in order to paint a portrait of herself. Looking this over, the part that fits the trope is entirely the pornographic section, and the fic itself appears to be a short porn oneshot with an Excuse Plot. Not helped by the character being 17.
• The Orphan Black fic "One step, Two steps" sees Sarah save Beth's life at the train station and the two become close, concluding with Sarah having sex with Beth to help assure the other of her sense of worth. Skimmed this, and it doesn't seem primarily pornographic, as the sex only really happens at the end of the sixth chapter.
• The harem fic The Power of Seven sees Katie Bell use a time-turner to give Harry the equivalent of a Twin Threesome Fantasy as he has sex with Katie of the 'present' and the Katie from an hour in the future, but the older Katie also kisses her younger self at the start to confirm that it's safe for them to do this. We've discussed this fic a few times before and I still think it needs review.
• The Captain America: The First Avenger fic Except it Abide in the Vine features some multiverse comics!Bucky-on-movie!Bucky action (with illustrations). Comics!Bucky even calls it masturbation when Sam finds them obviously post-coital the next morning. This is about 27,000 words and only rated M, not E, so I assume it's not all porn.
• One of the well-known example is Tea of Sagittarius series, where the original Kyon is accidentally genderbent into a female version, which made Haruhi almost freak out in happiness to the point that Mikuru and Itsuki suffers same fate. Long short story, Haruhi unconsciously summons male Kyon from another world as well. Regadless, out of curiousity, pride, and self denial they began to explore the world of sexual perversion in secret, taking advantage of their current state and both insist that this would count as masturbation instead. It wouldn't be so bad if this ISN'T about Kyon & Kyonko we're talking about, as someone commented: Don't know about the fic but the comment seems a little eh.

  Comments: My blowjob can't be this psychological.

• In one parody fanfic Trixie ended up having a 5-way with her reflection, a clone, a future version of herself, and a robot with her likeness. And to further complicate things, the story closed with a male version of her from a parallel universe walking in. For some reason I can only access a single SFW chapter which doesn't contain all of this but still fits the trope. I'm not sure if the inaccessible material is pornographic.

Edited by mightymewtron on Mar 27th 2021 at 1:11:12 PM

About the last one: FIM Fiction hides all chapters/stories labeled "Mature" unless you go to the Options menu to access Mature fics.

The Falcon and the Winter Soldier Episode 3 "Power Broker" was reported for:

Advertisement autoplayed with sound, despite any settings I have on.

Going to delete it because it's outside of the purview of this thread.

I brought it up before but it never fully got addressed, so I officially flagged Trope Names For A Porn Parody because, as much as I love sex jokes, it feels out-of-place on a wiki that doesn't trope porn movies to list a lot of detailed ideas for porn movies based on tropes. It's not even written in a very tongue-in-cheek way.

Edited by mightymewtron on Apr 4th 2021 at 3:16:00 PM

Yeah, it's definitely an oddity that's for sure. It's only laying out scenarios rather than something like detailed fanfic. The site catalog's sex tropes (which is fine, media uses lots of sex and intimacy tropes) but in this case, the page doesn't seem necessary, just a weird collection of sex jokes without any purpose to the site, but then again that's a lot of Just for Fun pages, this one just deals with sex so it sticks out more.

Oddly enough it feels a lot like Troper Tales.

Edited by DrPsyche on Apr 5th 2021 at 8:56:48 AM

The weird thing to me is that it's barely even jokes. Some of it reads like unironic porn plots. Of course, all porn is a little bit silly, but these don't even read like parodies of porn. A few examples that just don't read as very tongue-in-cheek to me (though the tongue is definitely somewhere):

• Ancient Egypt: The newly crowned Pharaoh grows bored with his many wives and concubines and prays to the gods to give him something to satiate his endless lust. He then sees a slave being abused by his master and, suddenly feeling empathy for the slave, insists that he stops and buys the slave. The slave is made into his own personal servant attendant and they both eventually fall in love.
• No Woman's Land: In a dystopian future where heterosexuality is considered a criminal offense and the genders have been divorced from each other on a national scale. One day, a man ends up discovering a woman far into male territory looking for her husband, eventually striking an illegal sexual-relationship of their own. She discovers that her husband has long since died for being a political prisoner and the man tries getting her back to the Female territory for her own safety.
• Rabbit Magician: A Hentai OVA about a teen boy finally confessing his feelings for a girl that he likes, only for her to reveal that not only does she like him back, but that she is a member of a race of magical, inter-dimensional bunny women that burrow into our world to find a mate, her true form similar to that of a Playboy Bunny. After becoming boyfriend/girlfriend and lose their virginities to one another, she moves in with him, using her magical powers to try to help him in their everyday lives (with mixed results every time), with her many, many, many siblings showing up to check up on her and end up becoming the boy's Unwanted Harem. If the OVA is popular enough, an extra episode is made showing that the two have gotten married, as well as having a litter of bunny-girls that proves that their sex-life is as healthy as ever.

Don't get me wrong, some of these sound like interesting plots, and I'd love if somebody could preserve some of these ideas elsewhere cuz they could make funny sex comedies (not the ones I linked, necessarily, but some of the other entries are pretty funny). It's just not fitting for this wiki.

And even the ones that might be tongue-in-cheek just seem....a little too far.

• Backstabbing the Alpha Bitch: In which the resident Alpha Bitch gets gangbanged by her girl posse after going a bit too far. And at some point, she gets pegged by the Beta Bitch's strap-on. My main concern with this is that the Alpha Bitch is almost always a young teenage girl.
• The Diaper Change: A high-budget Infantilist movie. An unusual, supernatural event regresses half of the adult population into adult babies, their bodies staying the same age but unable to do anything adults can do, with the other half of the population behaving as though the first half are their own babies. I don't think I need to say what the issue with this is.

And this isn't a 5P issue but some of these are already sex tropes (like Twincest) and in that case, what's even the fun in that?

Edited by mightymewtron on Apr 6th 2021 at 3:27:32 PM

That page was brought up before, and I didn't see any justification for it when it was. The Troper Tales comparison seems somewhat apt.

If nothing else I removed the entry for The Diaper Change on the basis of fetishizing infantilism, which probably violates the pedo-pandering rule.

My only question is if this is a P5 issue. I have no idea what a Just for Fun page counts as (trope vs work), and prior to this, only works were to be flagged and reviewed. Tropes went to TRS iirc.

I can easily take it to TRS for discussion instead, but I wasn't sure if this counted as a "trope" either. This sort of JFF always felt more like on-wiki creative works to me, and I rarely saw JFF taken to TRS (only tropes being made JFF after TRS).

It's honestly been years since I participated in anything on TVT so you probably have a better idea on this than I do! [/Sincerity]

The gray area here probably allowed the page to grow the way it has, tbh.

Me, I would send it to TRS first.

Could someone other than me with knowledge of Hunter × Hunter check this entry on its fanfic recs page?

Olivemeister's fics

• Recommended by lettergirlmj
• The content is split mostly between heartbreaking tragedy and really hot porn. There is no in-between. The collection of vignettes that take place in the Harry Potter Universe are especially worth a look. Olive mostly focuses on the relationship between Gon and Killua, but the Kurapika/Leorio pairing has made a few appearances recently as well.

If the Killugon fics are aged-up, it's likely fine if it's not 100% lemon.

Edit: Skimming the userpage, it seems like Gon/Killua is mostly romantic and the more explicit ones involve Kurapika/Leorio, who are both of age (17-18 and 19-20 throughout the manga, respectively). Still, I'm a bit wary.

Edited by ccorb on Apr 10th 2021 at 7:28:07 AM

Not familiar with H x H, but honestly if the entry didn't even mention porn, I think it would be an ok addition. Recommending an ao3 author who has more SFW than NSFW should be fine.

Silent Hill was reported for having an image unrelated to the game. That is... odd. What even is the image exactly? How long has that been up, SH 1 is a fairly well-known game. Not within the purview of this thread, but strange all the same.

More reports of pages with autoplay ads. Misreported again it seems.

Edited by DrPsyche on Apr 23rd 2021 at 9:01:27 AM