The Place for Purging Porn and Pedo-Pandering (AKA P5 flag evaluations)

To me fanvid:Touhou should be an easy angel.

A small correction, The Spiderses has 2 angel heads, not 1. And Maka Maka has 0 angel heads, not O.

It should; all it really needs is a cleaning.

Oh, thanks for pointing those little errors out.

Here's another small update:

• Page 1:
  • The Spiderses: 2 Angelheads, 2 Devilheads.
  • FaCe ThE StRaNgE: 2 Angelheads, 1 Devilhead.
  • Bliss Stage: Love Is Your Weapon: 0 Angelheads, 2 Devilheads.

• Page 2:
  • Ironwood: 1 Angelhead, 2 Devilheads.
  • Touhou: 2 Angelheads, 1 Devilheads.
  • Noodles: 0 Angelheads, 2 Devilheads.
  • Cybersix: 2 Angelheads, 0 Devilheads.
  • Morefuyu: 0 Angelheads, 2 Devilheads.

• Page 3:
  • Jungle de Ikou!: 2 Angelheads, 0 Devilheads.
  • Sengoku Rance: 1 Angelhead, 2 Devilheads.
  • Iron Virgin Jun: 0 Angelheads, 2 Devilheads.
  • Kanojo no Kagi wo Akeru Houhou: 2 Angelheads, 1 Devilhead.
  • Sundome: 2 Angelheads, 0 Devilheads.
  • Animamundi Dark Alchemist: 2 Angelheads, 0 Devilheads.
  • Da Capo: 2 Angelheads, 0 Devilheads.
  • Showgirls: 2 Angelheads, 0 Devilheads.
  • Wicked City: 2 Angelheads, 0 Devilheads.

Page 4:

• Spunky Knight: 0 Angelheads, 2 Devilheads.
• Shiro: 0 Angelheads, 2 Devilheads.
• Maka Maka : 0 Angelheads, 2 Devilheads.
• Hoshizora no Memoria: 0 Angelheads, 2 Devilheads.
• Kamidori Alchemy Meister: 0 Angelheads, 2 Devilheads.

Could I direct the panel toward Time Braid next? I've kind of been waiting since, like, mid may to get it reviewed.

Sure. What should we know about it?

We are currently working down our queue from oldest to newest. That said, I'll read it...

The work page has nothing sexual that I can see.

From the fic, a "Sexy Technique" which seems just to be a name of a ninja technique is the only problematic thing so far in the 1st chapter.

Nothing in chapter 2 so far.

Chapter 3 has something that looks like a rape scene done to the narrator - but seems to be very clinical.

4 also has nothing.

Chapter 5 has something about breasts - the narrator is grabbing under someone else's top.

Chapter 6 also has this Sexy Technique - "amazing breasts and the most incredible legs"?

Also, that narrator looks like - easy to titillate to me.

OK, so far I can say not porn. How old are the people involved and to which audience does it aim?

edited 15th Jul '12 1:09:27 AM by SeptimusHeap

I posted a big thing about it back on page 130:

https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/posts.php?discussion=13349331300A11026600&page=130#3228

I'd say it's most definitely Not Porn and whether or not it's pedopandering depends very much on how you react to the main character. She's treated as an adult throughout most of the story, it's text based so she doesn't appear to be a child really, but her age is 12-13 at the start of the loop, and there is a problematic relationship with an older woman.

The fic is flagged as mature, so theoretically 17+ (Also, are you reading-reading, or skimming?)

edited 15th Jul '12 2:16:05 AM by NineThePuma

Mostly skimming - not really interested in ninjas. That said, I do have a way to pick out specific things.

Ah, then you're probably going to miss out on any of the content that might be questionable.

The problematic relationship is in Chapter 3, and isn't really touched on again until much later.

Indeed, the 3 chapter scene looks more like a Bound and Gagged scene that happens to be connected to this "Sexy Whatever Ninja Tactic" thing.

Sexy Jutsu is canon to naruto =V The effects as given in the fic aren't. It's a physical age up and removal of inhibitions thing.

The main character is treated as an adult throughout the fic, and generally behaves in an adult manner. It is, literally, an age thing on paper that causes problems.

On School of Seduction, the fan works example is an explicit Ranma ½ webcomic. I tried flagging the page but it gave me the "log in, please" message.

It does that, but the flag registers normally.

Cool, thanks.

Can someone direct me to the posts discussing FanFic.The Spiderses and Fanfic.Fa Ce Th E St Ra Ng E? I know there have been a few, but I don't see them listed on the relevant thread.

Also, as I understand it, VisualNovel.Bliss Stage Love Is Your Weapon is a Bleached Underpants version, so we can limit the page to that one.

I'll do it, wait a moment...

Spiderses:[1], [2], [3]

Face The Strange:[4], [5]

Check also the posts below these

edited 15th Jul '12 7:24:47 AM by SeptimusHeap

@Komodin:

FanVid.Touhou

@7490: Not sure that description really makes sense. After all, it's not like Bliss Stage contained any sex itself. It has (maybe two or three lines of) rules for what happens if people do have sex, but beyond that it's all the people playing.

The VN, on the other hand, has been definitively stated as having (offscreen) sex, but beyond that it's hard to tell due to there not even being a public demo.

So, I don't think you can call the version that spends *more* time on sex Bleached Underpants...

Um, so are you saying the School of Seduction trope might need to go, or that example might need to go? Because I'm not under the impression that flagging the article the way to go for the latter...

edited 15th Jul '12 9:29:00 AM by Morganite

That's a sign that Bliss Stage shouldn't have been axed, not that Love Is Your Weapon should be.

Neither is pornographic, nor are they pandering to pedophiles.

Agreed 100%.

If I recall the original argument against bliss stage was "its abut kids fucking" fatal was brought up at the same time and I think some cross pollination of arguments may have happened.

The original reason for cutting was actually that game mechanics encouraged sex even with those who are preteens. It sounded creepy. Given the fact that it's a tabletop RPG I can say that while that may be true, there's no way for it to get explicit.

I don't remember the game encouraging sex with PR Eteens at all, also re-read my post I said the argument for cutting not reason.

I think it was the Level-Up at Intimacy 5 thingy that got this deemed wanting.

There is a thread here on Bliss Stage anyway