The Place for Purging Porn and Pedo-Pandering (AKA P5 flag evaluations)

OT: Are you talking about the Dragon Pink Tentacle Rape-Or-Whatever-It-Is thing?

I still recommend that Komo take a short break. Because either we're finding worse and worse stuff as time goes on, or Komo's ability to tolerate stuff is breaking down horribly.

Talking about Zanjibaru, which still only has one devil vote for some reason.

And I feel like I've watched way more weird hentai than any of you, since even that didn't faze me. Filled my with anger and disgust, but no more than the usual shitty rape porn.

edited 25th Jun '12 12:57:03 PM by KuroBaraHime

Re: Inu X Boku SS Ep. 6:

Nothing to report at halfway mark. Completely harmless so far.

Update: Still harmless. Hell, were it up to me, I would have zapped this one.

edited 25th Jun '12 1:07:01 PM by tdgoodrich1

Maybe we should have a rotating P5 to allow for broken-down members to take a break now and then and wash their brains out.

I mean, we still haven't gotten back to 5, which is slightly problematic.

Eh, I already took a break this previous weekend. I'm fine, really; that was just a small error on my part.

Since we're pretty much decided on Inu × Boku SS, I'll re-post what I found on the newest thing on the list, Animamundi Dark Alchemist, since that got kind of lost.

It's a Boys' Love game.
It's gory and has sexual content, but it's not explicitly pornographic.
It's rated All Ages in Japan. (The people who rate computer games in Japan are different from CERO, who rate console games. Computer games are just rated All Ages or 18+.)
It has an official English translation and release in America and Europe. It edited a lot of the gore and some light sexual stuff.
It's rated M in America.

Is there an actual plot in that work?

I'd think so if it's a non-pornographic Visual Novel. And a description of the plot is right in our page on it.

I'd like to request that Fill The Moon be bumped to the head of the queue, based on its HONF page...some very seedy stuff in there, plus that HONF page's fate is part of an ongoing cleanup effort for the namespace.

edited 25th Jun '12 1:22:55 PM by Willbyr

This last report is a formality more than anything else.

Re: Inu X Boku SS

Very tame shower scene with Ririchiyo. Her hair covers her breasts and ass so nothing is shown. Also some adult women poking each other in the breasts in a joke. Still nothing worth cutting.

Update: Some servicey shots of both Ririchiyo and Karuta, but given context, it was more laughing at the woman with the glasses and her ridiculous imagine spots than actual fanservice.

Verdict: Keep, clean if necessary

Pro:

• Shonen, thus Ririchiyo, our "obvious pedobait", is close in age to the intended audience
• Mostly clean

Con:

• Still some minor problematic material.

This one's mostly harmless. Strike Witches is far worse than this and it's wiki-safe.

edited 25th Jun '12 1:36:48 PM by tdgoodrich1

Fill The Moon is creepy as hell. I can't say if it's titllatng though. Never had the interest to read it.

edited 25th Jun '12 1:25:10 PM by lu127

@ Willbyr: Request granted.

Oh boy, let's see what's the problem with this one...

edited 25th Jun '12 1:25:55 PM by Komodin

By the way, did you know the author of this and Chu-Bra! is a woman? I

That... Explains a lot actually.

Why? Women can write naughty material. (aside: one of the banned manga (the shower head one) seems to be leading towards jossing my anti-ship)

I was mainly thinking about the rather excessive technical details, I was wondering how th author knew so much about women's underwear.

Now I know.

If it's any consulation, Komodin, I found the image on that Inu X Boku SS prurient at first glance as well.

It's a weird show. It's actually is a very good example of Male Gaze without neccessarily being all that fanservicey or explicit.

From what I've seen of The Dog and I, Secret Service I think it is okay.

I do think something could be said for finding a different picture though, because while I think that is canon art, it really isn't all that representative of the main thrust of the work. I say give the thing four angel heads with a recommendation to clean if need be and send the page to the Image Picking shop.

edited 25th Jun '12 4:47:07 PM by Catbert

I'd just like to note that pointing to an image on Moby Games by row and column number isn't such a good idea, because they rearrange based on how much window area you've got. The numbers Meeble pointed to in the Baldr Sky thread is a configuration menu on my screen, which I'm pretty sure is not supposed to be the problem image...

There is a headscratchers page for Digimon flagged. Pretty sure that's safe to zap off the list.

It's the one entitled "sex and poetry."

ETA: I Pm'd Komodin about it, but he probably never read it because you're not meant to PM defenses and accusations to P5. If I was thinking straight, I'd have PM'd Lu127 (the main moderator on this Sub Forum.) with the same details and had a lot better luck. It never crossed my mind to make a post in this thread. I'll do that in future, with things like this.

edited 26th Jun '12 6:46:35 AM by TheOneWhoTropes

Just to be sure: Nocturnal Illusion is a cut vote, right?

edited 26th Jun '12 2:43:33 AM by SeptimusHeap

I'm giving Netorare Genre its third angel, because browsing through the examples this doesn't seem porn related at all.

The page does have issues, such as many examples not seeming to have enough of a focus within the work itself to truly qualify as being part of a "genre", as well as being a trope with a Japanese name having several non-Japanese examples. Those issues are outside of the purview of the P5, however, so I would recommend that it get taken to TRS to sort them out.

edit: Yes, I sent a holler for it to be cut a few minutes ago when I saw it on the resolved list.

edited 26th Jun '12 5:38:03 AM by Meeble

It used to have a ton of porn stuff, but it cleaned up nicely when I removed works cut by Fast Eddie and the P5. I probably should have waited to clean it, in retrospect.

edited 26th Jun '12 7:21:51 AM by OjamajoLimePie