The Place for Purging Porn and Pedo-Pandering (AKA P5 flag evaluations)

Okay, since this got lost in the shuffle, I'll just reiterate: is anyone here familiar with Build Tiger?

I feel the need to prove I'm not a troll, so, in the interests of balance, despite the fact I was (and remain) a fan of Aki Sora, I have a page on a work by the same author that should be cut.

(It's already up for review, BTW)

https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Manga/Uwakoi

Having read the whole thing, it's doesn't have an incest theme, but it has the same artstyle, the same types of people in the same age group having sex, and while it does have a story, it's devoted to a torrid love affair directly related to the sexual content, and the sex is just as explicit as it was in Aki Sora, to the point calling this a spiritual successor to Aki Sora is completely accurate.

I have to admit it feels strange recommending a page cut when I don't like the very idea, but after comparing it to the site rules, it's just as condemned as Aki Sora content wise, and despite enjoying it, speaking from my own experience, the page almost certainly deserves to die.

In closing, maybe I'm being insecure, but I hope this is helpful and clears up any misconception I'm either a troll or have pro-Japanese work bias clouding my own judgment.

Regardless, I just hope this helps the P5.

I'm afraid I'm not familiar with it.

edited 31st May '12 9:54:29 AM by Rpgingmaster

I was referring to the "you are now leaving TV Tropes" filter, not the one for mature pages on-site.

I'm not, and I can't tell if the page image is hilarious or creepy.

Maybe Enzuru knows about it?

edited 31st May '12 9:53:46 AM by KrazyKopter

@Build Tiger: Not yet, but if it's in english I'm willing to take a look.

EDIT: god damn ninjas

edited 31st May '12 9:54:10 AM by NineThePuma

Ran into another strange work: Neko Kawaigari. It sounds like a typical H-Game, but what made my report this is that there seems to be some actual lolicon content in this - the opening video shows a slightly fanservicey picture of two very young-looking cat girls, and going by the trope page, there seems to be a possibility of a sex scene involving these two.

Edit: fixed link. Thanks Arha.

edited 31st May '12 12:52:52 PM by jkbeta

The page seems to have already been killed off without even going through the angel/devil head treatment as of yet, but the works page on the manga Hen probably deserves to die anyway.

Much like Uwakoi cited above, it's got content that pushes it beyond the pale, namely a shotacon scene that, while mild, is unquestionable in its context, and while the majority of the work is fairly acceptable Ecchi otherwise (if clumsily plotted), I'm afraid that (since I have read in its entirety), while fairly non explicit otherwise, that one scene is probably a death sentence, and since it seems someone already erased the trope page already even before it was moved to the review pile, I'd say, based on my personal experience with the work, give it three devil heads on the grounds of the shotacon scene alone.

It's sad, as otherwise it would survive our new content guidelines, but that one scene alone is, again, probably a death sentence irregardless.

edited 31st May '12 12:42:11 PM by Rpgingmaster

The wrong page was linked to. The proper one seems to be Neko Kawaigari. I've never heard of it myself.

I mainly know of the game through its entry on the Utsuge page. Never played it myself.

Re Build Tiger: As a procrastination excuse, I went and looked it up. From the chapters I read (5, 8, and 9), it's pure porn. There's a paper-thin excuse plot, but almost every page contained explicit, uncensored sex of one sort or another.

Now please excuse me while I go wash my brain. This has confirmed that furry porn is so not my thing.

<Passes over some Brain Bleach>

So, it can safely be scrapped?

Translation for the benefit of those who need it.

Utsuge: A sad game typically a visual novel.

Policy seems to be that unless the fast one puts his foot down on something(only happened once) cutting for content violation with out review by 5p (excluding pre-5p cuts which make up most of the backlog for reviews) is a ban worthy offense.

edited 31st May '12 12:43:31 PM by Shadis

@4232: Whether Hen's likely to survive or not, I'm under the impression that pages being cut for content violation without due process is discouraged... and as far as I can tell, Hen hasn't gotten it.

As far as I am aware, no page is to be cut without first being reviewed by the panel, and edit suspensions are handed out for those who abuse the cutlist. As for the works that were cut pre-panel, they will be reviewed by the panel as well. Of course, for some of the nastier works, this will largely be a formality.

Just one question: Since Mother Daughter Threesome is on the "resolved" items list with a disposition to move to TRS and clean up, should I make a TRS thread?

I'm fairly certain that Animeg is putting it through YKTTW currently. The clean, redone version. I think it's something like Parent-Child Love Triangle.

edited 31st May '12 1:10:53 PM by DarkConfidant

@Komodin: I'm not too familiar with the work, but I can check it out for you if you want.

Not within the next few hours, though, I gotta start getting ready to go do something soon.

Take your time, Enzeru; I ain't in a rush.

I hope the information on Uwakoi and Hen is useful to the P5.

My Furry BF just told me Build Tiger is porn, furry bara porn, with an Excuse Plot.

edited 31st May '12 1:35:14 PM by TheOneWhoTropes

Neko Kawaigari is absolutely a lolicon game. You can delete it with my blessing.

edited 31st May '12 1:40:38 PM by OjamajoLimePie

Why is WebAnimation.Nazo Unleashed on the flaglist?

I can't find much of anything on that Neko H-Game that I'm willing to access on my current computer, save for ja.wikipedia.org, and as usual Google Translate does a real hash job on Japanese. Apparently it is rated 18+ in Japan. Nothing is said in the article about the ages of the characters.

Sorry! I'll make a better version of it soon! The Parent Child Love Triangle trope! It is in the YTTKW!

@4247: It was only created today (moving from Main/) and the page type wasn't part of a batch given by Un Typed Pages — almost certainly a misclick.

edited 31st May '12 1:50:05 PM by Telcontar