Follow TV Tropes
I dunno, was there any actual prurience on the FATAL page or just tropersnark?
I was looking at the full history and some of it is pretty gross, although not as bad as some of the other pages that were nuked.
I would like to recreate the Baldr Sky page (still locked because of P5), since it was released on Steam this december with an all-age edition of sorts, which removes all explicit sexual content among other questionable things: https://sekaiproject.com/blogs/news/baldr-sky-changes
Edited by Itasio on Dec 29th 2019 at 7:58:43 AM
I could have sworn there was already a clean version and we had restored the page. I might be mixing it up with something else.
Anyway, I kept the data since when it was first cut, so I just tossed it all onto Sandbox.Baldr Sky. Content-wise, I'm not seeing any obvious problems, but there are a lot of ZCEs.
Maybe you're thinking of Caligula? Baldr Sky had its own thread where it was cut for pedo-pandering.
I took care of the ZCE in the sandbox, and I'd like to ask for the recreation of the Baldr Sky page, now that the adult content got downplayed to a minimum with the Steam version.
My vote is yes, but we need opinions from the others.
So Saya no Uta was released on Steam back in August of 2019. Apparently this removes the sex scenes with Saya (though a patch can be bought to re-enable it.) The page itself is currently a black hole of ZCE's, so maybe allowing an unlock could help restore the page. Perhaps we limit examples to the Steam version only?
Edited by Kappaclystica on Apr 13th 2020 at 1:03:16 PM
If it's still allowed under our content policy with the sex scenes, I don't see why we need to restrict it more.
I'm pretty sure Steam lets anything on these days, so I'm not sure it can be taken as a good measure of what's allowable.
Steam also has a "This game is marked as 'adult only'. You are seeing this game because you have agreed to continue to this page." warning for actual adult content.
The Song Of Saya does not have that. They charge $4 on their website for 'the Adult Content Patch'.
Edited by Memers on May 10th 2020 at 10:01:14 AM
I haven't seen much opposition for the recreation of the Baldr Sky page (at least with the Steam version)... I'd like to ask once more for its recreation. I also asked members of the P5 if I can recreate it but no one answered except Dr Psyche (who said yes).
Edited by Itasio on Jul 26th 2020 at 9:57:41 AM
I voted in favor too. Has anyone disagreed?
The CVR has it listed at 2 angels. I've asked the admins (again) to re-enable saving dispositions.
Sonic High School:
The reason given for the page being cut is just "Per P5". After some searching, I found what that refers to.
"Contains sex scenes with characters as young as six. Cutlist."
In the discussion about cutting the page, someone asks about whether the characters have been aged up, and is told there's no indication it has been done so.
This is simply not true. All the characters with canon ages are attending high school. While some may have skipped grades, four things argue against this being done anywhere near enough for the canon six-year-old to be her canonical age.
1. Her room is covered in posters "of things teenage women liked, such as the famous Boy Band One Sonic Direction, and famous television shows like Gossip Sonic and Pretty Little Sonic and iSonic and, famous books like Sonic Twilight and Fifty Shades of Sonic".
2. She's specified as having boobs.
3. She has a "pursefull of teen girl blood diapers"
4. The author states in the synopsis "all the High School students are 18 years old". Though it admittedly lies about there being no graphic descriptions, the rest of it is a pretty normal talking-itself-up description.
The other characters who have sex scenes are all canonically 15 or older, with one exception. Tails is canonically 8, and due to his intelligence he may have skipped grades. Nonetheless, the text also specifies that "he was not a woman or child", and combined with reason 4, it is extremely likely he's been aged up too.
While I want a page on Sonic High School too, admittedly the consent in that Shadow/Cream encounter is a little ambiguous. I once tried writing a page on the sequel Sonic the Hedgehog World War 2 Dragon since that has pretty much no smut, but unfortunately I didn't save my work and gave up.
Never read the fic, but just to let you know, Shadow's physical age is 15, which is below our acceptable age for sex in fanfics.
That's for fanfic recs, not having a page.
I know this isn't porn, but given the topic of restorations, I don't know where else to turn.
The page Warcraft The Artifact Weapons was cut because quote: "We shouldn't be giving a CHARACTER page to a bunch of inanimate objects."
That's fair, but the problem here is that some of the 'objects' are sapient weaponry with character traits of their own, some of which have manifested physical avatars and at one of which have been transferred into a physical humanoid body. And these characters were not transferred to other pages where they belong. The page was cut without a chance to do this.
I would like for the page to be restored to pre-cut, at least until this can be rectified.
Edited by Theharbo on Apr 5th 2021 at 9:14:27 PM
The correct topic would be Ask The Tropers, but I remember that there was already a long discussion there about that exact page which approved the cut - don't remember for sure, though.
Community Showcase More
How well does it match the trope?