Pretty sure alot of the old rules about reviving people got phased out, with the revived person usualy ending up where it was most convenient, either that or all the wishes to revive people after dende came around were REALLY cleverly phrased. Like most people killed by buu and cell would have been revived in some akward places that I'd think we'd have heard about or in the case of some of them having no body to return to, they shouldn't have been able to revive at all given how things worked in dragonball. I also feel like the one year rule never really factored into anything, so I'm still very confused to why it's even still cannon for any version of the dragonballs to have that rule since no-ones ever needed to revive someone who's been dead that longe that didn't have a different reason why they couldn't be revived. That being said I feel vegeta wouldn't wish the sayains back simply because he's long since accepted the sayain race as just being him and Kakarots familiy. Now maybe his repeated interactions with Cabba might make him nostalgic enough to revive his old lackies, Nappa and Radditz. (Though would Nappa still be paralyzed if he was revived? I feel like that might not be reversed since it didn't look like the damage goku did was going to kill him and being revived doesn't remove yamcha and tiens scars.)
While I can't say anything about Super, all of the rules regarding resurrection with Shenron are still followed all the way to the end of the Boo Saga. Goku wasn't brought back with the "Bring everyone who was killed by Cell back to life" wish because Goku had already been revived by Shenron once. When everyone is revived by Porunga at the end of the Boo Saga, they all appear where they were killed except Vegeta but that's only because Vegeta's body was currently on the world of the Kaioushin and you get brought back wherever your body currently is (or was, as the case may be).
Also, the one-year thing only applies to mass revivals. If you're just bringing back a single person then there's no known time limit.
Let the joy of love give you an answer! Check out my book!"they all appear where they were killed"
"you get brought back wherever your body currently is"
Those are the rules that I think got phased out. Because during the cell and buu sagas there were many people (many of them main characters) would have had to have been revived in places that didn't match either. Unless you are very VERY loose with the definitions of the words "killed" and "body", 17 would have been revived in the middle of space, and Krillin, 18, marron, Videl and Mr. Popo should have popped up on the Supreme Kais Planet. Since it's shown that 18 was still in some way alive inside cell and Buu turned the people on kamis lookout into food ad ate them meaning their bodies wouldn't have been on the lookout where they got teleported. And then theres the problem of buus house and the islanders cell blew up, since they didn't wish back the islands.
All I'm saying is that not all of the rules introduced in early dragonball follow through, in dragonball there was a big focus on reviving people bringing them back into their old bodies, to the point where they had to keep roshi, krillin and chaotsus bodies in stasis pods and gods needing to make NEW bodies for z fighters who got vaporized. Then during cell and buu, people just got new bodies magicked up and placed in convenient spots as part of being revived with not real explanation because I'm pretty sure Toriyama by that point forgot or hoped the readers forgot how complex reviving people started out. For years I assumed wishing people back with earths dragonballs just brought them to where the dragon was because half the time that's how it was summarized in the games.
edited 20th Oct '17 9:20:23 PM by TwistedGear
They didn't get phased out, because we see it happening on-screen. Trunks, Kibito, etc.
The dragons can also repair bodies, and can do so 'for free' at the dragons' discretion. They also have the power to move souls.
The dragons are individuals and can interpret wishes differently. The rules didn't get forgotten so much as the dragons interpreted them more favourably when it would be detrimental to the plot for them to do otherwise.
Assuming that 17 should be in Otherworld or that Videl et al should be on the Kaioshin planet is a big jump. Once their bodies are destroyed they can be given a new one by the dragons, and Kuririn even gets a new body for free. The dragons are very helpful, and it's only due to misunderstandings that they get inconvenienced.
For civilians, they don't focus on it. We don't know how convenient the wishes end up being for them.
edited 20th Oct '17 9:45:08 PM by Saiga
I seem to recall Kami or King Kai being the one that gave Chaotsu or Krillin a new body (Like I remember it was a "god" but not which "god"). Or at least that's how it was phrased, maybe it was Kami through shenron sindce shenron was an extension of Kamis power or whatever. I still stand by toriyama simplifying the rules of reviving and possibly a few other common wishes. A large part of making wishes in the piccolo to namek arcs was careful planning around rules that no-one seemed to be worried about in the Cell to buu arcs. Maybe dendes version of the dragon is just alot more chill and more reasonable with the wishes, but I don't think anyone ever commented on the change, they just made the wish then assumed everything would work out fine, which it does, but there's nothing to show the reason for their sudden drop in caution and I feel the only real explanation that I see is that some of the more problematic rules that never changed much of anything in overall continuity just got Soft Retconed or removed offscreen.
On a slightly different topic, I also never understood why the one year to revive rule was even ever a thing, in a narrative sense, since it never presented a roadblock where there wasn't one already. If I remember right, the explanation of a one year limit was during the debate of who to revive first with the namekian dragonballs, since they could only revive a max of three with the namekian dragonballs. Except the solution is to revive piccolo, thus getting the earth dragonballs back. There were already the threats of only having a max of three and Chaotzu could only be revived with the Namkeian dragonballs and the chance of not getting to use the Namekian dragonballs again. And the one year problem never came up again, maybe you could say Goku being revived in the Buu saga was limited by that rule, but again we already had a problem of them not having time to wish goku back so he could fight Super Buu. I can't think of a single point where someone being dead too long to be revived was ever a important part of the story. It also seems to be straight up ignored in any movie, sequel series or what if.
edited 20th Oct '17 10:41:20 PM by TwistedGear
God gave Chaozu a body so he could train on Otherworld. Porunga mentions fixing up Kuririn's body in that wish.
And Shenron has always fixed damage to the body, or people would just immediately die again.
The rules haven't changed. There was no rule about where people were resurrected, it's just what the dragons would do when the wishes weren't specified. They've shown that they can fold multiple wishes together, and the dragons will use their own discretion to 'improve' a wish. The issue wasn't about them having hard rules as communicating to the dragon what they wanted exactly.
Which makes some of the wish usage seem wasted, if the dragons are happy to do that for free. But it's not inconsistent so much as the trial and error approach the gang took to figuring out how to use their wishes (they never just asked the dragon the most efficient way to do what they wanted).
The one year revival limit probably just exists as a way of preventing really open ended consequences to mass revivals. It wasn't relevant to the plot, but prevents problematic wishes being made in the future.
edited 20th Oct '17 10:59:52 PM by Saiga
Just saw it myself.
I like that Toppo is less antagonistic to Goku compared to the anime, and that the plot is having Goku continually keep everyone alive via this tournament (he hears Zen-O say that might cancel it, but misses the part about destroying universes, so he's inadvertently keeping everyone alive just due to his desire to fight).
Also, while Toppo does win, it's more due to a lucky and well timed move as opposed to being flat out stronger (he is strong, but he admitted that if Goku had landed that punch, things would have been very different).
Now that I think about it, the Gods briefly fighting each other might have been in the notes as well since it happens in both version (though as usual, the exact circumstances and the way they play out are very different).
One Strip! One Strip!Well, Toppo might be stronger (even if he's weaker than Jiren). He handles Super Saiyan God pretty well, and we don't get to see how Blue fairs against him, because he's lucky enough to end it when Goku messes up.
Goku talks him up pretty well too.
One Strip! One Strip!

They were using the Namek balls when learning that was a thing...
Rules of the Internet 45. Rule 45 is a lie. Check out my art if you notice.