Well at the moment it looks like changing the Nightmare Fuel namespace to Accidental Nightmare Fuel is going to be the winner, with a 3:1 upswing. I think making a special efforts thread would be a good idea now, since if we can get enough people involved we can clean up all the bad examples AND keep the pages clean if everyone puts a few on their watchlist.
EDIT: I would like to ask any mod that comes by to delete Superman: Birthright, since it A) has only one example, which only takes up one and a half lines, and B) it's about a visual representation of superman being discected, which prompts Clark and Lois to leave the room. Clearly nothing accidental about it being horrifying.
edited 8th Feb '12 9:18:31 PM by Shaoken
Throw it on the Cut List.
Holy crap, you guys, The NightmareFuel.Disney page is terrible. So many "Am I The Only One Who Was'' edits... I'm practically in a Heroic BSoD about this one, because I don't know how to fix it.
edited 8th Feb '12 9:31:09 PM by BearyScary
Do not obey in advance.Remember, Nightmare Fuel is by nature something we feel like sharing with others, since Caveman Ug's rustling in the woods that he heard is kinda like the sound that Caveman Thug's thing that wanted to eat him made, so we should probably have some way to vent Natter when it comes up again.
![]()
Then it becomes a forum thread masked as article. We can't surrender to Thread Mode.
edited 8th Feb '12 9:46:38 PM by DrStarky
Put me in motion, drink the potion, use the lotion, drain the ocean, cause commotion, fake devotion, entertain a notion, be Nova Scotian*is thumped by the Codfish in a Derby Hat for mentioning that thing that we used to have that allowed for first-person pronouns
EDIT: ...in a manner that is not entirely condemning of it*
edited 8th Feb '12 9:53:09 PM by Artemis92
Ponders too much; thinks too little. Currently goes by Knowlessman.![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
Sweet.
![]()
Exactly. Too much of this stuff reads like a second Troper Tales.
edited 8th Feb '12 9:51:51 PM by BearyScary
Do not obey in advance.I'd like to request that That Guy With The Glasses , Atop the Fourth Wall , Cinema Snob and That Dude With The Suede be merged into one article, because with the exception of Atop the Fourth Wall none of them have enough examples to justify a subpage by themselves, but all would fit under the first one's title.
I've gone through Disney, somewhat leniently and with benefit of the doubt. I've cropped everything obviously intended to be scary as well as anything that lacked enough detail for me to tell.
Many of the examples that remain are ones that I'm not familiar with so I have no idea how it's played in context, so someone else should probably check it as well.
edited 8th Feb '12 10:36:19 PM by Noaqiyeum
ERROR: The current state of the world is unacceptable. Save anyway? YES/NOI strongly doubt that those voting for the crowner's leading option realize the state of the ANF namespace. They probably think we now have a large namespace containing ANF examples. We don't. We have a large namespace containing a few ANF examples, a lot of HONF examples and tons of content we'll delete when we clean the pages.
Again, I have't found a single work with enough examples to justify a namespace. No, not even Fantasia - nearly all the examples cover intentional scary items. Maybe something like Disney, which I assume covers dozens of works, but we can have Accidental Nightmare Fuel / Disney etc without a wiki-wide namespace.
Betcha a dollar that the option to move Accidental Nightmare Fuel to YMMV is only at the bottom 'cause it starts started with the word "kill." Basic headology, there. Also, what happened with Troper Tales is probably sticking in some people's heads like 9/11.
(Bold text thumped until I figure out what I should be shouting.)
edited 8th Feb '12 11:01:03 PM by Artemis92
Ponders too much; thinks too little. Currently goes by Knowlessman.I didn't say we encourage it, but either natter maintenance would have to become a regular thing, or we should find some other outlet. Could we have a Nightmare Fuel forum under Just for Fun, and have a natter push button as opposed to natter chop?
Personally, I think one namespaced subpage per work is the better option. Sure, it's more work now, but it makes the pages cleaner and we don't have an Accidental Nightmare Fuel page with only one or two examples on it. Plus, it makes curating them much easier.
I am baffled that people actually are voting to keep the namespaces as-is. Really people? The only option with no pros? Thank goodness it's in the red, but I'm still disappointed it has any votes. It's a textbook example of a knee-jerk reaction to reject any change.
edited 9th Feb '12 6:55:57 AM by ccoa
Waiting on a TRS slot? Finishing off one of these cleaning efforts will usually open one up.Whaaat? I didn't even notice that option. I thought the TSR was about change. There wouldn't be a crowner if we hadn't decided that not changing was a bad idea.
Ponders too much; thinks too little. Currently goes by Knowlessman.If people are looking for work to do while waiting on this crowner, we do still need the index/disambig page and Nightmare Fuel moved to Accidental Nightmare Fuel.
I'm not sure what should go on a disambig/index other than links to the pages. A definition of the fanspeak term? Someone who wanted this option, could you maybe sandbox what you were thinking?
EDIT: Wait. Someone moved it already, but left the full page on Nightmare Fuel. Erk. I'm putting up a skeleton disambig for now.
EDIT EDIT: And done. Someone want to look at Nightmare Fuel and fix it the way you guys wanted it? Also, I put in a request to kill the custom titling, hopefully that happens soon. Need to request a YMMV banner for Accidental Nightmare Fuel while I'm at it.
EDIT EDIT EDIT: And moved the subpages. Whew. Okay, I think that does it for the move.
edited 9th Feb '12 10:43:09 AM by ccoa
Waiting on a TRS slot? Finishing off one of these cleaning efforts will usually open one up.Sorry to double post, but does anyone know which mods are responsible for the customize title thing? I tried to get Nightmare Fuel's custom title removed, but it seems to have been rejected. It's possible that whomever did it doesn't know what's going on with this page, and, unlike the cutlist, there's no way to directly explain with the submission.
edited 10th Feb '12 11:44:52 AM by ccoa
Waiting on a TRS slot? Finishing off one of these cleaning efforts will usually open one up.All moderators, I think. Maybe no one came to your request already. Otherwise, there is this thread about bad Custom titles
Aha, thank you.
Waiting on a TRS slot? Finishing off one of these cleaning efforts will usually open one up.
Crown Description:
Vote up for yes, down for no.

A Special Efforts thread sounds good. That could be where to take the issue of whether or not to edit tropers' gut-wrenched reactions to some of this stuff. To delete, or not to delete...
Do not obey in advance.