By the way, Cider in post 26. We have Who Would Win, for just talking or speculating on random match-ups people want to talk about.
Wait, we did have it. It had an archive page, as well. What happened to it?
edited 7th Sep '11 10:35:28 AM by Madrugada
Huh? That seems to be Comically Missing the Point. If you didn't want arguments you probably shouldn't have had a debate page in the first place.
Why don't we find a fight web site and make them our unofficial affiliate through the Ultimate Showdown Of Ultimate Destiny page? Or just suggest people use web sites the page already links to?
Modified Ura-nage, Torture RackThe trope is when the meme is deliberately used or alluded to in a work. We do tropes.
In this corner, we have: Fan speculation on the outcome of a battle between two or more fictional or nonfictional entities.
In this corner, we have: An honest but possibly humorous attempt to determine the outcome of a battle between two or more fictional or nonfictional entities.
If post 2 indicates what definition it would have as an objective concept - Deadliest Warrior, Celebrity Deathmatch, and the like - that seems to me to be a pretty substantial shift away from "a Stock Reference to this tendency of fandom".
@Madrugada: I believe the Who Would Win archive was split due to length, but don't quote me on that.
This is a sinkhole.Would there be any objections to moving the fandom stuff to a Just for Fun page?
Or we could make a wiki for this, if there isn't already.
I'm on the internet. My arguments are invalid.I think we should add another option to the crowner: Split off Who Would Win for the thought experiment fans do(for example, here
), and Ultimate Showdown of Ultimate Destiny for if the fight actually happens.
I think removing an objectively used device from the subjective bin comes first...but maybe more than one of you would disagree.
I think we should make put all the hypothetical matchups on Darth Wiki. Really, it'd be nice to move something there that wasn't a negative opinion complaint, something that could give the place the attention it deserves and because of the negative opinion pages, its curators are already skilled at and used to removing unnecessary debates... we just need to give it a more appropriate Darth Wiki title. Who Would Lose? That sounds good.
Modified Ura-nage, Torture Rack![]()
I agree, and luckily it isn't mutually exclusive with the option on the current crowner, cuz we can't add new options to a single-prop.
I think discussion of hypothetical matchups should be done with the discussion page system in some way, not with a Thread Mode wiki page. We don't want to encourage bad habits.
edited 14th Sep '11 11:47:19 PM by troacctid
The current crowner is single prop. I can't add anything new to it.
Writing a post-post apocalypse LitRPG on RR. Also fanfic stuff.
Crown Description:
Ultimate Showdown Of Ultimate Destiny has been restricted to In Universe examples only. Is additional action needed? Options are not necessarily mutually exclusive. The related thread for this crowner can be found here

I think if you want a page for listing random fights fans want to see you should take it You Know The Thing Where and make a new page after this one is cleaned up. Why do we need that page on a sight about documenting story telling tropes anyway. If you just want to talk about who could beat who Ultimate Showdown of Ultimate Destiny already has links to several sites dedicated to doing that and I'm sure you can find even more from google's auto complete.
Modified Ura-nage, Torture Rack