Welcome to the main discussion thread for the Marvel Cinematic Universe! This pinned post is here to establish some basic guidelines. All of the Media Forum rules
still apply.
- This thread is for talking about the live-action films, TV shows, animated works, and related content that use the Marvel brand, currently owned by Disney.
- While mild digressions are okay, discussion of the comic books should go in this thread
. Extended digressions may be thumped as off-topic.
- Spoilers for new releases should not be discussed without spoiler tagging for at least two weeks. Rather, each title should have a dedicated thread where that sort of conversation is held. We can mention new releases in a general sense, but please be courteous to people who don't want to be spoiled.
If you're posting tagged spoilers, make sure that the film or series is clearly identified outside the spoiler tagging. People need to know what will be spoiled before they choose to read the post.
Edited by Mrph1 on Jul 29th 2024 at 3:09:00 PM
To me the only difference between magic and pseudo science in movies is that one looks like it comes from the past and the other looks like it comes from the future. But it is really just an aesthetical difference.
I care more about it being presented in a way that it doesn't feel like there are no rules whatsoever.
Speaking of which, part of the reason why I was so disappointed by Dr. Strange was because the fight choreography felt so samey to everything else, because all of these MAGICAL people were doing kung fu and making light constructs and everyone fights the exact same goddamn way.
Granted, they've changed that up a lot, but for a while it was basically "If you're not Thor or Tony, you do MMA."
My various fanfics.I would also point out that in Wonder Woman, they treat the magic as magic, and the gods are actual gods and never referred to as anything but gods. There's no "well they're really just long living beings that people just kind of worshipped as gods," no they're freaking gods, no if's and's or but's about it.
Which makes me go "thank you movie, that's refreshing."
Edited by Punisher286 on Nov 2nd 2018 at 1:02:07 AM
But at the same time, they also killed all of the Gods, so, ya know. Good with the bad.
My various fanfics.Optics.
They were lowercase-g gods. They don't have to be omnipotent or unkillable, just powerful and worshipped. You're making this about precise definitions, but language is imprecise and contextual to begin with, and taking that aside, that's not the issue for the people who want a more fantastical MCU. They want the trappings, the look of the thing. That might not be important to you, and that's fine, but that's what some of us still want.
Edited by Unsung on Nov 2nd 2018 at 3:18:00 AM
The Greek gods killed the titans, Cronus and so forth. The Norse gods and giants are often on roughly equal terms, and they kill each other all the time, not to mention the myth of Balder. The Egyptian god Osiris' whole thing is having already died and been mummified. Death and resurrection are complicated for the gods, much like they are for superheroes. It comes up often enough that there's a word for it.
Edited by Unsung on Nov 2nd 2018 at 6:18:08 AM
Technically the Titans are sealed in Tartarus, and as with the cyclops that were sealed inside before them, they can be set free, but that's pretty much the same as death if it's define as being in the underworld and not being able to leave. They don't do dying from injuries, sickness or age and etc. Norse gods have to eat the apples of Iðunn to stay ageless, and can be killed.
Norse Mythos is full of dead gods. Balder dying (which technically preludes Ragnarok) is the most famous case. Most gods are (perhaps ironically) at least somewhat mortal, since Osiris also dies (though he comes back) in Egyptian mythos.
To my knowledge only the Greeks and Christian lores operate entirely on 100% immortal gods.
"All you Fascists bound to lose."The Greek gods might not be able to die, but they can be wounded and dismembered. And the ways in which the Underworld and Mount Olympus are much more physical places than in most religions makes it at least somewhat ambiguous, since "cast into the underworld" could be interpreted in a few different ways, with the Titans existing in this weird space, mythically, where they seem more mortal in some ways than both their children and their parents. And then there's all the child-eating and subsequent disgorging of said children (like Athena cracking her way out of Zeus's skull), and Aphrodite coming out of nowhere riding a clamshell up out of the sea, and some myths where Pan is Hermes' son but others where he always existed in the woods, something separate and distinct from the other members of the pantheon. Greek mythology is weird.
Edited by Unsung on Nov 2nd 2018 at 7:18:45 AM
Anyway.
The whole "We Norse gods aren't actually gods, but really long-lived aliens" is straight from the comics, except the comics have all gods as alien beings (well, a cross between alien beings and gods). So, like, Thor is an alien and a god, but also not even the origin Thor, because Ragnarok is a cycle and there have been many cycles before.
Edited by alliterator on Nov 2nd 2018 at 6:17:56 AM
Not "Anyway." This is actually (at least somewhat) relevant, because while you do have that aliens-as-gods aspect to the Asgardians, you also have the Olympians and various other pantheons, and the degree of magic-as-advanced technology varies. The rules that the MCU has set up regarding the Asgardians don't have to apply to the portrayal of other gods and supposedly mythical beings, much less rules people have assumed apply to gods in general, which are hardly consistent across different cultures to begin with.
Edited by Unsung on Nov 2nd 2018 at 4:50:23 AM
I mean, kind of, but I still want to see Jesus come down from the cross and beat the shit out of the Greek gods.
How do you even explain that through the scientific method?
Like this:
"Multiple recorded repetitions of the experiment have shown that the dragon is a part of an eternal cycle of death and resurrection, where it's slain by humans through nothing more than their bare-hands. Upon every death, it empowers its slayer with its power and will come back to life so to do the whole death & empower process all over again."
I think in the Magic v. Science debate, people have this fundamental misunderstanding that in order to be scientific, something must be grounded in the laws of physics as we know them today. That's not how science works. At all.
Punching that dragon in the heart to gain superpowers is a thing that has already been tested over and over again with the same results obtained every time. It would never have become a big part of K'un-Lun's culture if it was not a reliable procedure that can be performed over and over again to attain a specific outcome.
Like it or not, the Iron Fist is scientifically provable. It's just not consistent with real-world physics. But neither are half of Tony Stark's armors.
Edited by TobiasDrake on Nov 2nd 2018 at 7:54:08 AM
My Tumblr. Currently side-by-side liveblogging Digimon Adventure, sub vs dub.

Well, it was brought up rhetorically — it's the same with saying that magic and science couldn't possibly result in different scenes, or that those differences, if they do exist, don't matter.
Edited by Unsung on Nov 2nd 2018 at 1:36:20 PM