Welcome to the main discussion thread for the Marvel Cinematic Universe! This pinned post is here to establish some basic guidelines. All of the Media Forum rules
still apply.
- This thread is for talking about the live-action films, TV shows, animated works, and related content that use the Marvel brand, currently owned by Disney.
- While mild digressions are okay, discussion of the comic books should go in this thread
. Extended digressions may be thumped as off-topic.
- Spoilers for new releases should not be discussed without spoiler tagging for at least two weeks. Rather, each title should have a dedicated thread where that sort of conversation is held. We can mention new releases in a general sense, but please be courteous to people who don't want to be spoiled.
If you're posting tagged spoilers, make sure that the film or series is clearly identified outside the spoiler tagging. People need to know what will be spoiled before they choose to read the post.
Edited by Mrph1 on Jul 29th 2024 at 3:09:00 PM
Saudi Arabia Ends 35-Year Cinema Ban With the Premiere of Black Panther
https://www.themarysue.com/saudi-arabia-ends-35-year-cinema-ban-with-the-premiere-of-black-panther/
Every time Ghost is mentioned as being the antagonist of AM&tW, my mind immediately pictures a different Ghost and I can't help but laugh at the idea.
edited 19th Apr '18 2:32:11 PM by Anomalocaris20
You cannot firmly grasp the true form of Squidward's technique!Its a shame about the way rights were split up because none can defeat Beast, the Snarkiest Avenger
Forever liveblogging the Avengers![]()
You're not fooling me! I already (kinda?) spoiled myself on Deadpool 2. (I say kinda because apparently it's from leaks I've never really read directly.) I won't forgive myself if somehow spoiled Infinity War for myself.
8 days.
8 more days.
I just need to power through.
edited 19th Apr '18 3:24:19 PM by TargetmasterJoe
I've heard that the Ultimate Clone Saga was betterish. Shorter most certainly. More well regarded.
The Real Clone Saga miniseries wasn't bad either.
So its doable.
Forever liveblogging the AvengersUltimate Clone Saga is actually pretty damn good. It benefits from having a very clearly conceived beginning, middle and end, whereas the Clone Saga went on for way too long and was written without any ending conceived (which meant they had to make shit up as time went on).
Plus it could be how they introduce Jessica Drew into the MCU.
edited 19th Apr '18 4:10:17 PM by comicwriter
x4 I won't say it's impossible but I doubt it. Civil War and the Clone Saga work on a conceptual level (mostly). One More Day does not.
So, Winter Soldier was... alright? A bunch of the details were dumb, but it held together on the whole.
Let's talk continuity! What's that? I'm not sure the MCU writers know either. I'm pretty sure in earlier stuff it was implied that SHIELD was newly formed, or at least no one had never heard of them. I distinctly remember a joke about how they hadn't even some up with the SHIELD acronym and were still using its long-form name. Now they've been around since the '50s! They have a giant Pentagon-esque building! Okay, they had a helicarrier and crew in The Avengers, but one secret (if major) project and a few hundred crewmen at max seems about right. I don't really like the idea of SHIELD as a big bureaucratic agency like the FBI or the CIA. A (relatively) small, dedicated force that punches way above its weight class in isolated incidents but can't fight an entire war on its own is more interesting.
My biggest complaint about the movie overall is actually the action. The first Captain America was very down to earth and practical — he carried a gun in addition to his shield and did very little in the way of acrobatics or showy moves. It was all very straightforward and to the point, even with the shield-ricochet trick shot shenanigans. In contrast, Winter Soldier was nothing but ridiculous spinkicks and pointless backflips. There was little about them that was interesting or added anything but "hey, look at our huge choreography budget", and virtually all of them dragged on too long. Hell, the first big scene was Cap going four or five rounds of fisticuffs with a normal dude, despite having thrown people twenty feet with one kick in earlier scenes. (Remember what I said about continuity?) They also seemed to have amped up Cap's physical abilities in general — jumping out of airplanes, falling a dozen stories without notable injury, falling off an overpass, through a bus, which then crashes into another bus and flips over, etc etc. I can buy it with Iron Man (even though he'd actually be pulp inside the armor) and Thor (he's a god), but with Captain America it stretches suspension of disbelief.
On to the plot! I didn't have a problem with the basic "Hydra faction inside SHIELD" premise, but I think they would have done better playing up the "got to smoke out the traitors" angle rather than the "just beat everyone up" angle. One of the big problem with conspiracy plotlines is that it's easy to turn "we don't know how much influence they have" into "they can do whatever the fuck they want", and Winter Soldier dove straight into that trap without looking back. Dozens of fake cops deployed on short notice? Sure! Heavily armed strike teams shooting up the city with no worries about official response whatsoever? Why not! Magic satellite targeting system that's just going to murder a hundred thousand people at once? Yeah, fine, no one will mind that! We'll just say they were all terrorists or something. People will buy it.
I don't give a shit about Bucky. Yes, I know, Cap is very sad about the whole thing. I don't care. The entire thing left me cold.
Movie wasn't all bad, though! Cap's new friend with the rocket-wing suit was cool. The scenes of chaos inside SHIELD as the two sides squared off and starting shooting each other were well done. The part with the German Swiss scientist converted into an AI using '70s computer tech was awesome, but totally wasted. I love the idea of decades-old superscience (that was one of my favorite parts of the first Captain America movie), aaaaaand he had a two-minute conversation with Cap and Black Widow and then allowed himself to get blown up. Ugh. They totally should have made him part of The Team for the climax — he's pissed about being shut up in a bunker and ignored for decades, and is willing to help stop Hydra in exchange for something to do. He can be the voice on comms announcing "two minutes to the deadline" or whatever for the rest of the movie. Seriously, such a cool idea and they did nothing with it!
I sort of feel like this movie doesn't belong this early in the MCU. The idea of SHIELD self-destructing and going from the stalwart defenders of Earth to struggling to survive is pretty compelling, but you've got to properly establish them as a powerful organization first. Set it sometime after the next Avengers movie, where they have a major effect on repelling some galactic-scale threat. In both movies that SHIELD played a major role in so far (The Avengers and Winter Soldier), they ended up being their own biggest threat and a good part of the movie was "SHIELD vs SHIELD", so it just comes off as them being incompetent rather than them being up against impossible odds. If you actually let them establish themselves as a major force for good, then taking them away and leaving Earth vulnerable is much more powerful.
Overall, I'd call Winter Soldier "okay". I'd put it above both Thor movies (the first being a fundamentally boring story, the second being mostly soulless), but below Iron Man 3 (which had two genuinely interesting stories, but stumbled by trying to tell them both at once). For those of you keeping track at home, that leaves the order so far as (best) the first two Iron Mans, the first Captain America, The Avengers, (cutoff for "good movie"), Iron Man 3, Winter Soldier, (cutoff for "alright movie"), both Thors, The Incredible Hulk (worst).
Really from Jupiter, but not an alien.That's actually a very good point regarding conspiracy plotlines. I'd never really thought about it before.
edited 19th Apr '18 8:03:52 PM by LordVatek
This song needs more love.Winter Soldier is actually considered one of the better MCU films by most people. I would...definitely not put Iron Man 3 above it, mostly because that film really shits the bed towards the end. Also Killian is by far one of the worst MCU villains.
It's actually the film that made me give the MCU a second try. After feeling lukewarm on or outright disliking most of the Phase 1 films besides Iron Man, I had basically decided it wasn't my thing and had moved on. But I decided to give it a shot and ended up rather liking it, so.
Nah. It's not the end of the world or anything :p
edited 19th Apr '18 8:12:29 PM by Draghinazzo
...so, my main original laughter was because you weren’t sure whether winter soldier would be as silly as Thor. It is not. While I share a few of your reservations re: Hydra conspiracy, I think the film is overall tightly written, with great characterization, solid action scenes that move the plot forward, and a great emotional core.
My biggest complaint about the movie overall is actually the action. The first Captain America was very down to earth and practical — he carried a gun in addition to his shield and did very little in the way of acrobatics or showy moves. It was all very straightforward and to the point, even with the shield-ricochet trick shot shenanigans. In contrast, Winter Soldier was nothing but ridiculous spinkicks and pointless backflips.
This makes sense in universe. In CA: TFA, no one trains Steve. He’s with the military, yeah, but all he knows is basic punching etc. In CA: TWS, he’s been awake for a couple years, and he’s had lots of time to learn various martial arts. It’d be silly if he DIDN’T improve/expand his fighting style.
Not sure which fight you’re referring to? Who did he go 4-5 rounds of fisticuffs with?
...you may need to go to the doctor and have her check whether you’ve got a soul.
Yeah, it’s just his best friend from childhood, basically his brother, and now his only connection to the 40s. Why would that be at all poignant?
Sam Wilson, AKA the Falcon, is a goddamn treasure.
Zola joining the team is patently absurd. He started as a Nazi/Hydra jerk, he actively infiltrated SHIELD and had people murdered, he wrote an algorithm to enable the murder of millions- no WAY should he be joining the team. No. Absolutely not.
edited 19th Apr '18 8:13:23 PM by wisewillow

>Matthew Renner
Was that on purpose?
@Native Jovian
Looking forward to your thoughts on TWS.
@Ant-Man and the Wasp
So Ghost is being described as the Big Bad now? Interesting. I was under the impression she was going to be The Dragon in league with characters like Sonny Burch.
edited 19th Apr '18 2:26:12 PM by AlleyOop