Welcome to the main discussion thread for the Marvel Cinematic Universe! This pinned post is here to establish some basic guidelines. All of the Media Forum rules
still apply.
- This thread is for talking about the live-action films, TV shows, animated works, and related content that use the Marvel brand, currently owned by Disney.
- While mild digressions are okay, discussion of the comic books should go in this thread
. Extended digressions may be thumped as off-topic.
- Spoilers for new releases should not be discussed without spoiler tagging for at least two weeks. Rather, each title should have a dedicated thread where that sort of conversation is held. We can mention new releases in a general sense, but please be courteous to people who don't want to be spoiled.
If you're posting tagged spoilers, make sure that the film or series is clearly identified outside the spoiler tagging. People need to know what will be spoiled before they choose to read the post.
Edited by Mrph1 on Jul 29th 2024 at 3:09:00 PM
For me, the Mandarin twist kind of goes back into the humor thing. It's a twist that's also played for laughs (and I'd be lying if I said I didn't I find funny at the time), but the movie just really overuses bathos to an almost infuriating degree. And that's even after the twist, right up to the climax.
edited 19th Mar '18 8:21:55 AM by deuteragonist
I think the Mandarin twist is great, but then, I don't give a damn about the original comic character and I find the idea of using what didn't work about that character in service of a theme a good idea.
If it purely was comedy I wouldn't care for it but since it ties into the central theme of "creating a villain for the public consumption" I actually thought it was pretty clever. Certainly better than whatever Iron Man 2 was trying to do. Iron Man 2 has humour that doesn't work a lot more for me, it's just fratboy humour (tits! booze! he pisses in the suit lol!) whereas Iron Man 3 is able to at least be a bit satirical (when Rhodey goes to the location and it's full of ladies in Burqas, for instance, I remember wondering if that was a sly dig at the whole trying to find WMD's in Iraq thing). Also, while Iron Man 3 has its confusing elements, Iron Man 2 has flat out plot holes, like with the "why don't you lead with that?" joke with the laser. Like... why does he never use that laser again basically?
edited 19th Mar '18 8:28:30 AM by Sigilbreaker26
"And when the last law was down and the Devil turned round on you, where would you hide, the laws all being flat?"Well, if you've passed Incredible Hulk and IM 2 I'd say you're through the worst of the MCU.
"And when the last law was down and the Devil turned round on you, where would you hide, the laws all being flat?"I'd amend that to "hinges mostly on whether or not they accept the Mandarin twist as a good idea and how they feel about Killian as a villain on his own terms".
The general opinion I see here is people liked the political themes behind the twist but dislike Killian for being a boring, uninteresting villain. In fact I would probably say he's one of the worst MCU villains at the end of the day. The "caricature" that Ben Kingsley was playing was far more interesting to watch than Guy Pearce (who I feel was miscast).
I'll probably post some more in-depth thoughts once our troper rewatch gets through IM 3 but I find it to be a mixed bag that's ultimately underwhelming.
edited 19th Mar '18 8:30:30 AM by Draghinazzo
Well, I'd say Killain was better than Hammer (who is a walking, unfunny joke) and Whiplash (who is massively boring) in that he has that one good scene at the start. When you start from zero even 0.1 is a big number.
"And when the last law was down and the Devil turned round on you, where would you hide, the laws all being flat?"The idea and theme itself are totally fine but (as another poster said) the execution sucks. If it wasn't played for laughs it probably would have made for a very interesting turn of events. However, the bathos just really brings down the entire thing for me. And yeah, I don't like Killian at all.
I should also note that I don't care about the source material either. I just want a good film. And that's the case for all of the MCU movies aside from Spider-Man Homecoming. Iron Man 3 is just a mess to me.
Hammer's only problem is that they overused him. I get why people complain about him since he gets too much screen-time but he was never supposed to be a serious villain really. I disagree that Killian is any better than Whiplash; Mickey Rourke's acting is pretty good in some scenes (like the intro where his father dies and he buiilds the whip tch) and his banter with Tony (the little there is of it) is genuinely entertaining to watch. He could have easily been a good villain if the film was built more around his conflict with Tony, but IM 2 is just too bloated and has too many threads so he feels wasted.
Meanwhile, Killian starts off the film as an over-the-top caricature of a nerd who feels like he belongs in an 80's movie, making it hard to take him seriously. Then in the present he's just a smug, douchey corporate executive type with pretty much no charisma or presence whatsoever and Stane was sooooo much better in comparison.
edited 19th Mar '18 8:43:00 AM by Draghinazzo
I mean, I found Killain's opening scene pretty good and every single one of Whiplash's scenes massively boring.
But after Stane, every single IM film has tried and failed to live up to that level of hammy badass.
edited 19th Mar '18 8:43:46 AM by Sigilbreaker26
"And when the last law was down and the Devil turned round on you, where would you hide, the laws all being flat?"I'm going to ignore the stuff about Tony snubbing Killian because that honestly contributes nothing to the film and winds up muddying Killian's motivations by making it look like the entire scheme was about revenge against Tony. Nerdy Past Killian should have just been cut out of the film; literally nothing would change.
What it amounts to is that Killian recruited Maya Hansen to fund her research into Extremis. It's supposed to be this life-saving formula but has a side effect of making things explode. Because comics.
Maya's been trying to wean out the explosion side effect, but Killian started testing on human subjects before that could be achieved. Specifically, he received state sponsorship and began testing on disabled military veterans, giving them back their limbs. Everything was great until one day, one of them exploded, killing himself and several bystanders.
Killian panicked and tried to come up with a scapegoat to make it seem like his formula wasn't responsible for the explosion. So he invented a fake terrorist attack, inventing the character of the Mandarin and appropriating the imagery and name of the Ten Rings. It became his go-to excuse. More clients started exploding and every time they did, it was another terror attack by the dreaded Mandarin, scourge of the West.
At some point, the Vice President became involved with this on the promise of Extremis to restore his handicapped daughter's legs. Presumably, this arrangement is how Killian was able to get state sponsorship and disabled veterans in the first place.
To help sell the illusion, Trevor Slattery was hired to play the Mandarin and Killian started releasing videos online of the Mandarin calling out the Americans and daring them to stop him. He also started courting Tony Stark, first through Pepper and then through Maya, because Tony's the only person he was aware of that could actually solve Extremis's instability. After years of Maya's failure to achieve stability with Extremis, he needed Stark's brilliance to make the explosions stop happening.
But the problem with his fake terror threat is escalation. You know the criticism of the villains in Die Hard trying to disguise a bank robbery as a terror attack, guaranteeing an escalated response they never would have had to deal with in a bank robbery? Yeah. The longer Killian's fake terror threat went on, the harder the Americans, S.H.I.E.L.D., and eventually even Iron Man came down on him. He ran into the problem face-first, and there was only so much the Vice President could do to protect him.
So, out of desperation, he came up with a new plan: seize the Presidency by staging actual terror attacks. Let the Mandarin assassinate the President of the United States. The Vice President can then assume power and lead a fake war against Killian's fake terrorist, placating the public and intelligence forces long enough for Extremis to be solved and for Killian's miracle drug to become marketable.
Ultimately, the entire conspiracy is the result of one really poorly conceived attempt at covering up a devastating side effect spiraling out of control into a savage web of lies to protect a desperate man from having to admit to the government that his product is killing war veterans.
edited 19th Mar '18 8:50:48 AM by TobiasDrake
My Tumblr. Currently side-by-side liveblogging Digimon Adventure, sub vs dub.I didn't mind Hammer — he was stupid, but in a fun way. The only Hammer joke that really annoyed me was the super-duper micromissile thing on the War Machine suit that turned out to be a complete dud. Like, if Hammer's actually that incompetent (rather than "good, just not as good as Stark"), then how the hell does he stay in business?
I don't have any problem believing that The Incredible Hulk is the low point of the MCU, though.
Huh, that actually makes a fair amount of sense (even though it's very silly). Not sure if I legitimately didn't understand most of that when I watched the movie, or I just forgot it after the fact. Probably the former — the fact that we're figuring this out piecemeal along with the protagonists rather than having it laid out all at once like you just did probably made it hard to follow.
edited 19th Mar '18 8:47:15 AM by NativeJovian
Really from Jupiter, but not an alien.![]()
When you put it like that... reminds me of Sword Art Online Abridged for some reason.
Killian, make-it-up-on-the-go scheme worthy of a Coen Brothers character.
There is an alternate ending where the Ex-Wife works as intended and Vanko has no armor suit.
edited 19th Mar '18 8:57:58 AM by Tuckerscreator
One explanation for the Ex-Wife that I've always liked is that Rhodey used it wrong.
It's described as a bunker-buster. That's a hell of a missile. Bunker-busters are designed to be so powerful that they collapse the bunker underneath their point of impact. They're earth-shaking missiles with a massively potent blast. They are not designed to be launched from five feet away from the intended target.
The Ex-Wife malfunctioned because it didn't have time to properly arm its charge before hitting Vanko's suit.
EDIT: And if you're wondering why an experienced soldier like Rhodey would make that mistake, Justin Hammer presumably walked him through how to use it himself. And Hammer's an idiot.
edited 19th Mar '18 9:00:54 AM by TobiasDrake
My Tumblr. Currently side-by-side liveblogging Digimon Adventure, sub vs dub.![]()
Huh, I actually kinda like that ending better. I was never really a fan of "haha, suddenly I have a power suit too, why not?". Doing things by just low key sauntering up like that seems more in character for Vanko.
That's a reasonable take, though if that was what happened, Tony pointing out the problem would have been funnier than just shitting on it because it's Hammer tech.
Heh. Hammer being a moron makes sense, but even if Hammer explained it wrong, wouldn't Rhodey realize it himself.
Not that I don't like the idea myself.
One Strip! One Strip!![]()
![]()
That's the thing, really. He only needs a power suit to take hits, which he never really does. Instead he uses his whips to immediately control the situation. That's what makes the fight interesting — the good guys really only need one good shot at him to end the fight, but he's so effective at keeping them on the defensive that they don't get the chance.
He should probably have some broken legs and maybe a shattered pelvis after repeatedly being hit with a car, though, yeah. Chalk it up to comic book physics.
edited 19th Mar '18 9:16:03 AM by NativeJovian
Really from Jupiter, but not an alien.

The only things I like about Iron Man 3 are the main theme and how Tony ultimately proves that it's not just the suit that makes him Iron Man.
But the absolute waste of Ben Kingsley ruins it for me completely.
I don't care about Killian at all, and agree that Maya would have been a better final villain.
Hell, I even think that the Mandarin being a dude behind the scenes is a good idea (because that's literally what Mandarin means), but the execution was lousy.
One Strip! One Strip!