Welcome to the main discussion thread for the Marvel Cinematic Universe! This pinned post is here to establish some basic guidelines. All of the Media Forum rules
still apply.
- This thread is for talking about the live-action films, TV shows, animated works, and related content that use the Marvel brand, currently owned by Disney.
- While mild digressions are okay, discussion of the comic books should go in this thread
. Extended digressions may be thumped as off-topic.
- Spoilers for new releases should not be discussed without spoiler tagging for at least two weeks. Rather, each title should have a dedicated thread where that sort of conversation is held. We can mention new releases in a general sense, but please be courteous to people who don't want to be spoiled.
If you're posting tagged spoilers, make sure that the film or series is clearly identified outside the spoiler tagging. People need to know what will be spoiled before they choose to read the post.
Edited by Mrph1 on Jul 29th 2024 at 3:09:00 PM
So the scene is good because they show interaction? by that same logic Shirtless Thor scene is good because it finally give them knowlage of the infinity stone or Natasha/Bruce in barn are good because it make them interact....see my point?
Also the whole choice feel force as Steven dosent even doubt for a moment, he just punch Ultra-bots, saying he will save people when Ultron clearly point out is usless since they are floating right now and them later just prove that point! and all Steve is sulk there talking until Nick come out of nowhere to save his ass, it dosent matter how much interaction you have about a situation if your solution to it is flying deus ex machina
In the end the only thing I get was: a) Steve idea of heroism os puching thing until it stop and b) when he cant, he just wait until the plot save him so he can get back to punch stuff...and of course, they pet him in the back for choicing good even when is already clear he will.
"My Name is Bolt, Bolt Crank and I dont care if you believe or not"- Rogers: The next wave's gonna hit any minute. What have you got, Stark?
- Stark: Well, nothing great. Maybe a way to blow up the city. That'll keep it from impacting the surface if you guys can get clear.
- Rogers: I asked for a solution, not an escape plan.
- Stark: Impact radius is getting bigger every second. We're going to have to make a choice.
- Romanoff Cap, these people are going nowhere. If Stark finds a way to blow this rock...
- Rogers: Not 'til everyone's safe.
- Romanoff Everyone up here versus everyone down there? There's no math there.
- Rogers: I'm not leaving this rock with one civilian on it.
- Romanoff I didn't say we should leave. There's worse ways to go. Where else am I gonna get a view like this?
Steve's being completely unreasonable in this scene. He's letting the perfect be the enemy of the good. He would sooner let the entire planet die than sign off on an imperfect solution, clearly establishing that the body count isn't as important to him as how much blood is on his hands, personally. As Nat appropriately points out, it's insane that he would even consider this to be a choice. That it's even a discussion that needs to be had at all.
You save as many as you can, then blow it. That's the answer. It should be obvious to everyone. Even Nat's ridiculous olive branch is a ridiculous attempt to appeal to the centrist fallacy in a situation where there is absolutely no merit to Cap's position whatsoever. No compromise that should be had. He is 100% flat-out wrong.
In addition to being a convenient plot device, Fury showing up with the deus ex Helicarrier is also a prime example of how the reality of the MCU contorts itself to prevent Captain America from ever being acknowledged as in the wrong. Instead of having to face the reality of the situation, Cap's unyielding obstinance is narratively rewarded.
edited 27th Jun '16 9:39:44 AM by TobiasDrake
My Tumblr. Currently side-by-side liveblogging Digimon Adventure, sub vs dub.
Except he never tells Tony not to blow the city. He merely says, "I'm not leaving this rock with one civilian on it." Which means he's not leaving. He'll save as many people as he can up until they all suffocate from lack of air and then Tony can blow the city.
Saying, "Hey, you should kill these thousands of people in order to say millions" would cause anybody to be obstinate and tell you no, they won't kill thousands.
edited 27th Jun '16 9:41:45 AM by alliterator
Yes, that's what Nat was suggesting. It was a middle-ground compromise to Cap's Perfect Solution Fallacy.
But it's not what Cap was saying. He chastises Stark for coming up with it, saying, "I asked for a solution, not an escape plan." Implying that Stark blowing up the makeshift meteor is not a solution to their predicament.
This exchange,
- Romanoff: Cap, these people are going nowhere. If Stark finds a way to blow this rock...
- Rogers: Not 'til everyone's safe.
has him further rejecting the suggestion of blowing up the meteor with even a single person still trapped on it. Cap makes it clear that he's not just opposed to escaping with his life intact; he does not acknowledge the idea of destroying the meteor as an acceptable course of action under any circumstances less than a 100% complete evacuation.
In essence, he's refusing to acknowledge time as a factor and instead demanding a perfect solution that makes it possible to ensure absolutely zero fatalities. Rather than being called out for how asinine this is, the narrative rewards him with Fury's deus ex machine.
edited 27th Jun '16 10:29:19 AM by TobiasDrake
My Tumblr. Currently side-by-side liveblogging Digimon Adventure, sub vs dub.![]()
Once Natasha comes up with the compromise though, Cap agrees with it. I think that's what you aren't getting — of course Cap says he wants a perfect solution at first. He wants to save everyone. Unfortunately, he can't, so he goes with Natasha in sacrificing themselves in saving however many they can.
That one bit of dialogue isn't the end of the conversation, you know.
edited 27th Jun '16 10:34:15 AM by alliterator
No, he doesn't. He's never given a chance to agree or disagree. Fury shows up immediately after she offers the compromise, preventing Cap from actually having to make a hard choice on the matter.
- Romanoff: I didn't say we should leave. There's worse ways to go. Where else am I gonna get a view like this?
- Fury: Glad you like the view, Romanoff. It's about to get better.
At no point does Cap compromise. That's kind of the point of his character. He's never agreed to a compromise. It's the same thing in Winter Soldier, when he declares that S.H.I.E.L.D. must be completely dismantled from the inside out. Nothing less than the extreme absolute is acceptable to him.
Cap demands that things be done his way or not at all. Always. The narrative has constantly treated this as a positive trait and rewarded it.
edited 27th Jun '16 10:39:41 AM by TobiasDrake
My Tumblr. Currently side-by-side liveblogging Digimon Adventure, sub vs dub.In regards to leaning optimistic, it goes both ways. Stark's optimism that the dangerous AI experiment will work THIS time wins out over Steve's distrust.
Forever liveblogging the AvengersBenedict Wong talks about Wong
.
“There isn’t any martial arts for Wong in Doctor Strange actually, he’s more of a drill sergeant to Kamar-Taj. He’s one of the masters of sorcery.”
That one kinda gets a Debate and Switch. Tony and Cap never actually get the chance to has out who's right or wrong because Thor jumps into the middle of things and the end result is explicitly stated to not be what Tony intended anyways, so the result is, "Nobody was really right but it worked out well enough in the end."
edited 27th Jun '16 10:41:00 AM by TobiasDrake
My Tumblr. Currently side-by-side liveblogging Digimon Adventure, sub vs dub.It is not in Cap's character to give up easily. He is too stubborn to do that. So he doesn't give up. He decides to stay and rescue as many people as he can even though it might be useless simply because that's what a hero does.
Plus, can you imagine the scene with Cap just shrugging and saying "Oh, Tony says there is no way out? Oh well....okay, people, we are done here, let's blow this pile of rock up and leave."
That's a False Dichotomy Strawman. Nobody was suggesting blowing the meteor right this second. Stark was reporting that he'd found a way to kill the meteor, and Cap was refusing to entertain the notion so long as a single person was still on it. No one said, "We should blow up the meteor right now, this very instant, and kill everyone on it."
Cap's extreme position was not taken in opposition to an equally extreme opposite position. He was the only one taking an absolute stance.
edited 27th Jun '16 11:37:31 AM by TobiasDrake
My Tumblr. Currently side-by-side liveblogging Digimon Adventure, sub vs dub.Again, his stance is "I'm not leaving this rock with one civilian on it." Which means that he wants to save all the civilians, but also that if he can't, he's not leaving. He's choosing the stay. He can't stop Tony from destroying the city, but he can stay there as save as many people as he can until they all die.
edited 27th Jun '16 11:46:12 AM by alliterator
That's not his stance, it's just something he said during the argument. He's also against the detonation. You're cherry-picking.
edited 27th Jun '16 11:54:44 AM by TobiasDrake
My Tumblr. Currently side-by-side liveblogging Digimon Adventure, sub vs dub.Glad to hear that they took that particular criticism into account for Wong, but I wonder what prompts him to follow Strange around. Is it to provide him with discipline once he becomes the Sorcerer Supreme because he's Strong, but Unskilled?

Yeah, really, how DARE Cap to end up in a situation in which he is forced to order the kill hundreds. And how DARE Whedon to actually do something great with Natasha in the movie by building up on The Winter Soldier and The Avengers, showing that Natasha is the voice of pragmatism, letting her lay out his shitty option for him, so that he has acknowledge that yes, he will have to order the destruction of the floating City. And how DARE them to add a moving moment in which two characters (one of them previously defined by her own survival instincts) decide that they will leave their ride off the floating rock to someone else, so that someone else can survive in their place.
There are a lot of problems in Age of Ultron. But this scene is certainly not one of them. It is, in fact, alongside with the hammer scenes, the wood chopping scene, the peep talk and naturally Vision's confrontation with Ultron one of the best moments in the whole movie.