Welcome to the main discussion thread for the Marvel Cinematic Universe! This pinned post is here to establish some basic guidelines. All of the Media Forum rules
still apply.
- This thread is for talking about the live-action films, TV shows, animated works, and related content that use the Marvel brand, currently owned by Disney.
- While mild digressions are okay, discussion of the comic books should go in this thread
. Extended digressions may be thumped as off-topic.
- Spoilers for new releases should not be discussed without spoiler tagging for at least two weeks. Rather, each title should have a dedicated thread where that sort of conversation is held. We can mention new releases in a general sense, but please be courteous to people who don't want to be spoiled.
If you're posting tagged spoilers, make sure that the film or series is clearly identified outside the spoiler tagging. People need to know what will be spoiled before they choose to read the post.
Edited by Mrph1 on Jul 29th 2024 at 3:09:00 PM
The MCU shines light on the actions of the heroes all the time (with the exception of Steve, who tends to be right by default, but that's a good thing...he is the moral compass). Taking down the helicarrier is portrayed as the right action, because there is so much more in stake (never mind that Steve goes and informs the people working on them about the Hydra threat before the attack). That is above all shown in Steve himself, who has to fight Bucky until the last microchip is inserted because the life of all the targets have to get rescued first, and only after he fulfilled his mission he allows Bucky to beat him up because at this point, it is only his own life on the line.
In Age of Ultron, there isn't a lot time to dwell on Tony's actions, but there is no doubt left that he acted rash and irresponsible. Even before he creates Ultron the movie clarifies that his actions wouldn't be approved by other avengers. I am actually more concerned that the movie never addresses Bruce's culpability in all this (aside from one throw-away line), but that's what it is. And Wanda...well, she gets the "heroic sacrifice which she survives" redemption. (Never mind that she pays a high price for what she did).
Ant-Man actually addresses the theme of morality, too. During the whole movie, Hank is pretty much portrayed as a hypocrite. A well-meaning one, but he is not the moral compass of the movie. Hope is. Hank is the guy who first lectures a thief about changing his ways and then sends him stealing. He is the guy who knows what is at stake if Cross sells this technology, and yet he isn't ready to brief the person who has the best chance to stop him, simply because he would rather allow the world to fall in chaos than loosing his daughter. It is not like his actions aren't understandable, but as much as Hank scoffs over Tony creating Ultron, he created his own monster, too, in Cross. He also doesn't really care. He has a bunch of ants which he uses however he pleases, but he only gives them numbers. Scott on the other hand gives them names and does care if they die or not. In my eyes, the movie doesn't portray Hank as a Myagi-like mentor figure. He is not meant to be one. He is meant to be the flawed mentor who delivers his knowledge to the next generation which hopefully will do better with it.
I mean, those ants are only gonna last a few months at best. Probably best not to name them.
I'm with you on the rest, though.
Maybe you'd be less disappointed if you stopped expecting things to be Carmen Sandiego movies.Yeah, I thought the fact that Hank numbered his ants instead of naming them was so he wouldn't get attached, considering how often they die. Which makes since considering he lost his wife and probably couldn't emotionally handle losing loyal pets on a constant basis.
edited 23rd Jul '15 12:30:16 PM by spashthebandragon
I've got fanfics for Frozen, Spectacular Spider-Man, Crash Bandicoot, and Spyro the Dragon.I totally agreed with Hank on not naming them. Like, maybe in special cases, sure. Scott had Ant-ony who was the one ant he always rides, but even Scott wasn't able to come up with an entire hive's worth of names.
I mean, it's just pragmatic. A colony has thousands, sometimes even millions of ants. I dare you to come up with 10 million individual names and remember which ant each one applies to.
A few key ants, maybe, but a whole colony? Who has time for that?
edited 23rd Jul '15 12:32:09 PM by TobiasDrake
My Tumblr. Currently side-by-side liveblogging Digimon Adventure, sub vs dub.Oh, on the subject of ants, I've been meaning to ask.
The swarm that rushes into the final battle on Cassie's toy table were all bullet ants, right? Or were there ants besides the four (Crazy, red, bullet, carpenter) that we're introduced to?
I wonder if getting bitten by that one that got super-sized would be even more painful than normal. Cassie better be careful with it.
You cannot firmly grasp the true form of Squidward's technique!Star Lord killing random people would not give him meaningful flaws. That would just be senseless dark and edgy. The meaningful flaws come from everyone's personality rather than their course of actions taken. Scale (amount of things accomplished) vs content (who the person is). Why they do it matters more. Motivations, wants, and needs that all conflict with each other. Anyway if you make how more extreme it would lessen the idealism this verse thrives on
edited 23rd Jul '15 12:36:20 PM by xbimpy
It's always weird for me to see Ant-Man get so attached to his ants when he's basically hijacking their nervous system and forcing them to do what he wants. If ants have any capacity to feel terror, they must be terrified every time he controls them.
Scott: "Come on, Ant-tony, let's go fight some bad guys! Wheeeee!"
Ant-tony: "Oh god what's happening to my body someone heeeeeeeeeeeeelp!"
edited 23rd Jul '15 12:38:38 PM by spashthebandragon
I've got fanfics for Frozen, Spectacular Spider-Man, Crash Bandicoot, and Spyro the Dragon.They're drones. Functioning as an extension of someone else's body is what they exist to do.
Ant-Man is basically the hive queen.
edited 23rd Jul '15 12:44:37 PM by TobiasDrake
My Tumblr. Currently side-by-side liveblogging Digimon Adventure, sub vs dub.![]()
He isn't hijacking their nervous systems, he's communicating with them via signals.
As for why they obey his commands, the implication is that he's using the same communication method other ants use to relay orders and objectives (i.e. "Go over there, we found food"). It's not entirely accurate, ants are more individualistic than that and certainly couldn't comprehend complex orders, but that's how the movie works.
![]()
edited 23rd Jul '15 12:44:56 PM by Anomalocaris20
You cannot firmly grasp the true form of Squidward's technique!Pym actually mentions in the movie that ants can't pull off complex orders without someone in the field.
Forever liveblogging the AvengersThe opening conflict is just "Avengers versus Hydra". The fall of SHIELD is recapped few times in the film, enough that many of my friends who hadn't seen Winter Soldier understood it fine.
I mean, yeah, the heroes all have flaws. But they're flaws that don't actually prevent them from being heroic as far as the narrative is concerned. Got G is a good example. We never see Rocket or Star-Lord do anything really unsympathetic, like, say, killing a guy in cold blood or something.
Yeah, I don't think "killing a guy in cold blood" is the type of flaw I'm talking about. But we do see Drax nearly kill Gamora. And then Drax and Rocket get drunk and get into a fight on Knowhere. And then Drax drunk dials Ronan, which basically means that Drax is the reason he gets the Infinity Stone in the first place.
Oh yeah, the Guardians of the Galaxy have a ton of flaws. In fact, Drax fully realizes his flaws...and then continues with them anyway at the end of the movie! He says that he chooses to mask his grief with anger and apologizes to Rocket and Groot...and then at the end of the movie, he says that Ronan was just a pawn of Thanos and that it's Thanos he needs to kill (getting a sigh from Gamora). Because he's still using anger to cover his grief.
Rocket has flaws from thinking everyone else is mocking him; Star-Lord has emotional issues concerning intimacy (stemming from the fact that he couldn't hold his mother's hand while she died). The only ones really presented without flaws are Gamora (she was already trying to do the right thing) and Groot (he is always awesome).
![]()
Okay, I think this debate's drifting a little too far from the actual point. When I say "flaws," I mean flaws that actually make them unlikable. This all started because people were complaining Hank Pym is a bad person or something.
edited 23rd Jul '15 1:50:07 PM by spashthebandragon
I've got fanfics for Frozen, Spectacular Spider-Man, Crash Bandicoot, and Spyro the Dragon.![]()
So your problem is that nobody is completely and utterly unlikable?
...huh? I mean, yeah, I understand that. None of the heroes are unlikable. You like them, flaws and all, even when they make mistakes and screw up. But that's...sort of the point. They are flawed people, but not irredeemable.
I mean, I'm pretty sure none of the main characters in Suicide Squad are going to be unlikable either. We are going to like them, even if they are darker than the Marvel characters. (I'm not talking about the Joker here, because he's not one of the protagonist. He is, clearly, an antagonist.) I mean, we even see Deadshot hugging his daughter. He's clearly likable even though he's an anti-hero.
So I'm not sure what the complaint here is actually.
edited 23rd Jul '15 1:56:24 PM by alliterator
Here, just let me go get my old post for you:
Captain America jumped on a grenade. That was the writers' way of showing the audience that Cap is Incorruptible Pure Pureness who will be a good guy forever. Darren Cross turned people into goo at the slightest provocation. That's the writers' way of showing he's a Card-Carrying Villain who wakes up every morning and puts evil cream in his evil coffee while he plots how to destroy the world.
Now, is this dynamic a bad thing? No. I actually think it's incredibly entertaining, like Marvel decided to film a bunch of super high quality Saturday morning cartoons. But it doesn't lend itself to a great deal of character depth. A MCU movie's never, ever, ever going to make me think or change my greater perspective on the world. And on the rare occassion that the movie tries to make me think like Age of Ultron did, it just turns into a trainwreck since there's not enough time for an adequate discussion of the worth of humanity in a movie about superheroes bashing in an army of robots.
MCU movies are the potato chips of cinema. And, again, that's not a bad thing, but it makes these arguments about whether Hank Pym is a good or a bad guy really, really tedious. Yes, Hank Pym is a good guy, end of story. Unless the writers ever decide to have him kill an innocent puppy or something, in which case, then he'll be a bad guy.
Heck, I wouldn't bat an eyelash if Civil War ends with Tony realizing he's wrong, and then he high-fives Cap so they can team up for Infinity War, because Robert Downy Jr just makes way too much money to not be in that movie, so he obviously can't do anything that evil in Civil War.
(Also, note that I specified movies. The Daredevil TV show got pretty darn morally ambiguous. But what works for a Daredevil TV show doesn't necessarily work for Ant-Man or any other hugely popular mainstream Marvel movie.)
edited 23rd Jul '15 2:02:54 PM by spashthebandragon
I've got fanfics for Frozen, Spectacular Spider-Man, Crash Bandicoot, and Spyro the Dragon.Right, but you seem to be changing the goal posts now. That post was about "moral ambiguity."
"There's no such thing as moral ambiguity in the MCU movies."
When I went and refuted that and provided some examples, you changed it to "unsympathetic" and when I provided examples of that you said "unlikable."
Let me put it a different way: moral ambiguity does not equal unlikable.
For instance: it's clear that Matt Murdock being Daredevil is morally ambiguous. But he still remains completely likable.
edited 23rd Jul '15 2:06:15 PM by alliterator

Ronan is seen bathing in cold blood and later they kill him, does that count?
edited 23rd Jul '15 12:26:37 PM by Anomalocaris20
You cannot firmly grasp the true form of Squidward's technique!