Welcome to the main discussion thread for the Marvel Cinematic Universe! This pinned post is here to establish some basic guidelines. All of the Media Forum rules
still apply.
- This thread is for talking about the live-action films, TV shows, animated works, and related content that use the Marvel brand, currently owned by Disney.
- While mild digressions are okay, discussion of the comic books should go in this thread
. Extended digressions may be thumped as off-topic.
- Spoilers for new releases should not be discussed without spoiler tagging for at least two weeks. Rather, each title should have a dedicated thread where that sort of conversation is held. We can mention new releases in a general sense, but please be courteous to people who don't want to be spoiled.
If you're posting tagged spoilers, make sure that the film or series is clearly identified outside the spoiler tagging. People need to know what will be spoiled before they choose to read the post.
Edited by Mrph1 on Jul 29th 2024 at 3:09:00 PM
Honestly, there's gotta be more effective ways of fixing problematic or stereotypical parts rather than just making them into white people.
I was more fine with the Mandarin because they at least managed to have some fun commentary on the nature of Yellow Peril caricatures in general, but somehow I doubt Doctor Strange is going to be that clever with it.
edited 15th Jul '15 3:07:49 PM by comicwriter
It's kind of a damned if you do, damned if you don't.
The Ancient One is kind of an Asian Stereoptype in that he's a mystical old grandmaster, and they'd catch Hell for leaving him as-is.
But he's also a minority, so they'd catch Hell for making him an old white dude.
My various fanfics.Considering the great job Uncharted 2 did, and Far Cry 4's ability to portray Himalayan culture with some sort of respect, there's at least some increasing awareness of the area that surely it wouldn't have been too hard for Marvel to reinvent the character in a way that's a lot more realistic and respectful while staying true to his roots.
Nobody's been saying anything of that sort. Stop before you dig yourself into the Everything Is Racist (Against White People) hole.
edited 15th Jul '15 3:25:19 PM by AlleyOop
i understand what people mean about the unfortunate stereotype thing, but i think it's important to keep in mind that the idea of a spiritually enlightened old sage or w/e exists in a lot of asian cultures too. as long as the character was actually you know, tibetan, it wouldn't really have been particularly disrespectful.
edited 15th Jul '15 3:24:52 PM by wehrmacht
x5 Yeah, it really is a tricky situation.
I think making it an asian woman would have been good, though. As long as they wrote her well, and didn't make the actress put on a terrible accent, it would have been mostly fine.
They're gonna run into the same issue with Danny Rand, too. And I'm interested to see how they handle that.
edited 15th Jul '15 3:25:05 PM by Mukora
"It's so hard to be humble, knowing how great I am."Yeah, that's an utter bollocks framing of the argument, and you know it. It's not "More women! No not that kind!" It's pointing out that yeah we should be getting more women and minority parts in the MCU but not at expense of the other.
But that doesn't make for as cute a strawman, I guess.
edited 15th Jul '15 3:29:37 PM by comicwriter
There's no good answer to Danny Rand.
Either they play him straight as a Mighty Whitey figure or they recast him as an Asian man, ignoring a perfectly good Asian character that could be used for exactly that role.
My Tumblr. Currently side-by-side liveblogging Digimon Adventure, sub vs dub.What about Latino, Middle Eastern, or mixed race in general? I'd be personally happy with an ABC Rand, but those other options will sidestep both issues while also being a more accurate reflection of the current demographics of New York City.
edited 15th Jul '15 3:40:03 PM by AlleyOop
Either they play him straight as a Mighty Whitey figure or they recast him as an Asian man, ignoring a perfectly good Asian character that could be used for exactly that role.
Wait, what "perfectly good Asian character"? You mean Shang-Chi? Because Danny Rand and Shang Chi are vastly different characters.
I don't think making Danny Rand Asian-American has any unfortunate implications.
I'd like if they just did Shang-Chi but that's probably not gonna happen...
Well I think they were pointing out in that they're both street level martial arts-based superheroes.
But honestly I feel like this bit, you could make Asian Danny Rand work. Just make sure to hammer home that he's a thoroughly modern, westernized kid so the culture shock of going to K'un Lun is still there.
edited 15th Jul '15 3:40:43 PM by comicwriter
![]()
![]()
The big issue is he's supposed a very visible outsider with respect to his adopted home of K'un-Lun, which wouldn't be as obvious with an Asian actor who at least superficially resembles all the other inhabitants of K'un-Lun. While there's a lot of Applicability left if you make him Asian, The fact that he's a different race from the locals is an important part of his character from conception. There's also the All Asians Know Martial Arts stereotype, or at least the idea that the only Asian action stars are kung fu masters.
On a side note I'd really like Jimmy Woo to show up in the MCU. He's not particularly stereotypical and would fit well into AOS or one of the other TV shows.
edited 15th Jul '15 3:46:50 PM by AlleyOop
Regarding skipping Doctor Strange due to gripes over the casting:
The movie doesn't even come out for 16 months, and the only info we have is who's playing who for three characters, who's directing, who wrote it, and what the source material is. We still don't know the story or any characters aside from Strange, Mordo, and the Ancient One. They haven't even started filming yet. So maybe you should wait for more information before you make a decision. There's plenty of time to do so.
Make mine Marvel.The bitter
dubsmash war
between
Agent
Carter
and
Agents of
SHIELD.
A lot of links, but the end is so worth it.
![]()
![]()
I'm saying it's much too early to say you don't like casting choices. Heath Ledger, Michael Keaton and Ben Affleck were all widely-hated choices when they were announced as the Joker, Batman, and Batman respectively, but Ledger and Keaton proved the haters wrong and the consensus on Batfleck did a 180. I know this isn't exactly the same thing, but I still think it's myopic.

The Ancient One is supposed to be Tibetian, which Tilda Swinton clearly isn't. Yet another example of whitewashing.