![]()
I actually don't count that other way.
There's zero need to go Fanon Discontinuity when the game retconned it's own events.
Plus, many fans were dicks about it. And like, it's saying something when you have legitimate cause to hate a game and still manage to go overboard about it.
.....and you know what? I shouldn't have mentioned 06. I should know better. I'm gonna end this before things get out of hand like they always do. I'm 100% serious about this.
.....Mephiles is the greatest villain ever.
Edited by HandsomeRob on Apr 13th 2023 at 1:34:35 AM
One Strip! One Strip!Maybe now when people think 'Sonic was killed' they'll think of The Murder of Sonic the Hedgehog first.
The Protomen enhanced my life.Speaking of Surge and Kit, people have brought up the hilarious mental image of them ending up getting the redemptions they honestly deserve from Cream, who's wholesome, innocent, and fully capable of kicking ass as needed.
Judging by Starline's logs, whoever Surge was before her current personality held on for a long time against his brainwashing.
I was legitimately hyped when Robotnik became Mr. Tinker and how that introduced Belle.
I'm probably one of the few who really, really wished Mr. Tinker lasted longer, or the very least gave Robotnik a major break from his usual villainy. It was pretty disappointing how fast and easy he turned back, basically killing off that particular personality.
EDIT: oooh I just realized, perhaps Mr. Tinker was used as a means of foreshadowing Surge and Kit?
Edited by Tony-Sharx on Apr 13th 2023 at 3:23:35 AM
Certified, self-appointed Sonic VisionaryI feel like the IDW comic is in more need of recurring villains than more redeemed former villains. Though Surge and Kit's theoretical redemption could be really simple considering how paper thin their motivations are. Moreover, I'm curious what Surge is like when she's not thinking about Sonic, and Kit when he's not thinking about Surge.
Like, if you boot Surge over to Silver's future where there is literally no sonic for her to hate, and don't give her means to get back, does she occupy herself with something else once she's exhausted trying to get back?
Edit: I wouldn't mind a scenario where Eggman is faced with a scenario where he has reason to revert to Mr Tinker for a time. It would be curious to see what Mr Tinker makes of it, who never really got to come to terms with him being Eggman. Would be nice for Belle too.
Edited by Whowho on Apr 13th 2023 at 11:27:54 AM
![]()
Surge would literally just terrorize and destroy everything and everyone around her.
Her sole purpose is ruining Sonic's life and everything that ruined hers.
Even if Sonic was somehow removed from her life, she wouldn't be satisfied because Starline didn't make her with any purpose beyond killing Sonic. And given how mentally unstable she already is, she basically admitted she'd just kill everyone.
She's basically Shadow without a moral compass dictating his actions.
Edited by BlackYakuzu94 on Apr 13th 2023 at 6:50:55 AM
A lazy millennial who's good at what he does.I think the worst part about Mr. Tinker is when Belle finds a letter he hid in a Moto-bug when Starline was first trying to change him back. He wrote it because he had come to believe he was Eggman based on the evidence, and he apparently suspected that he would change back at some point (and I think word of god confirmed Tinkerer was slowly starting to revert, with Metal Sonic just being the last straw, but I may have misheard that).
It's depressing.
One Strip! One Strip!They kind of shot themselves in the foot with Tinkerer imo. Because having him around basically means no Eggman for an extended period of time.
Which makes the Big Bad spot would have to be occupied by someone else in the meantime.
A lazy millennial who's good at what he does.It probably would've felt like a cheap move, but it would've been cool if - like - Tinker had made an AI of himself or something so he could stay around for a while, while still making it explicit that the real Tinker is dead and gone.
Overall, it had the same energy as all the same "let's do something crazy and reform one of the main villains for a while... oops everyone likes the reformed version, welp too bad it can't stick around" energy you get all the time with Batman.
Edited by KnownUnknown on Apr 13th 2023 at 7:42:38 AM
I keep seeing this sentiment but other than Silver, Knuckles and Shadow, this isn't that much of a thing in the Sonic franchise. Hell, Silver and Knuckles were Nominal Villains at worst.
The main point is that Sonic doesn't much of a Rogues Gallery. There's Eggman and the D6 as of late, but that's about it as far as the games are concerned.
The comics added Rough and Tumble (Henchman, as per Flynn), Starline, Mimic (more personal enemy for Whisper), Clutch, Surge and Kit.
A lazy millennial who's good at what he does.![]()
Rogue and Omega also debatably come under that category, Gemerald definitely does, and Blaze is - I actually don't remember what the context is over their fights in Blaze's introduction, so maybe not Blaze.
Edit: trying to rack my head for former game villains who could return as villains, but the games are usually Eggman enraging forces of nature.
Edited by Whowho on Apr 14th 2023 at 5:27:30 PM
I presume he was talking about villains in the Archie comics...because that sentiment didn't really make any sense referring to the games.
Also any other villain in the series usually just gets "Keelhauled" off and doesn't ever come back.
Rules of the Internet 45. Rule 45 is a lie. Check out my art if you notice.Speaking of "Keelhauled", there's Captain Whisker, Johnny, and Dr. Eggman Nega (however you want to name him, he's technically still an Eggman, that's what he am...)
- Whisker: Presumed dead/not functional in Blaze's dimension in game canon, presumed retired in Blaze's dimension in comic canon
- Johnny: At large in Blaze's dimension in game canon, presumed retired in Blaze's dimension in comic canon
- Dr. Nega(tive): At large in Blaze's dimension
There's also Infinite (at large, nerfed if not fully depowered). And THE END, but the latter should be used very sparingly as a colossal threat.

Was just made known to me that none of the Sonic games are rated T for Teen, in spite of how some games are darker than others. Is that true?
Edited by electricmastro on Apr 13th 2023 at 4:34:12 AM